← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/285/2005allowed

Lakhwinder Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab

2020-02-17Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu18 pages



        

 

!"# # 

$%

&

'((

!)# # 



  

   









   

  

     





 !" #  $



 %"





!&  %"



 

' (

&  ( 

 )    

     !

  

 *+*,**-

.     /  & !

 & 

 )  0,&  ,,*+,**1 

.&    

"       "

  

" 1*,

 " 10   2    #    32#3$ )   

"%"



  "

   

                 

  

     

      

  

                            

  

 !"    

   # $  % &   $ '

,  "     (   !"     )   *  +  ,    &   

       - ,  .  "    $ 

     / %

) '

    "  0+%   $

  1. 0+%      $ 

   

    "     

 / 

   

        " 4!  !

          

"



" 11 # # ) .



"    " )   4!      

"

 )   

"%"    "

&  "

%

'

"

&    0 "            % .      "     % " 

 

- "        

  

 " " 5 % "       % 



 !

 

"

%

.

"

.  2 +*3 !   %  

 

         (         4     

    

      

 

   

   

          

  



     





"

    #           

" 

    $

     

 

     % %

%

% % %  &    

 

 

   

 '        

 



  !

 

"



   

 (  (  

 

 

        

  (      

  

    

"   % %  ) *  *      

 

 

  

 

!





"      

    

 !   

"  

 % 

% (     

  

 

  

      &(      % %%+  % % &    

    

    

       

   "

  , %   (    

 



   

 %% %     *  

 



  

               %- "   

  "!

       .

 "  "   "

     . "  

!

  

  .        !  )!

  

   ! 4!    ,  

+ 67,  2 '         "

 . 8  '

 

 

2 /





 !

2 /

 "

 .     "

""

"

 9 

       : ,5*1,**1

   

 ""  "" 

 !

"

  % ;4< '

"

 .   "

"

 

"%

 2       )   ;4 2  "

7 4! 

  

   "!

  "

     "

 .  /   : ,5*1,**1



  

"

 .

= 675 %

>!     

   8  / & (

 ?  @& !

  : ,**1,**1  -1*  "!

     %   6    "! "  

 

" /  & 

  / >

     "  

  "

.       / >  !.   '

A

.  " 

   ) .   %

   " 

   .   ! ) . 

   !  

"  "  .  '

      '   

-

"

 2  "

7 4!&   !   @  





   (

 "

 .   @ '

    "

 

   !

"

 

 .

""  '

  "

  4 . '   

"

 ,**1,**1 '

  



""





* 67B 

       

  %

 %

  !

 "" / >  : 

    !   " %

 

     .  !  !. '

    

 '



  .    %

 '



"

   % ;4> 2  "

7 4!& 



 %

 

     .  !  !.   5CB ! '

 

 "". %    '

      %

   '

  4

    

"

'



 

 

%   "

 67+ 2 /

        .  ,**1,**1 

 !

  ! '

"

   ;4>     " <2 ;4>C1 



 '

 



    0*      ,,C,1& 

 .  %

  . 

  "" /

> 

  . '



A 

  ;4 7 ! !   " "    



 9 

   2  "

7 4!& 

  

"

   %

>!   "

   0**C-**  '



"

  /

>

""

, 67,      

"

   

  ,5*1,**1 '

"

%   "

 !    "" 

"!  !     (  %        /   "" 

  "" 

  

  '

! "

     "  .   ""

 . !   

 #.  " .    ) "

   ;4< "" "

 .   ! "

 )  

"%

2  

   2      1 671 

       .

 .

 "& ""  "!

    "" 

  !    %   / >  '

 

!

!

    / >  ) .       / >   

 

 : .     .&  .    !  0*     "  

!    ! . / >  ) .

A  !    "

!  

"

 '

 !  "!

  4 . ' %

&  .

  "!

  4 . '   

"

.  "

 2  "

7 4!&   !    

   ""

!. '

   % 

!   ! '

  %

 !

!

".& "& 8!  ""  '

  !

 8  + .

 6        &   

&  

!

!

 

0 67 %

       !.

!

  

 '

   %

 "



 !

 

  !

 %

 

     .  !  !. 

 

  

 

'

   

 

%

 - 67, 9 %         "

 *  !

!







%

  !

 

  !

 %

 

    .  !  !. 

 

    

 '

     "

  / >  



5 ""    <

 &     !   ) "   

67 

 >&  "!

  

  .

 "  "   "

    .

"



B "    "   ""  4  !      "

 "   !

 %

 ""     "& 

"

    !    0**   '

  . 

   '   . 

"%



%  + 67B 

   "

7 4!     4

 .   

"

 '

    

%    "  )  " 

  4   " "  ! .  ""  

675 %

>!  ""   675 %

>! &  ,**1,**1   -1*    "!





 

 6

 "! " 

 &



  / >  '

"

   

"        

 '

A

. 

"  

   ) .  !   .   %

 ' %

&  "   !

  ""  !

4

+  " "   

!        "

  %

. !.

4  

 %  . !    "

.  !  ! " "  675 %

>!    !  !.

!

  

"

     "

     

"" 

     "!.  / >  )



   4   " "   671 

 ""   !& 

  !    %   / > "7""  '

    !

    /

>  ) .      / >   



 ) . "    ! !    ! . / >  2  "

7 4!&   !      !   . '

  %

 !

!

".& "& 8!  ""  )

  ""  ""  !

4   " "   

       ! 671 

  !    

   ""

!. '

   % 

!   ! 2  4!77 " & 

    ""  "!

  4 .  =**      "

!  

"

 2 " & 

4   " "   !  

!&   %  "

!!

 . '

  "

  4 .    675

%

>!  671 

   

" "

)   " "   

 4  ! 

  

 "" 

  / >   % "

   "   .   " 67 %

  67, 9 %  % "  ".

   .       "

 %

  "

  

=

 

  %

 

  

 675

%

>!   "

7 4!      "

  4 .  ""

"

    

"

  "

   -**    ,**1,**1 ) "    " "! % "

 2 

  % "   " "!

% "

& " !  "!    " "!"

 ! 

4"% .      ""  )

    " %

 " %

 

4 =    



#   



 ! "

#   $%&$  $'&$ %    4   " "  !       

   .  "  

! . "    % . " "

            !  % "

  "" 

%    "

 9   "

      "   #  ! 

    % .&       

   "

& 

  !  " ! .  "  



  " "!"

    "    

. !

! 

"

 "

     !.    )

#  ! "

?

 

% " & " & 

  !

"   ! &  !

 "

 ! & 

" "!"

  "   !  .  "   )

  %

 

  

        

         

      

    

 

   

  

*        

        

         

!"#

 





  

  $  %  



    

  

   

  &

    $  % 

     



 '(   )* 

!"#

  +    +

   

    ,       +   

!#

     

  



           

     

      -      

   

    

 



      +    +    

          



 -   +





 #

 &  

 +  

+  

 

      +    



     



 

 



      ,         

   

     

  +

  +            

 +          



 ) + -  . &     

     

       

   

 

              /    + 

  



  +  +      

    +       + 

   

   

      - 

  0

  

          1 1 110  111  +1         

  

 2       

       

   1  1 11  11 1 1 )     

 3 

  +  

    



  

       

+   +      

  

           

 4

 



     

       

    

    

 

                    

     

  

                     

      



 

, 

          

    

  

 

             

         

     +    + 

 

  +        

    0

        



5 

 &     



   

       

     

      

 

    

  

      

    

 ,  '( 

  

   

      4 

    

      $  %    0

    

   

!" #

  

  

     

  

 ('   & 6    ))         ,  % 

  

     

  

   

     

     

  7 ,*

   



#   (

 #")  $%&*  $+*+ %   

% "

 

4  " "    

       "

% "

1    !

 "   . 

   ". 

 "

!

  %

 

'

 4   

 ! #

  

   +  

   

 

 6 4  

 &   

     

     +     

              

       



  

  

 /     8 '*+ '9)

        

 +        

 

+         6 4 

 

 /+        

    

    

2   

         



   

       

           

 

     

     

  



  

      

      

       

   

  

 

   

      +   

 





   

! #

 

   

   6 4 

 

  ! #

   

0      

  -  

  

      +  

     

   #

  

 +   +        

  

   

! #

   

 7 ,

   



#   ,)-.



 ! /" 0#/

  $%&%  $123 %      

.  

% "

4 7 " "  !   

&   %

    . 

    !

 

 



""

"

  %

 

  4    

 

   

     



  

  





    

       

 &

  

, +    

+        5



 - 

  +    +  



    

 

     '9             

    



   



   

  

#

  

   

   /   +         

  

      

   

  

 

     

  

   

 &   

!#

-

     

   4 + 

 

 

       4

 !       

 % 

           

 $                 

   :  

       



    

 0  



             

      0

 - "

!                      $ 

     

  

                           

      4

  

         

       

  

   

                  

 /   +    + 

   

   

 

!#

    

  

  4  &  

 

   

 

    

     

 

    

 

     /  

  

5   

    ')

              

   

   

 



   





   

   



      

  



    



+    +

    +    #    $ 

   0   

  

       

    

   7 ,,

   



#   #") )( )/ #

 ! 0  $%'+  $1&' %   

4  " "     . % "

    



  " "!"

&  !

   "   !  "

.          "  "  )

  %

 

9 &     

 



 *          

            

 

  4  8    



      

      

!#

             

  

 -       %           ! #

         -       

  +   

B

     



            - 

 +     



 *     

    



  



   

         

    11 11  1

1*111

   



''  

   



  

    8     

        

  



 *     1 1 11 

17 ,1

 % 9 "   :

 ' #      4/4)

  $%'2 #  25*2     

% "

    

   4 7 " "  !  " .  ! 

" "

  "   

!

 ""

  % "   

  )  (       

 

!"#

     

   

    



   !"#

 +    

+     

 +      

4 %  

 4  #  , #   &-6 '9* 4% )*;< '9* % =8 );) 

          !#

    

    



   

 

 

+ & >  ,  %       +

 ,

  ,

  4  3 + *( % = '(? @ ';) % =8 (; 

   

  

!"#

 

     



               



  

     

 

       

      6

  

    



    4 %  

 : 6  4  A   &-6 '* 4% ?) @ '* % =8 ')'  :  4   4 

#+1&-61'9*14%1'()?1@1'9*1% 1=81''?)17 ,0  "     % "  

   .





,- "" .&       ) !  !

  

 *+*,**- 

   )   

"A "    !

  ! )   

  )     

.

 

" 

* + ,-.



*

 ,

 , .

 /0$1 !)2   # >  1B 6

 



C8 6

 

C8