High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15292/2015disposed of

Deepak Kumar v. Pgimer Chandigarh & ANR

2016-01-07Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain5 pages

!"#"$%&%'()*

( +,

- -,

."&"'!(

. /%0 . &1 #2#0$ !".!1"3"!%!%'".

&45 1 !. !12#0$ !".!1"."&3'#"'!&

/"&1%'# 4 1"3"!%!%'".1 & 33. $1"#!1%&$6.!22%7368'%'8 %$".#".# !"#*23 &&"#9:!1"."&3'#"'!&2;1"."9: #7%&&%' !1"3"!%!%'".%'

%$.9%48:1 &9""'$ '$"44"# ," .'"#$6'&"4.!1"3"!%!%'".&697%!!"#!1 !!1"3"!%!%'". !".$734"!%'81%& -.7 8 #1 "#%$ 444"8" 334%"#.

#7%&&%'! $6.&"%' &!. #6 !"'&!%!6!" "#%$ 4#6$ !%'

"&" .$121 '#%8 .1 .&1.!2+ +%'!1"&"&&%'$77"'$%'8%'

'6 .:2'!1""'!. '$"!"&!2!1"3"!%!%'".; &. '5"# !*<%' !1"7".%!4%&!"9"%'8 $ '#%# !"9"4'8%'8! $ !"8.:2%'!".7& 1%&7".%!2; &8. '!"# #7%&&%'%'

%$.9%48:"#"3&%!"#!1"

."=6%&%!""" '#; &36.&%'81%&$6.&" &!1"9. '$1%';1%$1!1" 3"!%!%'".8! #7%&&%'; &'!1%&4%5%'821" 334%"#. 33" . '$"%' !1""'!. '$"!"&!'!%%"#.!1"&"&&%'64:2;"0".2'!%$%'8!1" $!!1 !!1"3"!%!%'".; &'!"4%8%94"!8"! #7%&&%''$"1"; & 4." #: 36.&6%'8!1"$6.&"2#"&3%!"!1" $!!1 !1"1 #9""'%&&6"#!1"."=6%&%!"

#7%!$ .#. 33" . '$"%'!1""'!. '$"!"&!21"#%#'! 33" .%'!1"& 7" ' ;.'8%'.7 !%'6.'%&1"#9:!1" 6!1.%!%"&!!1"77%!!"" $'$".'"#!1 !!1"3"!%!%'".9:$'$" 4%'8!1" $!1 # 33" ."#%'!1" $73"!%!%0""> 7%' !%'. #7%&&%'%'64:2&"&&%'2$ '$"44"#1%& #7%&&%'%'

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

'4:2 &1"7 :9" &!6#"'!%'!1".%'&!%!6!" &;"44

;%44'!1 0"!1"/6.%&#%$!%'!$ '$"41%& #7%&&%'%'!1".%'&!%!6!" ," .'"#$6'&"46.!1".&697%!!"#!1 !!1681!1"3.0%&%'&%' !1" 3.&3"$!6& #%# '! 3.0%#" !1 ! %' $ &" #7%&&%' &!6#"'! %& $ '$"44"#9: 2!1"&!6#"'!%&4% 94"!3 : 3"' 4!:'!1"$ &"%' 1 '#2!1"3"!%!%'".1 #'!4"!1%7&"4046'! .%4:2. !1".21%& #7%&&%' ; &$ '$"44"#9:!1" 6!1.%!%"&21"'$"21"$64#'!9"#%."$!"#!3 :!1" 3"' 4!:"6.!1".&697%!!"#!1 !9"&%#"&! 5%'8 ."& %#!; $!%'&2

6!1.%!%"& 1 # "0"' ;.%!!"' ! %1 . 6'$%4 "#%$ 4

"8%&!. !%'2 !' !! 5" $!%' 8 %'&!!1"3"!%!%'".' $!2!1"".!%& !&3%4!1""'!%."$ ."".!1"3"!%!%'"..7%'.%' #0".!"'!7%&! 5" ' !1" !1". 1 '#2 4" .'"# $6'&"4 . !1" ."&3'#"'!& &697%!!"# !1 ! !1" 3"!%!%'". 1 0%'8 9""' &6$$"&&64 %' !1" "'!. '$" "> 7%' !%'; & #7%!!"#%'

%$.9%48:%' '6 .:2&"&&%' "/%'"# &6'%. "&" .$1 "44;'@1"3.&3"$!6&.

#7%&&%'%'&"&&%'64:2; &%&&6"#&3".!1"$'#%!%'4 %##;' %'!1"3.&3"$!6&2 $ '#%# !";11 # 4." #:#'".; &#%'8 A - %' ': &69/"$! ! !1" !%7" 334:%'82 ; & '! "4%8%94" ! 334: .

#7%&&%'! A -$6.&"&3"!%!%'".1 #7%&?&! !"#!1" $!&%'!1" 334%$ !%'2"0"' #7%&&%'$ .#; &%&&6"#!1%7"; &&!33"# !!1" "'!. '$"!1""> 7%' !%'$"'!."9:!1"'0%8%4 !.."$8'%B%'81%7!9" &!6#"'!%' '$"!1"$'#%!%'&4 %##;'%'!1"3.&3"$!6&;"." =6%!"">34%$%!2!1"."%&'"...%'!1".#".3 &&"#9:!1" 6!1.%!%"&%' $ '$"44%'8 #7%&&%'!1"3"!%!%'". " .#4" .'"#$6'&"4.!1"3 .!%"& '#3".6&"#!1"3 3". 95

!"#$%&"' "('')*' # +'

, "('#-.!

.!(#

+!"#$%& / +0++ 0"

' " !"1 ((!

!" (!

+!'+

( 23!

! 445+0!

! ((#

6' !

+ '

( , "('#-.!

+(("#$%&0

!' 7

* +( !

296

$%& (!

!! .!(#

/ : "(+;

<:::::: =+0( # ' 23 #!"1

(#'(("

23 !

! !

' 0 0 ( ''0+ '

2 ' +(("((+!# >

? :::::: @ !( + +0( # ' 23#!"1

(((" 23 !

0 !

'0 ( '+

!'0+ '

2 ' +(("((/

(

" ( #

+ !

' 23!

(("# !

+ '

"(' ("(" (( ' "# +'+(

0: +

!" ! (#.!(#

(A"!((

+' ( (( '

+ #0( #'

( 23 !

!' !

$%&/ "+ #" !

!' !

!/ (( (#

+ +'

((!

+ !

!' !

"! ((# !

/ A "" (+!(((( + ( #'.!

! #+( #0 ' ((

, "('#-!

!(A $%&+!( !(+' 9!(

( !+ # !("

+ 5 # ((

, "('#-!

!' 7

"('((#! / "

! , "('#-

@ # B! 0

B! 8

29"#

( !

"+(( (('(

! ! +

1!'#!

/+ '(# ,&1*(- .!' 8

"".! "3.!".