Dhanpati Devi And ORS. v. D H B V N Ltd. And ORS.

 


  


 



.//01 2

 


#    











;  
!"#$% !"#$%

+,$!-#   

   

# #&# /./.3

&$'$(')#*#'"././.3 #-$'.././.3

 
      
  
   
    

    
 
4 
! ,
# "


 

5!
 6,
# "


  
 
  
   


  

 
! "
# 

 " 
 

$ % % 

 "
 
&&&''(
 
)*

  
"
+ ,
,
-   )*

 
    
)*

  
-
  *
 - 


$ % 

 "
 
& &.'&''/
 
)*

  
1 
+
7! 
  8,


- 
% % 

0
# 
1
 " 

"%  


1
%
₹','','''9:
 
₹<,'&,/&=9:,
 
-
   - 
)*
 




23
 
%

 ,


 
)*


 "
 






 " *

₹','

 " 
% '','''9:,

" 

1 
)*
-*


   

 
! "
#  



 !

"# $ &

 
"


"



%
-,

!):4 "



*
 "

,
-



 
 



"" 

 
 
- 
1-6,
,
-"
-

) )
  

'.'<&'''
>
'('<&''',
- 
 % 
- 
) 
% %


 ,
 ,
- 


 )
,
- 


 
 



 % 

"%

" "
-


""
-
 
 

,
  



"" 
>
 

" ,
%
-
 % 

 "
%
)
-
% 
"" 

-
 % 
 

1 
 ,
- 

-
 "  
  ?


 
 

  
   
%

'='22=
)*

 
- 


 % 

 


 @
" 

 %) 
 22=

 % 


 : 
- ,

 
- 
6  
)*

""*
 % 
#
04
 
! "

"
?'<:#
41
-
    

'?'/&'''

  "
!
1*,
,
 

 
"
 - 
<
4
-
  


 "   
-


) - 

 

₹2,?/9:
 
%
#

% *,


"
 
&'&&'''
" % % 
₹/,'','''9:
-
  
 "% 
 

  

/
A 
 
 

 ,

" 

-
 
  


₹','','''9:
)*
0
#""  
#",
=//
 6
"% 
 ,
- "
-
 " 

 
 

$ % 

 "
  
&.'&''/
  
)*

 
1 
+ 7! 
 8,
,
-  
₹','','''9:
 
-
  "% 
 




23
 
% (
#

 
  )*,

   
   

  ,
-"
-
 *
 - 
)*

 
"
+ ,



$ % 

 "
  

&&&''(
* *


$ % ,

"% 
- 
)*


1


 " 

₹<,'&,/&=9:,
- -
% 

%



   

23
 
% 
.


 ,
) 
  
-

   "
%
)*

0
# 
1


@%

"% % ,

 

  

 
! " 
#  

#%&

  '$($! # $' ( )$"( $ =
  
"
 


 
" 


 
"


+

"%% 

% 


  %

@ %

"%  
*)


" %
  

0
#"" 
#"
4 4

  


0
# 
1
- * *
 " 
%
%


₹2,(/9:,

  % 

% *
 * *


 "  ,
  

 
"%

₹/,/ /2'9:
 
%
!"
 " ,
""


 
"  ,

"*


  
" 
 
-

 % 

"%  2
4

 
"  
,

 
) "

*
 ""
 *
% 
  

0
#"" 
#"

"%

"% ,

"

 @  

)
 
)*

"

" 


  % 

"% 

%
"" 
" %
"  
"


 

) ) 
 " 

 
$ % 


1

4!

!'5!,67"4!(&"!"#$% ('6 6!89 *+,-./+"'( 01-  

-
 
,

 
) "

*
   ,

" 
  ")

%
" 
""

" 
" %
%*
)
 *
   

-
$ 
"% 
>
 
 % % ,
 
"
)%


 "
 " 
)*

0
# 
1 

)


  

 
! " 
# 
   

)
 -  
'
 
",
 
"


  
)%


 
 
 "  
)*

0
# 
1

) 




 "
 

 "

 "

   

" 
4

"   


"%  

) 
" " *
   



  * *

 *

 " )



-
    "
)*

1

B "
 

$"
  
! "
''


1

1 1 
"  

4

 
 
"
 

 

 

  "  *
  

 "
-
 
)
 "  '

  )$($ (! &
#
 


 "
  
 







 


 "  
"" 


"" 

 

""   *
)  
 


"" 
-

  "
  

""
4
 
*

₹','','''9:
 

0 
% 


" 


 " 0
#"" 
#"
-
 
)*

  

-
 " 

 





$ % 

 "
 
&.'&''/
 
)*

 
1 
+  7! 
  8,

?
4
 
 


   
   

 
 


$ % % ,
-"
-
 *
 - 
) )*

 
"
+ ,




$ %  

 "
 
&&&''

'(,
-  )*

"%  

₹','','''9:
 
-
  



 
23
 
%
-
% 

 " 

₹<,'

'&,/&=9:,
-
%

 %


  
<

- ,

1



 
0
# 
1


 
 
-
 

% *
 "%


 "  
#
  

 *
" " 
CB)
:<,


%  *
 *


 "  
-
₹2,(/9:

 
# 
1,
-

,
  

% *
"%

₹/,/2'9:
)*
 "
%
-


 
,
 

 " 
!"
 " 

 *
% %) ,

 
"% 


%


 "
  "

  %

 

   "*

/





 


  
D)

! %
1 ,

)      %2 *! /  '( 2 &2 3  "

 1 +,+0

'



-- ,4,

" " *
 

 *
%
 "  )

"" 

  
 ,
 

"
"
) )
 " 
%

 *

 
 "  




  %
 "%




- -
"%
"% % 

 
B "


%

 "  

 :
) ! *

    

    



  





  

 

  

     

 





       



 
  

  



 
 




 


 

        
 



     

  



 


    


  

  



  
  
   



   
   



   

  
   



   



   


    



 
 



  
   
      
 

 

   
 !""

+   

 

     
  

 :

;

<22:

 !

<2*+,-=/7

> >74

    # 

  

   
 

)   2 ( 5 2&   (

*-6 666/-

6,    

, -

! $  

 

 
  

   # 

)  2(5 2&    (

?*-666/-

6,@- -666

*  /-678 *   


  #       

  


  

   


%


  

& &   
 


    


 



  

    

  '  

 

  
    

   
 

       

     

 




 

  (
  




      





 

 

 



 


   

  
 $ 

          



 # , .(##  - 6  /07

/ /0 1    &    
       




    

 

  

   

        
  (
       





 
    


   

 

  

$   

 



 

 
  

   

  

 

 

  
  

 
 

    

        2 

  
   % 



 (

  

  

  

    

 

 

   



    
 

 

  

    



 

 



          

$    
  

  

      

  

   3
- 

  

 (

 




 





   

 

      

  

 



 
 
  

  
 


 

  

      *

 
 

 

 





 

       

    * 
   



 

        

  

  
     

    

 
 

 



     

    

 

 

     

 

'   4 

      
 


  

 
 
 
      (

  


%


  &  


  






   
 



      

  '  



   
-       
 

      




     

  


 

  
  
  

 
        

 

 



   '
   '

  
 5   %

   
 

   



  

   

   &

  

      
  



 


  
-

 $

 .  
 7

  

        
  
     




  
-  
  
    

       
  


   

     

   
 

 
    

  

 

 

      %  
 

  





 
        
  
 

   

 

 
     
 

  

 

   
 $      
   



  

        
  

 



 

 

      

   
 

  

 


 



 




$    # 
 




     
 

  




  8+   

 



 
 





            


 





  

 
   $   






 

(

A     2'22    < 2*+,-4/6

4+7  

    

' 22 %

<2*+,+,/--

= =04;

(
4 
 -


  

 ,

% *
"%


)

)
  

₹2,(/9:
 "  

) .
4

 
 


  
"


1

"

    :

  2 " 5  1*+,,./>( (*

 /77+,

 *
 

- 
 "





   
)
"

" 

)  

 
*
% "%
B

  %
 
"% 
 

" "*
-,

" 
   % 

"% 
 



" 
#",
2==
"
)
  


 
B B"


%

 " 

 :
) "      



 
    



  %           1 



   
    

      



    ( 9 :  
   

  
  

  

 






 ( 
 

   

 
  



       < 
 
      

= =  
 

 
     





 

   
   

  #      

 

 

  




  

 

  
 !""



          
  

            =   =





) 
    
)*

1
"


1

:

;

;

 :

 2  " 51*+,-./+"'(0,
-  

-
 

 :
)" ( 
 *   
      

     =   



 
    



  

 * 

  





      
    #  


%

    
    
 

    

 
  

  $ 

  

   
 

   6"

    

  : >???-   



 

   


  


 

 % 

    
  
    

  


 

   


  @ :  ????-       


  
 1⁄3  

   

  & 




   

   

 

:

: "????- .:>>>>>& 67 



     

  B

   
 6"

     


    


  : />????- $   

 
 

  


  

   

  

   

   @ >A       

     


 


 2      

 

       
 
 
    

2
4 
 -


)
"


  

,

1
"  

  

"% 
 *)


 
)*
 * * 
" 


  %

"%  
 


 " 
#"

22 ) 

  ;

    *
4"%

2(/9:
& 
 "
E
?'3

&./'9:
7?'3

2(/8 ?

?2.&9:
72/F
9?8 "
-
 
B 
9?
<


4"%

.2<?9:72/:?2.&8 <     
?

/ # #
   "*
?8

&,?2,'=9:
7.2<?.F&F (  

C

=,/'9:

.

 
CB  

=,/'9:

=  

1%

,</,&''9:




<=,<''9:B !  


<=,<''9:B&  $"!,$*+#' !"7$'

 9./93/ : &'

A A
  % 


  "

)*
 *

   
" 


  %

"%  

%
"" 
"

%
 
-6


₹<,&',('

" ,


"% 
*)


 '=9:

- ,


 





  

 " 
 
" % %


₹','','''9:
 


1 @  *,

 
"
)
 

% 

B" 


  
" % 

  
 " 
  
&
#"

"" *,

 

  
 

"% 
 
B 

₹','

'','''9:,
 
-
  

 


23
 
%,

-  
)*


1 
&&

4 
 -


 
 "

 
 "  
  ) ,
 
  

 
! "
#  

;

$ % 

 "
 
& &&&''(
 
)*

 
"
+ ,
,


  )* *
 
 ,


$ $ % 

 "
 
&. '&''/
 
)*

 
1 1 
+
7! 
 8,
,

% 
 
" 

 
)*

  

 " 
&?
  



) 
 
-
" 
 "
 
)
  
././.3 G
#

1   
 2   H  
 6 9   H  
 )


I 


I