High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14373/2016disposed of

Wassan Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-10-10Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

"#$$%&'&()

"''"(*&(+, -- $#&#&($.

/$.'0'

*#"#$ 0(1"2"(3#,$.'

-- $'4(3$(#'

.$'$(#)- . &',0 ","1"(536%"#$.#,$4$#&#&($. .6&(&#6"'#,&55 0(1"2

$#&#&($.5 8, &' '$.6&(+ "' " $"3 ('#"29$ 0(3$. #,$

9&%$5,"'&9$3#,$&('#"(#4$#&#&('$$:&(+;0"',&(+#,$.3$. 3"#$3

(($<0.$ -!58,$.$2=,&'(">$8"'.$>6$3.>#,$

.>#&(?&'#-! 0.#,$.%,"99$(+$&'##,$.3$.3"#$3 @

(($<0.$ !58,$.$2=#,$.$%>>$(3"#&('.8".3$32=#,$** 5 >.&#'". 0."9!..$'#."#&(. .>#&(?&'#-'#"(3'3$%9&($32= #,$('4$%#.$($."9 9&%$5.3$. "(+$5>.&#'". "6&(+,$".3%0('$9.#,$4".#&$'"#9$(+#,5#,&'0.#&' #,$%('&3$.$36&$8#,"#&#&'"&#%"'$.#,$>"##$.#2$.$>"(3$32"%:# #,$#,&.3.$'4(3$(#"(3."(.3$.#2$4"''$3".$', .&$9=&#>"=2$(#&%$3#,"##,$4$#&#&($.8"'$(9&'#$3&(#,$

9&%$$4".#>$(#"'"('#"29$( AB@ &'(">$8"'2.0+,#( ?&'#-<$>4#$$!"(3,$8"'4.>#$3"'&%&"#&(+$"3('#"29$ 6&3$.3$.3"#$3 @ B@B3$4".#>$(#"9&(;0&.=8"'&(&#&"#$3"+"&('# #,$ 4$#&#&($. "' "9' "(#,$. 49&%$ &%&"9 &( #,$ =$". B@B ( #,$ "99$+"#&('#,"#8,$(#,$4$#&#&($.8"'4'#$3"# 9&%$*#"#&(5"(3&"9",$

"9(+8&#,#,$%-3$9&(;0$(#,"32.0+,#($9"3=&(#,$49&%$'#"#&(( ABB@B"(3:$4#,$.&99$+"99=&(#,$+6#;0".#$. ,$3$4".#>$(#"9 &(;0&.= %09>&("#$3 &( &(3&(+' "+"&('# #,$ 4$#&#&($. "(3 " >"1. 40(&',>$(#.$&#0.$#8=$".''$.6&%$8&#,4$.>"($(#$$%#8"' &>4'$32=#,$40(&',&(+"0#,.&#=6&3$.3$.3"#$3 BB,$.$&'( %,"99$(+$#'0%,.3$.&>4'&#&(>"1.4$("9#=

$#&#&($.8"'.$6$.#$3#,&''02'#"(#&6$."(:('#"29$ 8$BB6&3$.3$.3"#$3@BB 44".$(#9=5 =$".'"#$.#,$&>4'&#&(#,$>"1.4$("9#= #,$&>40+($3.3$.3"#$3

(($<0.$ -!8"'4"''$32=** 5 "1&#,".$>6&(+#,$(">$#,$4.$'$(#4$#&#&($."9(+8&#,%$.#"&( #,$.'.> .>#&(?&'#-<$>4#$$!%&#&(+#,$.$"'(#,"##,$8.: "(3%(30%#,"'2$$(0(3#,"6$3$#$.&."#$3

09$@!!#,$ 9&%$ 09$'5B.$"3'"'

998')-

! "

# $ % &

" %

() 2".$4$.0'"9#,$'#"#0#.=4.6&'&(>":$'&#%9$".#,"# &(9&%#&("(=>"1.40(&',>$(#80932$"2".#"3>&''&(..$#$(#&( &(?&'#5.8$6$.54.6&'"!'#"#$'#,"#.'4$%&"9.$"'('#2$

-- .$%.3$32=#,$*04$.&(#$(3$(#&($"%,%"'$"(3'021$%##%(&.>"#&(2= #,$$40#=('4$%#.$($."9'0%,3&';0"9&&%"#&(>"=2$8"&6$3 0.&(+#,$%0.'$".+0>$(#'5&#,"'+($0(%(#.6$.#$3#,"# "(.3$.3"#$3 @B

,"'2$$(4"''$32=#,$** 5>.&#'". 0."9!

"(3 &( #$.>' 8,&%, #,$ ** 5 >.&#'". 0."9! ,"' >"3$ .$%>>$(3"#&('..$'#."#&(#,$(">$#,$4$#&#&($.(?&'#-&( #,$9&+,##,$998&(+.$"'(&(+)- *+, '- (./01 2#

' '

# ' #

/33/

5 #

# 5

5 6 ( #

( 7

/4(/8(48//

*+, '- (./01 2 #

# '

( 9

(

16 * ':5**

( * 2

() 44".$(#9=5#,$.$%>>$(3"#&('%(#"&($3&(#,$.3$.3"#$3

>"3$2=#,$** 5>.&#'". 0."9!,"6$(#0(3"60.8&#,

-- #,$('4$%#.$($."9 9&%$5.3$. "(+$.5>.&#'".6&3$&>40+($3 .3$.3"#$3 @

(($<0.$ !

$.0'"9#,$.3$."#(($<0.$ .$6$"9'#,"##,$(9=2"'&'

3&'%9'$3&'#,"#4.$6&0'"44$"9'4.$$..$32=#,$4$#&#&($."+"&('##,$ .3$.3"#$3

8,$.$2=,&'(">$8"'.$>6$3.> .>#&(?&'# - '#3 .$1$%#$3 ( B

"(3

8$6$.5 #,$ .$%>>$(3"#&(' >"3$ 2= ** 5 >.&#'". 0."9! 6&3$ .3$. 3"#$3

,"6$(#2$$(3$"9#8&#,,$4.6&'"!0(3$. 09$@"!!

$(6&'"+$'#,$3&';0"9&&%"#&(#2$.$#"&($3&(?&'#5.("%%0(# &>4'&#&(">"1.40(&',>$(##2$8"&6$3.'4$%&"9.$"'('#2$ .$%.3$32=#,$*04$.&(#$(3$(#"(3'021$%##%(&.>"#&(2=#,$$40#= ('4$%#.$($."9(#,$.8.3'5"'4$.'4&.&##,$4.6&'&#8"'#,$ .$"'(&(+.$%.3$32=#,$** 5>.&#'". 0."9!#,"#,"3#2$3$"9#8&#, 2=#,$('4$%#.$($."9 9&%$"(3"6&$8,"3#2$.>$38&#,.$+".3 #%(&.>"#&(#,$'">$.#,$.8&'$,&'&'4.$%&'$9=#,$"'4$%#8,&%, ,"'2$$(%>49$#$9=6$.9:$38,&9$4"''&(+#,$&>40+($3.3$.3"#$3

(($<0.$ ! %%.3&(+9=5 #,$ .3$. 3"#$3 @

(($<0.$ !%"((#'0'#"&(

. #,$ .$"'(' .$%.3$3 "26$5 .3$. 3"#$3 @

"# (($<0.$ 54"''$32=#,$('4$%#.$($."9 9&%$5.3$. "(+$5 >.&#'".5&''$#"'&3$ ,$>"##$.&'.$>"(3$32"%:##,$%>4$#$(# "0#,.&#=.4"''&(+"(.3$.".$',"(3"'4$. 9&%$ 09$'5 8&#,&("4$.&3#,.$$>(#,'.>#,$3"#$.$%$&4#"%$.#&&$3%4= #,&'.3$. #&'5,8$6$.5%9".&&$3#,"##,$2'$.6"#&('>"3$2=#,&' 0.#8093(#2$%('#.0$3"'"(4&(&((#,$>$.&#'#,$%"'$

$#&#&(&'3&'4'$3&(#,$".$'"&3#$.>'

90%:= ,$#,$.'4$":&(+C.$"'($3) $'C ,$#,$. $4.#"29$) $'C