High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1536/2015dismissed

Muni Ram And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-05-27Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra10 pages

"#$

"#"&#'

"#$ (

)$ *+ )

, ,, -

*+ )

, ++

!"# $%&' !(&)&# $%& '! *&"#

+ # &&&(! && !& #+# &&& *&"# $%&(! ,!&"

, &%!& &# $%&& &&$ "&# $%& ' - ./ ,, -

!&( %&22& ! 3 " 2.$ & 41 !&$&'! & 7&% !&'

!"& %"&& '!& # !&%! %"&&& %&2& %8'!9&

%:%#1;<6=!&'' &>!%'1;<6?@# (&& 4;

4516#! (!! &'2&* '! & %"&&#!%% :!%2 '%'

! !&.2&& &&%9& %:# !& "& "2%#451A =!&'' & !>%'451A?@ !'# !& !&" &" "$&%%&

%2& !&%'&'%& %6 5< 451A# & " &"%& %2& !%: ! &(& # & & ! 9& %: .""%# 4B

!'# ! 2 !& ! '%&=@ =&@#

&(& & 4B 4518#&: :&! #& # & #!! #!&%! &'2&* '! '%&=7-;@#!3%'451A3!& &2 '%!# ! !% '&%:(: "&%!

!3%'451A3#!& !3%'1;<63

! & $ & % ' ! . ! "& %" ' !# " # &

%2%2""&( &$ % &( ! C "7 .%&" &>

? (!%! !"#$%!"#&'('' & '

)*+ ,--.,%,--.' '(,& %&2&

! C "7

.&& &! A1 '!$ %=&@#&& &!(!'#

%27&% !&'#!& !'2"& !:'

"&(#!'&&( !

! " ! # $ %&&'&$( '& ) &&'&$ # * % &&'&$

& '!!& $7&% '2"& : '"&(#$&"!&!(!%! & ! C "7. && (!!!&'% !3%'

1;<63#%22% ! &'! 2&* '&'%& % 6 '! & %#(!! !&'&%: % !3%'1;<63#%22% ! &'2&*

'& %"&& %8'!3%'1;<63 &&!&! &'! &( ':'"&( =&@#& '2! $%% %46=1@'!3%'451A3#$ (!'& 7&% !&' '# /

,,&"#

+()

! % ! ,-$ .

() % !

/ ()

% !

$#! C "7.(& & 2&*

&&' !!&" >% & ! 3%'1;<63# &%%%46=1@ ' !3%'451A3 &&(!& $:'"&(#! C "7 . && &! A4 !'# && &! (!' %2 7&% !&'#!& 7"& #!&!&'&%: % !3%'1;<63#!%%! &'2&*

'&'%& %6'!& %#& #!&!& '&%:% !3%'1;<63# %%# ! &' &%'& %"&& %8'!3%'

1;<63 0 1 !

20 3 # '$()() 1 2" # '$() () ! % &&'&$ '& # %

! " 4 # % ! &&'&$

! 5 !

" ! # $() % !

1 ! "!

# '$()'& 1

'& %

" " 1 " % '& 6 # '$()()

1 %0

# '$()() 1 '& 5 2 7 018() 1

9'&

" ! '&

" : ;68 9 !

# '$

# '$()() # '$()() # '$()() '& "

1 : ;68# $() &&'&$ &&'&$ # * % &&'&$

( 5

'& 4 1 # '$()() '& 1

$# (!"2&* !& $&! & $&!&" #(!%!%%!3%'1;<63#!

C "7.&& &!A4 %& $ %=&@# ! % %"&#!&'!'%& %6'!3% '1;<63# !%2 '%'!3%'451A3# ! '!&(& #(!%!(&!( &( 2'

%11#'!3%'1;<63#! &(!%2

'%'!3%'451A3# &(%2 '%'! 3%'451A3#!%: !%% #&!2'

!$7&% =&@# %2 ( (!

$ &" #% 2&*&&(& !3%'

1;<63# !2&* '&&(& !3%'1;<63#! !%2 '%'!3%'451A3# &! &2 '% 2&"# ! %2& &2& " %2

2 2'!&%"%2"& ! 3%'451A3 ;

%:%#!& ( 2 #(!!! %: !%% # !'%& %6 '!%'1;<6#!!%2 '%'!%'

/ 451A#&2%!&#(!!!& '%& %&2 4516#!(!!3%'451A3&2 '%& /%&2 & < !& $ & # #!&!'%& & % 6 ' ! 3% ' 1;<63# (& 5< 451A#& #(!! &'&%'!& '%&# !%2 '%'!3%'451A3 !'#2 '!$ %=&@#!&%:% %&2& & %! !3%'1;<63 .:"# ! :"

%"&& %8'!3%'1;<63#$'! &'

2&* '!& %"&&#(& :!%2 '% '!3%'451A3# & /#'!&(& (!%! %&2& %:%!'#(&& &'%2 '%'!3% '451A3#&2%!&# %&2 4B !"# !'&%2'&%'&'%& %6'!3% '1;<63&!& &# !%2 '%'!3% '451A3#!&!%%"$&%& 2#!'! $&" & ! :" %"&& %8'! %'1;<6#& #'&"$&" & !&(& & :&! E% "& !2#'! %& !"&'' &$ !& ' ! &%: "& %&2 &2 $ && F&2%!& 41D & 4B $#&&"'&& 1B'!"&'' &$$&"!&!!&$&"&

0 %$ !& %2&&2:&! E%"& 4<

!''%'!& $#!&#! !&

2 &%% ! $&" ' ! "&%! ' ! &%: % #& &"! !&&! '2%!&""

!$&" '!"&%! '!&%:% &" !%&%!&"" !& '!&(& &!$ %!& !%2& 2 ! &!(&2'! 3%'451A3 &

#&"& !"& &%"

!&!%2&!& %&"%"& &!&&2 "& (!3%'451A3 !'#!&%:%

!&$ %2 '"" & "&('"" %%" E% ! %2& 2 !&(& %% #! 2& 2'!3%'451A3 1A .%"&"%!& & #!" &'' &$# &"& % # !& ! E% "& & & &"

%2'!"&"&#! (!!&'&%"& ! "$& "% .:"#(! "%!&! "" $ &"%'!&! '!

"&"#!.' 2!&#& # %& 2 1#23 !

"&5

16 &'2&!#!.' 2!(# & #(!!& $ $&#!&2 2

'%&=@# & %: ! &(& & 2&& &

&''2

1B &% %!2&%&"'!& % #!#&""! &"%&=@#'&#&"& =@ '

7,, -8 7++ 8 (

% *&$ ! G!!&* /&

/ G!!& " /