← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1950/2009dismissed

Punjab State Civil Supplies. Corp. Ltd. . And ANR. v. M/S. Toor Rice Mills, Bhawanigarh, Sangrur

2016-01-22Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages



    

 

 !!"#$#%&%'() %*+,

'%-./  !#0#1/'221#!$(2( #%3 *+4%*#5(4 % 4!( 22!11% $ 6!($'$

7$( #11$+48%#5(4+#$ (#" /%5('(%*% 4!(  !$2%*!% $   

   !"

#$  94! 4!( !2( !($1"122!($:).!118!* $!! 4!-'*5:!% ;  .!(!!((!*  4! !2( !($(% ;

< 94! 4!( 4!-'*5:!% $4'1*.!(!2( !*#% 4!#5!$ ;

(!$!% &

( =!$4'2 +*0" !+ ( 4!22!11% $

(///1(+*0" !+ ( 4!(!$2%*!% $ >>>>>  !"

 %&' 4!  22!11% ?

 #$  55(#!0!*    4!  (*!(  * !* @A+84!(!.) 4!.-!" #%$#1!*'%*!(/!" #%<@ 4!(.# ( #% %*%"#1# #%" +,($4( B," C ($! #%5?$#*! 4!

8(** !*<@+40!.!!%""!2 !*

( =!$4'2 +1!(%!*"'%$!122!(#%5%.!41 4! 22!11% ?

4$(#$!* 4!118#%5$'.:#$$#%$&?

4!  8(*  (!:!% #%!*  8$  4!  #11!( 40#%5.!!%$!% % #"!.)(!5#$ !(!*2$  4('54 4!#$ (#"

%5!(%*$8!11$40#%5.!!%$!(0!* 4('542'.1#" #% *#*% #% !% #%11)22!(+ 4!(!(!+ 4!)"'1*% (#$! 4#$ 5(#!0%"!.).(#%5#%5 4!#(.-!" #%$8# 4#% 4!2(:! !($

/!" #%<@," D .

4!"1#:8$% 11#%58# 4#% 4!E!F"!2 !*"1'$!G !0!%  #  4!  8(*  5#0!%  .)  4!  (.# ( (  "% #%#%5  4! !1!:!% #% !(!$ 84#"4#$11#%58# 4#% 4!!F"!2 !*"1'$!+ 8'1*% '$ # $-'(#$*#" #%%$'22( 4#$"% !% #%+4! 4$(!1#!*'2% 4!'%(!2( !*(*!( 4!%G.1!/'2(!:! '( * !* H(!%*!(!*#%#0#122!1,AAH +  # 1!*  $  7$  I#$%  #"!  (*#%5  :2%)  6!($'$

'%-./  !#0#1/'221#!$(2( #%3 *%*% 4!(D

/#%"! 4! #11!(4$.$!% !*+ 4!(!(!+#:21#!*1) 4!

.-!" #%$0#$??0#$ 4!!F"!2 !*"1'$!(!*!!:!* 40! 8#0!*#%0#!8 4!2(0#$#%$/!" #%@," 

(///1(+1!(%!*"'%$!122!(#%5%.!41 4! #11!( $'.:# $ 4  4!#$ (#" '*5!4*$2!"##"11)% #"!*#%4#$(*!( 4  4! 2'.1#" #%8$(*!(!* .!!!" !*#% 4!!8$22!($B%51#$4(#.'%!C %*  B-#  '%-.#C+  84!(!$  4!  % #"!  8$  5  2'.1#$4!*  #%  B%*#% F2(!$$C%*B '%-.#(#.'%!C4!2( #"'1($5#0!%#% 4!"1#:2! # #% (!*$ 4'$&?

7$( #11$+48%#5(4+#$ (#" /%5('(+ 4('54 # $2(2(#! (72( %!($C 4!(!#$%:!% #% 4!%:! 4!2( %!(%(4#$2!($%1 **(!$$0!% 4!(8#$!+#%"$! 4!8(*8$ .!!F!"' !*+#% 4! .$!%"!$'"4**(!$$+ 4!$:!"'1*% .!!F!"' !*4! .-!" #%5 '( 1$'%* 4  4!"1#: 4!

8$11#%58# 4 4!

!F"!2 !*"1'$!%*+ 4!(!(!+""!2 !* 4!.-!" #%$% 4!!%*+ 4! 1!(%!*"'%$!12()$(*#$:#$$1 4!22!1

( 40!4!(* 4!1!(%!*"'%$!1( 4!2( #!$%*22(#$!* 4!22!(.= 4!(*!( 4!%G.1!/'2(!:!'( ":! .!2$$!*#% %22!1#1!*.) 4! #11!(5#%$  4!

+84!(!1$ 4!

"% (0!($)  %  .!41    4! 

 0#$??0#$  4!  "1#:  '%*!(  4!

!F"!2 !*"1'$!8$(#$!*+.'  4!$:!8$%!5 !*4!(!1!0% 2( #%  4!(*!( 4!%G.1!/'2(!:!'( (!*$ 4'$&?

         

   

   

  

       

          

  !   

     " 

 

 !   

 # " " $  !          % &' !   %   ( )

    %  ! 

     

 

  

     * %  

 +%,

- ! !   %        

  # " " $  !   )          

   ,  ( , %  &'.

4!(.# ( (+84#1!8(*#%5 4!":2!%$ #%+4$ =!% #% "%$#*!( #% 4!!1!:!% J%*<J#% !(!$ +84#"4$2!( 1'$!### +8$11#%58# 4#% 4!!F"!2 !*"1'$! ( 4!$=!.(!0# )+ (!1!0% 2( #% 4!8(*(!*$ 4'$&?

B*   %   (     

   / 0 0 1 *  

  

  ,     2

32

 4 25  %  "  /

0 0     2

 

62

2 4

5   %  "  / 1 &   ' *    %  (     

    !       / 2 6 1 %

62

2

(!

   "

" 

 !   %

) / 2 6 1  ( %      "

   

    

  & 

   

% %

' 7 ,   (, 

" !    4

5  

%   32

2     ,  8   

  !



.

4!#%*#%5$(!%*!(!*.) 4! .-!" #%5'( $% 4#$2#% (!* 4'$&?

2

( 

  %

 ,     %

             



   ( -   (

%  %  &'

  "  ( "          25     ,  %       2

32

     

5  

%    % +%      2

 

62

2   

%  

    

 %  3&' 



  ,  (

  ( "  

5    %    2  ,    *   

  " "    (,    +%      " 

 !   

  # " " $     

   

 

         

     ( ,  : % .    %

     9       

; !  <

 (1 =

   

 &3'  <%  % 

6 

   

 (1 <%  $(  > #  *

    2

&' <9?@ 30   #1 < A   / # (1 * B% 7 <   ( <%,   #- " 

? 2

&2' (  %   &B>C'.

:#%5(!!:!% 8# 4 4!#%*#%5$(!%*!(!*.) 4! .-!" #%5 '( 41*#%5 4  4!(.# ( (*#*% 40!-'(#$*#" #%$ 4!"1#:8$ 11#%58# 4#% 4!!F"!2 !*"1'$! !:!*)+#%)+8$ 4! %5#%5 #(!" (

%0#!884 4$.!!%% !*.0!+%5('%*#$:*!'   #% !(!(!#% 4!#:2'5%!*(*!( 4!22!1#$""(*#%51)*#$:#$$!* 8!0!(+ 4!22!11% ?

$411.! 1#.!( ) $!!= 0#%*#" #% 4!#(5(#!0%"!+#%)+#%":2! !% (':

&*+&%,

*-

.

 !  %&/012

#$