← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1610/2007allowed

Chhaju v. Sante & ORS.

2022-12-05Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal20 pages

        

!"# $%#$& '"(#)#*+#$,

#-#$.#%/&

((!01-2/)#%#)#!-#%"($13((2-4 55#66!/"

7#$-1- !/"#!/%"(#$- #-5/%#/"- &8 4 49 4

$#-#/"& $72:$!* 1/2!,%.)!"#, $"(#!55#66!/" $  !%!.,%.)!"#, $"(#$#-5/%#/"-  

   







 



       

 

     

 







     !



"

  #$ %&   

 

    

   



    

  



$ $



   



'

%!& (    

             )      )  

 

 



   

 

            

 

      "

         

 '

%*&         

         

 







+            

     

   '

%,&  

   



   

    

$ $



    

  

      

'

%-&        

    

     

   .  



  .      .   

 



 

                

      '

*



   "   

 #$

; / 01  

0  02  3  !-455, 

 4,45, 02  4     0    %6+15& !75, ,    . 

--8)9-02     4,45,, 5  9

 0 :     0   

     0  2           



    

    

945578 02 

     



 

0 

       

 !!!578 0      

7.

 8    ; <!,: <8%7$4&=  

 

     

7.

 4 

     0   58*    +     02       

  

 54-!44,  



02   9)7    0 2    587$588 

 $ $



%  

& 02    4945559 

 

  

   



 !!!578 

895      

$

  

       

02   

 

  



     

   

 (   *

 

<

    >

2    

 

  

 (   9%&9%&9%& 9% &    02        

  

 

   

      

    448559



  

 



    





    "

 !!!578  

   

"

*4559         *48559  

 ,



  

     "  "    !75,, 0:

 0? 0:  

0 :  +    

  (  

 02    

  

 







      

 

 !!!578 



02         





   0 2      (   

0 

 

          0  02     



 "



 02     0     

   

' ( 

   02       578 0         !75,           +      

 "

         (

 

 

 

 

 



  .

 

   

@  8  +  

#$   



   





 

     

  

         !"    

 

 # #     

  

 

  



  

 $ -      

 

     



    ( 

 

    



 

  #$ %& 0

   

     6+15   

 

     

       

 

    5, 



 

02  



 1

0            

    

 

  !!!578   



02    





    

          %&    



02  5-9$-8 %&

  02





     <5 578 % & 02     !74578/ 0 1  0

  0 



    02  

 

     

 % & 0 

 

 

+    

 



     02    

  58 578

  % &  

       



 0                

    .





   

   

0 2     

    

     



  .

+ 





0   

5 5782   



   

 02     % & ?    

           

    

                



02    

 





   



? 



  0   /    A   +

     



02   

  

 % &

 

      0    

    = "

= 

  



    



        

               @7$0

/ 

  

  448559

       

(

  

  448559 9

 ?      

 

   

    

  7 ? 

       

0  ,  .   --8)9- 

 !75,6+15 0:

 0? : 

0:

 0: 8

      +  @$ B ; @!$ . @*$0 <   @,$;

< @-$ :   0

  @9$>

            

    

  

  02 

  . 





   5 =  

00

;   0

 0 2     @72

02       



  



 

 

 

>      "

  

        

     



 

 

2    

  02 ( 

   





%@70

/ &

  

     448559   

      

           

+ 

@7

/ C0

 ( 

$+ 





  

  448559 (  

      

            

       !!!578   448559(    

        .

    

   

  7 8 

 .

  

  578 

  *485592 

        4  -5 0 /

 59*

 

 

 

  +    #$ #-)$25"2/ -12" 

   



2*#  $*  ?(2)( 5#$2%+#32/-"$1/

 

   

  

       

 

      

          

  





     

  

  

   (

 

           



 

  



   

     

 .

(    

 .

   "  





  .

 





  (     58* 

    

 

   0  

(         58*0     

, .

         02       

" 





     



           

    

   

 

    

     

          

 

   

! (    



    

   

; <!8.   8%7$4&        !75, (       

                  

  =





 

   



      0    !75, 

  

  

      

0      



 

02  

 

   (    

   0                      !75,     

 !!!57802   





 

0 

   



  A 

0    ,      !75,          



   

 

 

0 





    ( 

0      

   

  (    



  .

 

*



   .

 0  2              

            5-7$-8 584$8< 

        

    

  ( 

    

      0           

D    

 

  A  574$70   

 



  

,.

  

  

  % 

   &  0 

 



 ( 5780     

  0 2  

  

     

 

  02   

    0  

 !!!578  

   

       58*  0  0        



    ; <!,:  <8%7$4& 

  559 ( 

  

      



     ,



     



   



 

02    5)!-5 578 !!!578(    

   

 945578

  

 !!!578=     

 

0  

         !75,

 02 

 

 



     - ( 

 !!!578 

%02 &    



 

 

 02

    

 

= 

  

       

  

;





 02    

 

 



      . 

(  



01  0

  

+   

+  . 

 

A  

  02            

 +

  0 ,

 %& (  6   87!  (          

              0 84 (  6   87!      

             

              

  







.     

  > )A

      



 

 .  ( 

  

     

)            

 

    "

     



 

  

    



          

 > 





   

 

         



.

    



 

  

 

 

   (      

  

  

 

    



     > 

<  

>     



     9



 . 

 (   

 

  

   

    01  0

  

0   

02    +      

      



    

   02 2         5$4 

  

 0  2   

          

    

      





( 

  02        



 





02    

  2          

 (  



"   

 

    

    02         





   

"





         

(

.  

     >

 AA 8  6    +

E

 F 

"





   

  

   

'

   !"#$!%%& '()*$+*#        

    



       

 

            

       

 

     

   



      



      

           





       0 4 ( 

6   87!     0 4!

(  6   87! A        

  

+ 

   

 

  

 



      

  

  

    

  

    

      

 . 

    

0 4 49 (  6   87!(

   

02       

5)!- 578      

 2    

    

 00

/ C0

02      

  

    

        



  2                           0 84 0 ,%& (  6    87!    

+

 

A 

   

(    

   



     

 

        

  "   

     ( 





    

     

           

  

  

         

 % & 0 ,

6   87! 7

+ 

  

 

0  

 

+                 .

        

     (  0  

!545!44, 

  % !,47!44,&

  + 

$ $  (



 !545!44, 

   54  = "





   

    

 + 

      *44!44,   =

*44!44, @ 

>     .  !54!44,   !,!44,= !,!44,1 

 

 7!!44,0 +  

           

0  

 0;

  

  8 (       02 



   5)!-5 578

(

 0      A 

54  

( "

  

  



   

      

   (   

       



    



           



  

             

 

    0 ,-.' (!!!$ (/(((    

 .  

      

+ 



      



2  0 1 20'345 -6 (!+( 3/5$$*%! 0      

                                     



    (     

   

     

 % &

0 , (  6   87!     +

     

           

           ?  

   

   "   

  

   

:

  0       

 

   



       

   

 

 5

 

    

 0    



=                    

   

 

 .    

              

  

     

   02        

02 

  



             

    

+ 0 2 ( 

    02      . 



    (  

 



      

     

02   A    

 %& 0 ,   (   6       87!                    

  A       02    

  0 02       



   5,  5,,2   +  

 594

2    578(



 02 



+   !4

+ 

  

  "   (          

58-$89554$555-$59 !444$4  0 

+  

 6  .      

E0 F559 E2 F557  0  

> A        

  574$7

     



 02  0  

, .

   7.

 4  ( 

 

 

  

02   



  

  

         

A 

0    

    

     

    578    

 

    0 2  







 0     

   



 

(  

   

  

          +       

    

    574$70    

,.

   7.

 4  A       

%6+@!&   578

0        

  02  

  02  

 



  



 



  

0 



02   578     



    

5780 

  

2  

 

 

 

    



 ! :

          

       

    

  





   !! 2  



 

 



   

 !*

;  0    

'"(#)#*+#$,

49 4 /"

 @(#"(#$-5#!:2/3A$#!-/#% & A @(#"(#$$#5$"!+6# & A