Kabal Singh v. Gmada And ANR
! "
#$ %&' (!)*+ ",&(-. "
/ 0(1(23,*!2(3(23,
*5* (&,((675,-.&,((8(,
*68*
*+ & (9(:(.8)(.!,6 & ;
2,(7(.28)(<, &* 2,(2,(7(.8)(.!,*68* ===== + ,6*9*(<!)(>5(*,(88(8
# 6(**8 1- *68 ?*( !!) ! , !* *68:)3,6@*(66)(86*,(75 *6)!(*8(6(8,7
, -( "
. , *68* !(8 ( *),7 ! (7!*8(6*&,( ,6(668!(6 58,)(3-*8!)7*
.,6 6(8(*57! * B. "."""C?<(8*(*7- ,(8(668,
5:(12(6((9!((6(-,1(()(75 , 6)8*,(,1(9<3-78,*!(,@*(7(* &(3(23,*(8!2(3(23, ,*)(5*8(8(-**5()! ,DE!@$E '
6,***513)(8.,*68*
**58(E !,(7!(6(87(*53 ""*> -(8*58 , )7C* )7 )(3- , E )88 ,( , 6<(**5))**!5,8(<!*(8,(,!**68 88 (3 , 6 ,7 *51:) , )8* 78 , (5**/.A(8 ",!(8(*58+? F/ $'5<>5886*(*57! * .B".""""
""$ (9, -' 13 #"G 1- , &(),. "
<3 8*)6()* 8)57* *5178 1- -5 E )58 **58 1- , 8( !H8 ( < -5 ( >58 86* , (75 <, G 6(- <, #" 8(-* !7 , &(),. "
(- 56 /" 8(-* 7(- 1 )88<,#G6(-(856B"8(-*<, G6(-6 <>5* $'
1(()6(-7!/ GI
(? *57 ! * / .A ."""
"" $2H- (9, *- ! ,5*(8-'131(()/ G!,(6))(16(8J
G * / ,(! -(- *(7* !7 , 8( ! , **5 ! E (-7*),8578(*58+?
!"#$%&'!# !"#$%%&'!#($#'
) !* +$% $& ,!# !#')'"# #$%$& ,!#
"A?? "
" B /A "" #A" ""
""
#BB//A ""
"A?&(-? "
#
" B /A "" #A A "
""
##AB "" # # "A?? "
#
" B /A "" KA"""
""
A/ /A "" K K "A?&(-? "
K
" B /A ""
""
KK ""
"A?? "
K
" B /A ""
# ""
""
//A "" / / "A?&(-? "
" B / "" / A "
""
"B"B
"" #$% -./011111 .23-/0111 /4/./0111 (() G(75*,(16(-(1<,#"8(-*!, **5!(7 ,*E!*,(1(*!(11-<(-!*(. 3!,<*<,,667**!*( !!).&. 22(3(.(!6(-7!#"G!,6)!,6(8(88 (*!!J G!,6)!,6 L # ,6)8*,(,,(!(66(),8,1(9 !,(*!,((1,76(-,1(())*8(! ,(7!,6 ,1(9.,<.9(15B "8(-*
# )76,!7(* ,1(9!78,7,(,786* #"G!,6)H68 # "/ (8,!.>58,7,( , 7 H88 1- , *68* 8 (* , ( ,* (*6) <(* )88 , 1- , 6 1- , 1(9 ,(. ,<.<587(98!!))*83<,((*68,(! K - ( 8(8 "
"A , 6 >5*8 , *68*!H*!<7,@*77*!)(5*?/!, E H6**3 !()( 617* (38 6(- , * (8 6(-) !,H8868 (**573,( # "/ <(* ,(*8(!7(93,6(-7.,8(-<(**5),(*<(( )()(!,E ,8(-<(*77( *83,!()*(8 ))57*()* ! , )(* , 6@* (7* 3(83 ,* (66)(!,((8,8(-())5!,6)85((*6) ( 61(1 , !()( 8!!)5- !8 , 8(8 "A 6(*,6)85(,58*(8((1-7(9 ,6(-7
, 6 1- ,* 8(8
(8 ,* >5*!(H*!<7,*@,*(7358 ,(<*(8 *6)!,8(8"
"A <58>5(-(66-, 8(8
/ *6,(,<(**6*, 8(8"
"A *93(H*!7 <(*,(-*6* ,6@*>5*!H*!7)(8,*8(8
8)(5*?/,*68*<8)8, 8(-56/"8(-*<,#G6(-(856B"8(-*<, G6(-
K 6<>5* ,)1,(!!,*68*,(, 6(-7 )58 ,( 1 7(8 ,** * < !588 8 )(5*?/,6<(*1587(9(>5*!H*!7 !,H*<(*!5*8,<(*>5*!,67(93 ,6(-7 , >5* ! 7(93 , 6(-71-8 , *65(8 8(<58(*-,!,7!6(-713H88 ,(3*688,6@*>5*!H*!7. )( 1 )88 ,( , 6 )58 ,( 7(8 , 6(-7 ,** *(8!*683,6@*>5*!H* ! 7 7(9 , 6(-7. , *68* **58 ( ) 8(8 "/
)(356,6*,<)(5*<,-,E 53, 1)()8())5!,*!(586* "G!,(75 , ,(3
. , 6 !!8 6(- , 1(() (75<,*(86(- )88,*(71-,*8(8
(8 >5*8 ,* )(* 1 )*88 *-76(,)(- , 6!8( K" /! "
#<,),<(*8*6*8 !1-(8(8:58378(8 / #8)3,*68* (9(8)*,7(<,<7,*
7(-, 8*686(**8,7653888(8
#:)3,6@*(66)(
, 76538 8 )55*- )8* ,( (,53, (* 6 )(5*?/!,E ,7!6(-7)581H881-B"8(-*, 68,(8((8-H68 *<78(,*68*,(8 *688 , 6@* (66)( ! H* ! 7
,<(*>5*.,!.!,61387(9 ,6(-71-8,3(*65(88(!6(-7 ,6 )58,(7(8,6(-71-8,3(*65(88(- , ! , *68* H83 , 7 ,5* , 1(** ! , 765388*5* ,765388*.,!.(11 *?(*8 (5*?/ ! , E 7- 68* ! 6(-7 ! #"G <,5*65(3,8(!,*(7 ,<8*F
8)( ,( , (75 <(* 1 6(8 <,((*(17!,E!8(8"A
,8(
"# 15*- !* , 8( !7 <,), G 6(- * 1 )7658 )586**1-,(>58,66(-#"G! , (75 <, #" 8(-* !
"# ! ,( 68 <58 ,( H68
"K (8E!**!8(8"A
<6*57,!,(#"G!,(753,<,6(-( G !7
"# <(* 1 6(8 <, ( (*(1 7 ! , 8( ! E!8(8"A
*(7(!!().,8(!6(-758,E * ,*)(*((*58)(5*/H**!/"8(-*(8B"8(-* < 67**1 , (66)( ! H* <(* 7(8 (7* 778(-())5!,6)85(8!!)5*H6**81-,1(9 8*15*3,( ,<(*81(8!(5,6(!, 66(-3,(75 ,**(!)(*!H83,7! 6(-7 , 76538 8 :)8 , (66)( , 5* 1(**,(,H8868,(8(*(6*8 *<78(,
/ *68* *688 , 6@* (66)( ! H* <,),<(*7(8<<,,*68
,7(.,<.8*8, <(*)88 ,* < 6 ,( , (66)( ! (7 <(* 7(8 1- , 6,7*!15<(*7(81,(!!(,86(- ,)6*! , 3( 8)57* ,( 1 8 56 )8 ,( 1(9 8)57* < *38 1- , 6 *566 ! ,*. <(* )88!*(),(,6@**3(5*(66(85*8, 7( 6() <, , *3(5* 53, ,( (66(8 * ),!,*51-(88(8"
8,*1:)(8 1*8,(<(*)**(-!85,*5)!6@*)7 8*),(3,((1- <.(*,*,<)(5*)<(***58,*1(** (8,765388<(*(*6(**8,*1(**.<5815!( , 6 8)8 ,* 7( (3(* ,7 ,* 358 ! , *68* 8 )()3 , E ,* 358 ,- 75* **5 ( !*,*,<)(5*(86(**(!*,8 8H6**(-6(* <,,,-(8**5(!*,*,<)(5*) <8 7(9(-1*(3(83,(8-!*5),(*,<)(5*).! **58 ,)*!,6(*,*3(8(966
,6*.,!.8*6*8!,!<38+? , 76538 8 8(8 # * * (*8 , 6@* *(7 ,( , <58 6(- , (75 (* 6 )(5*?/*())68 ,6*,(7(9,6(-7<, !5<9*!,)6!,7(!7,*68*(*
A ,H()(756(-(1 !,6!(*7(9,6(-7 (*87(88.*51:)(-88)!(5.15( (5,-.,6*,(*(88*7**8(8,765388 *,(1878,(1(8-6(**8 ,*,(18(*)** $2 ;M ' 2 .1#5$621.- $
EE' (8