Sudhir Bhatia And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!"#"
$% &&
'()*"+* "
* + " "
$ +# , +#(# '
+- * +# #.
$) $ #
+ /* $)(.
" "
$ + , +#(# '
+- * +# #.
$) $ #
+ # $ 0+'(+- $ ( /2), + * . " "
$ +# 0+'(#*"34(/ +5 #*"# *2 2 +- '"$! "$7 * * 8+" . " "
$#!
// $9( # "
$ 3 8 $) ! # + "$, 3, )2 * + + 27 * + 7 "$:) !") )7-!
// $ +) + 7+ ," - ! # + 7 "$: 1 $+ /
" "
$ +# * + "$ # 1 9( #*"$: +) + ) ) ;; <$$ =(+ # > $) > ? + #. ! ", 3- .(+#( $ $# +(! "
$# ) & <$$ =(+ > ?8*"!*"#"$!
$ + , $ "
$ @():/ $ + $) + ) "$ A 8* + 7-" "#* 3) * * # 3 = !( )"$," 8
$# +(! "
$#) )& <$$ =(+ > ?8 (3)$ 7 ! ) * :+" , * . " "
$ +#"# * * -7 !
/ / /7 +#
#") $ + (. (#"$: '
!" - $ / 3- $)"
$ "38 - 3
+:
$"B "
$< +#* + CC?>+ #.
$) $ $ A(+#( $ * + 2 * - 8 + ) 3 # $ -. $) 3 !1 2 -. + #. ! ", 3- "$ "3 5"* + * # >2 0 $# ," /.3 =2 ' !
+ $!*1(3 * + +2 * . " "
$ +# = !( ) $, - )#) <$$ =(+ >? <$$ =(+ >?+ #. ! ", 38" * * + (. !" -* # ") $, - )#8 + = !( )
#. +$# +(! "
$#3 +) )& <$$ =(+ > ? $)+ 9("#"
/.)( -8 # !!
+)"$:3- "= ) 8 , +2,") "/.(:$ ) +) +) ;; <$$ =(+ > ?7 * * $, - )#8 + "/.
($) )
$) * . " "
$ +#8 + )"+ ! ) .
-# /.)( -"$ !!
+) $! 8" * 33 !
++ # $ * .+ /"# * * -8 + $ * 3/ /7 +# * !" -, $"$ * "/.(:$ ) +) +2" * #7 $$ ) ##(7/" )7- * . " "
$ +# * /# 3, #2 * * -8 + $ * 3 * 3
#"$! 7 + * !
/.3 "
$ * + (. (#"$: + @ ! 2 * +3" + / /7 +# * # !" -* )#(++ $) + ) * "+/ /7 +#*". # !" - $) * -8 + #(7# " ( ) #$ 8/ /7 +#7-+ #.
$) $ $ A+ (. (#"$:
'
!" - $).(+#( $ * + 2 * -8 + ) * "++ #. ! ", 3 #
'"/"3 + + * ! #"$ 28* + "$ *
+) +) ) <$$ =(+ > ?.
## ).(+#( $ $# +(! "
) & <$$ =(+ > ?"#($) +!* 33 $: A * , * +)3 +$ )!
($# 3 + * . " "
$ +# # 3# * + #.
$) $ # $)* , 3# :
$ *+ (:* * +", 3.3 )"$:# #8 33 # * + 3 , $ "$# +(! "
$# ..3"!
73 "$ * !
#
+ .+ ! )"$:(+ * +2" 8 (3)7 + 3 , $ + .+ )(! * + 3 , $ = + ! # $# +(! "
$#) )& <$$ =(+ > ?+ )8" * $# +(! "
$#) ) & <$$ =(+ > ?28*"!*+ ) #($) +%>
D
" # $ % &
'
&
&
&
'
&
#
# '
& (
) *(
+
,
-
&
. # '
%
/ !& '
" # $ % &
0 ,$12
&
'
#
!&
3 # '
" # $ % &
&
#
#
!
,
&
#
!& 0 ,$12
! 4 #
" # $ % &
0 ,$12
&
'
&
5 & !
$@ "$ + )"$: * , $# +(! "
$#3 , #$ / $$ +
) (7 * "$!
# + (. !" " #27 $ " 3#
.+"! !* +: )7- * # !" -2 * "/ !
$# +(! "
$2* # 7 :", $ " #/ /7 + " * + * $# +(! "
$# $ + "$ $-8 -#. !"- * * 7 $ " "+# + $# ! "
$"#$ 7 :", $"$!
# # !" -!* $: # * "+# / /7 + $)"$)(! # # !
$)/ /7 + $)"$# ) :","$: * / /7 +#*". * / + +) * $)# $ "33 * .+ @ ! * #7 $ /.3 )* * # 7 1 . "$/-/"$)"# * , $" / /7 + * !" -"#($ 73 7 + * !
# !
$# +(! "
$ +8* , ++ $2 !" -* # +":* !! . * #(++ $) + * / /7 +#*"."$# ) "$)(! "$: $ 8 / /7 +2 8*"!* * # 7 $ ) $ "$ * .+ # $ !
# * + + 2 * .+ /"# * * / /7 +8 #!* $: )7- * # !" -27 * !
$# +(! "
$!
(3)7 !
/.3 ) $)3 #!
(3)7 * $) ) , +28 (3) / $ * * 7 $ " "+# + $# ! "
$"# 7 ) $" ) * #(7# 9( $
E/ /7 + $ * :+ ($) * * "#$ $ 3 #3 $: " "# # 73"#* ) $ + !
+) * " "# "+# + $# ! "
$ 7 8 $ * , +$/ $ E :"# +"$:( * +" - $, - )# $)/ /7 +# * # !" - ; (+ * +/ + 2" * +:(/ $ * 3 +$ )'
!
($# 3"# 7 !! . ) * 7 "$: # !
$)/ /7 +2 * 7 $ " "+# + $# ! "
$$ 7 :", $ . " "
$ +#"$ $-!
# 8*"!*#* (3)* , 7 $!3 +3- .+ ,") )2 #. + * $# +(! "
$# $)E + 2 * "+# + $# ! "
#* 337 !
$"$ ) $3- "+# / /7 +#8* + #.3 "$+ )"$: * = #(:: # # * "+# + $# ! "
$ #!
$ /.3 )"# * $ 7 8 $ * + (.
!" - $)" #/ /7 + $)" $ 8* + # # * " * # 7 8" * " #"+# / /7 +
$," 8 /-)"#!(##"
$ , $)+ $#!
"$ ) * + "$2 * "/.(:$ ) +) +# ) ) ;; <$$ =(+ > $) > ?2
$# +(! "
$ F + ) ) & <$$ =(+ > ? $) +) + ) <$$ =(+ > ? "$ + 9( #* ) " "
$ +# + * 3) $ " 3 ) !
33 ! * "+7 $ " #+ / * "! :"# +"$:( * +" -2"$ !!
+) $! 8" *3 8 " "
$## $))"#.
# )
* * +#.
1"$:E+ $ )
#E * * ++ .
#E