High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2347/2020dismissed

Rajdeep Kaur v. Davinder Singh And Others

2022-11-22Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja10 pages

!"#$"%&'&($ !"$

)$""*+ ,- "!&!&("- .' .&($"-/&(01 ($!1"-' "'*($"(!' 2 34

/ +/

-"'"(!2

-)&!"'15 -/&(016$.% !"6#-!1"*"!&!&("-

-7$,89&96$.% !"6#-

- 1$,' #6$.% !"6#--"'*($"(!: ;;;;;; +/ 6 - 8 < 5 < # *-"'"(! -".&'&( *"!&!&(6 %1 88"(0" 1 ' 7""( = $"! (-$"-$ !"$* ''"$7<!1",-!#8" -("$&.&8 ,$0" -&.(6 8 ($1 -651"-"7< ( **8&% !&(,($"- -$"->

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

'! !"$ !1 ! !1" -"'*($"(! : 5 ' %D,&!!"$ # !1" %1 -0"' .&$" ),$0="(! $ !"$ :: * ''"$ 7< !1" ,-! # 8" -("$ ,$&%& 8

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

*"!&!&("-!1 !/"%!&(':A ($#!1"%!6"=*5"-!1"/ -* (%1! %!&(#,-!1"- (%"#-"=. 8#"(%- %1="(!'#-=*,78&%*-*"-!&"' ($ ' !1" %! # * ''&(0 # -"'8,!&( ' 5"88 ' -"0&'!- !&( # 0 &('!-"'*($"(!:5 '$("&($&'%1 -0"#1&'$,!&"'"(,="- !"$ !1"-"&(6(',&!6*-'"%,!&(-!1"-8"0 8*-%""$&(0'%,8$1 ."7""( = &(! &("$7<-"'*($"(!:@*8 &(!&##67 '"$!1"-",*(6&(.&"5#!1" '*"%&#&% 7 - *-"'%-&7"$ ,($"- /"%!&( :B # !1" %! ( !1&' -"0 -$6 8" -("$%,('"8*8 %"'-"8& (%"8 58 &$$5(7<(G78"!1"/,*-"=" ,-!&(!1"% '"#

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

8# "(%- %1="(!5&!1,!7"&(0',**-!"$7< (<-$"-#".&%!&(* ''"$ 7< (<%=*"!"(! ,!1-&!<6% ((! 7"' &$ ! 7" ( %! $("&( 0$ # &!1(1&'* -!" 8'',7=&!'!1 !"."(&(!1"!-& 8 -&'&(0,!# # C6 !1" *"!&!&("-@$"#"($ (!

5 ' (! 78" ! *-$,%" (< -$"- * ''"$ 7< (< %=*"!"(! ,!1-&!< '15&(0 (< $),$&% !&( ' -"0 -$' !1" ,( ,!1-&9"$ %%,* !&( # -"'*($"(!:@*8 &(!&##."- (<#!1" (%1 < !G'*-*"-!< 1 ."1" -$8" -("$%,('"8#-!1"* -!&"' ($0("!1-,01 !1"* *"-7?/"%!&(':A :B#!1"%!51&%1 -"-"8". (!#-!1" *,-*'"'#$"!"-=&( !&(#%(!-."-'<&(.8."$1"-"&( -"-"*-$,%"$ 1"-",($"-

! "

$ %

! %

# &

! %

% % %

(

) %

* ! (+

-= *"-,' 8#!1"*-.&'&('-"*-$,%"$1"-"&( 7."6$(! #&($ ',7'! (%" &( !1" ',7=&''&(' = $" ( 7"1 8# # *"!&!&("- 1" ',7=&''&(= $"(7"1 8##!1"*"!&!&("-'!!1""##"%!!1 !!1"!"I!# /"%!&(:B !" " " #

" " $ %&% "# $ & " ' '1 887"&(!"-*-"!"$ ' J51&%1&'&( & 0$# &!1$("- && &(!"($"$!7"$("- &&& *,-*-!&(0!7"$("F -"5&!1,! (<="-&! ($-"D,&-"'!7"-")"%!"$ ( =< %('&$"-"$ *&(&( !1&' &' (! !1" %--"%! &(!"-*-"! !&( E$ # &!1F 1"-" &' D, 8&#&"- 51&%1 *-"%"$"' ($ D, 8&#&"' 88 !1" ',7'"D,"(!!"I! ($!1"-"#-"6&(=<.&"56&!'1 887"&(!"-*-"!"$ '2 J51&%1&'&(0$# &!1 &.

$("- .

&(!"($"$!7"$("- .& *,-*-!&(0!7"$("F E$ # &!1F &' !1" "''"(%" # *-!"%!&( *-.&$"$ ,($"- !1&' *-.&'&( ($ &! % ((! 7" ' &$ !1 ! 8"0&'8 !,-" &(!"($"$ !1 ! "."( !1"

= 8 #&$" %!'E&(!"($"$!7"$("F-E*,-*-!"$!7"$("F5,8$ 1 ."!1"*-!"%!&(#!1&'*-.&'&( ($!1,' (<&(!"-*-"! !&(!!1" %(!- -< 5,8$ !- ."8 0 &('! !1" &(!"(! # !1" 8"0&'8 !,-" 1&' &(!"-*-"! !&(&'#,-!1"-'!-"(0!1"("$#-=!1"1" $&(0#/"%!&(:B# !1"%!( "

" #

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

(:@$"#"($ (!="-"8<(!1"7 '&'# -"'8,!&( $ !"$:ABC* ''"$7<!1"- = (%1 < !1"-"&'($,7!!1 ! !1"/ -* (%11 '7""("=*5"-"$6,($"-/"%!&(:A-" $5&!1/"%!&( # !1" %!6 #- !1" *,-*'" # -"=. 8 # "(%- %1="(!' ."- !1" *,78&% *-*"-!&"' 5"."-6 7"'&$"' * ''&(0 -"'8,!&( $ !"$ :ABC6(8"0 8*-%""$&(0'#-&!'"(#-%"="(!5"-""."-&(&!& !"$ "&!1"-7"#-" (< ,$&%& 8 -D, '&,$&%& 8 ,!1-&!< ! !1"&('! (%" # *"!&!&("-@$"#"($ (! : - !1" - = (%1 < !6 ,($"- (< # !

'! !,!-<-"="$&"' . &8 78"5&!1!1"=' '!0"! ( $),$&% !&($(" '-"0 -$'!1" 88"0"$,( ,!1-&9"$%%,* !&(#-"'*($"(!:*8 &(!&## !!1&''! 0"&!5,8$ 8'7" **-*-& !"!8? !!1"8 (0, 0"# !1"/"%!&( '5"882

! #

" #" "

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

&$"(%"&(!1&'-"0 -$ ($!1"-"#-"8" -("$-& 8,-! 5 ' -&01! &( $&'=&''&(0 !1" **8&% !&( #&8"$ ! !1" &('! (%" # !1" *"!&!&("-@$"#"($ (!:6,($"- -$"-> ,8":: $ ($ '',%1 !1" *8 &(! #&8"$ 7< -"'*($"(! :*8 &(!&## % ((! 7" -")"%!"$ ! !1&' *-"8&=&( -<'! 0"6&(!1"# %!' %&-%,='! (%"'#!1"*-"'"(!'! 0" 1"-"8& (%"*8 %"$,*(7<8" -("$%,('"8#-!1"*"!&!&("-! !1"% '"!&!

* &% = < 8' (! 1"8* 1"- % ,'" &( !1" *-"'"(! % '"6 (G78"/,*-"=",-!6&(!1&'% '"5 '$" 8&(05&!1/"%!&(B#!1"

$1< - $"'1 "("- 8 / 8"' I %!6 :CB 51&%1 &' -"*-$,%"$ 7"85#--"#"-"(%"2 ,) %

# %!

( * )

# ( -)

! &

* % "

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

($!1"-"#-"!1&'% '"&'(! **8&% 78"!!1"# %!' ($%&-%,='! (%"'# !1"*-"'"(!$&'*,!" (!1"-%(!"(!&(&' 8'= $"(7"1 8##!1"*"!&!&("- !1 ! ( #,($ !&( 1 ' 7""( 8 &$ ! !1" &('! (%" # -"'*($"(! :@*8 &(!&##&(1&'"(!&-"*8 &(!' '!%(!"($!1 !!1" %!&(#!1" *"!&!&("-@$"#"($ (!:5 '(!&(0$# &!11&'%(!"(!&(&' 8' 8& 78"!7"-")"%!"$&(.&"5#!1" ."-="(!'= $"&(* - B#!1" *8 &(!651"-"&(6!1"-"'*($"(!:@*8 &(!&##'*"%&#&% 88<'! !"'!1 !!1" "(!&-" %!&(#*"!&!&("-$"#"($ (!:5 '5&!1 =!&."!85"-!1" *-"'!&0"#!1"*8 &(!&##&(!1""'!&= !&(#1&'#-&"($'6-"8 !&."'"'&$"' &!6!1" ."-="(!'= $"&(!1"*8 &(! -"<"!!7"*-."$$,-&(0!1"!-& 8

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

**8&% !&(&#'6 $.&'"$'!1 !'1"= <$"#"($1"--&01!'&( ("##"%!&." = (("- ($= <(!',##"- (<*-"),$&%"#-5 (!#1"-$"#"(%"&(!1" ',&! 5"."-6 &! &' = $" %8" - !1 ! !1" 7'"-. !&(' = $" 1"-"&( 7."= <(!7"%('!-,"$ ' ("I*-"''&(#*&(&((="-&!' #!1"% '"&(1 ($ "($&(0 **8&% !&('6&# (<6'! ($$&'*'"$# +',-.+ '/01' 1023. " . " / & 0/) . 0/)