Kanwaljit Singh v. Shri Guru Ram Dass Hospital Charitable Trust & ORS


  


  






























  
  
 















    





!


" # 
$ % &


 '


  # ' !"#$%%
 


 ( )

) *
+', 

#    )
+ , 
 *
+', 

 # ' -----  
 & &
#   *


# 
 *

##'

$ 

'
+ 

./




$

   

0 ' 





 


 




'  

 # '

 

%  
 ,

#1


22.
 '
 !

#! 

 

!# 

3*
2
 '
3
1

, 


%
 '


! 1
'
!#1

!
 4 1*




 *

!'
 


# 
#  




#   
  1
## '

!





!


$ %
" # 
&

*
+!  

22
&* 

#!'

 

 
 1



!


  

 
  
 '
 *
+!  

 3225

   
 '

  '

! *
%1*

#    

%
 ,

#1


#

%
, ! *
 *

   ,



#
! 
6
 *

 , 



 '*
 


''

, 

#  (#   
 '




'
  '
 ,

#1

 

!
22.
 '
 !

#! 
 

!# 

3*
2
 '
3
1

,  +



 '! 
 '
'
#

'
%1

 
$ *
  # ' (
 '

##
 '

!

'

!

'


  
&*

' '
#  

 ,
%1

#    
 

#1

 '
 !
%

'
#! 
+
! 

 ,'


%

# 
 '

#
!

 '
 '  

*

#   


 ,

!



*5*/(


7 

!



! 


!%

 '
+# 

0 # 

! /!#!

 ,'

%

#  *

00 '

! 
 
# '
 '



#   

'

#1! 

!

*




'
!

+!  
0

  


4%
8 9*
' # 
'

#

1
& #   
 
 ,

9
 


' 
 
 '



' 






 !
:

7 


#   
 
#'

  '

# 
 
#  
 

 , 



  '

+$

!
 
 
, '
#1


#
! 
 ,'

 
  # '

 

#

%
$ , 
, 
; , '
1<
 *
22 6 '





#   

%! 


 

  # ' 
 

%  

#
+$ !
 '
, '
#1



 1
% 1
% 
'

 !

1

*


! 1

'

'
#

,
%
 '

!
%   
6 '





%! 


#   

% 


'
 '

#



# 
#

 !

 '

 
#   
6 '





 # '

 '

# !

1 % 
% 
!  %  1

 
#  


 # ' (&





( ''
# ,

  
 '

 , 

 ( ( '
!



% 6 '





 # '

 '
#
  '! 
 ''

 
()*+,-./(0)1(2*%3)3/ 1-4)5)-.

36/(* 
  '78  

' 
 '
 '! 
 #'
%1
6 + 4 
6 '



 

%! 



 ''

 ! %


 
 '  
 '

#   

, 

  , !'1

, 
6 '



 

%! 


 , 1*

 # 
 *
1
,'
%1
 '! 


$ 

 
( 0)-+)94,3%,-:62*%6(,1(1);)***<,3)9
6)(,3)59/(1*3)-. 36/(*
8 

8&' ''

= 8

"'

 !

 '





# 
 '
,  
#

'

' !
, %


 
 '



 '! #

'

(0)-+)94,3%,-:6>*
 
;

#< =
#



 '
 '! *


## 


 , 1*

 '*
1
,'


!


,,'


#  
&
, 
# 

 '
 '! 

#'

'


'
( 

   -.,1?3)%).:1(1%6(// 1?3)4//  @/-.)*  %+);,  %12)(-)  )A)-3,  )63*)2 %;)()?(1*321.)-,& =7=  %

 7  



    

 

        

    




     

       

    



   
      
 !

  
 



  "



  

  

     



 #$ % & "


%

 %       



!


    
 '


  (    (     



  
 

     )        

     


 

     $
 

 "

 %    

 %       

  

        

    
  

 "


    

    
    "




      
   *   

 

  
  

 "

 
 

 



      

  

 



   +


   

   
       ! 

   % , -      
      
    

 


  

     

  


!

   !



             "



 '



   

 
    

 

                 

. 

.)2)(,%1:)(,99*$3.@*6/%3)3/ )6)()*63()

  %

'=& 

 



 



     

     /  



                         0

     

 *6, /B6-9:,/*  -3/(-)3,-)9  -B  @*  -,-    -.,)

8  %



7&



   #$ 1 = "



 

2  

  

      



!

 



 

     

  

  



   



    


  

 

/      




 
  




 

   

  
      

!



 



 
   1
3

 

!

   

# 45

    

      !

       

     45 

  !

     

               

  45 -     

/          



  



      

  

    

/         (6   

    

  /  
 

   

  

     '

  



!
   $ !
     

             

       

   

   

      

 



   

 45* 

      

  

       

45 *

  
 

       7   

           


  

 

          
 


   

  

 



 



 

  

 ' 

  

   

  # 

  

    

'

   

  

  ! 

 

   457 

       
  

  
    
     


         

   
 7



 
   


 45 *     

 !

   

          

   /      / 

       



 

   



 

           



   



'



         45   36/  B-3()B3 5/3+//- <(,2)3/  <)(3A  )-.  36/  %3)3/ ,-*3(1;/-3)9,3A)-.():/-BA %3)3/,*1-./(36/(/)9; ) <(,2)3/9)+)-.36/(/,*-/9/;/-3 <159,B9)+&36/-(;)9 B1(*/ (36/)::(,/2/.<)(3A&,*3,-2?/36/(/;/.,/* <(2,./.1-./((.,-)(AB,2,99)+()36/(36)-)<<()B6,-: 36/,:6
1(31-./((3,B9/

36/
-*3,313,-)9

-.,))-.,-2?,-:,3*/C3()(.,-)(A41(,*.,B3,- 4!5 "

   

    



  



    

 

 



  



     

      "




 





  
   8 


    

 

       

 
 !   

 

       

   


 

  -  )B3&  /)B6  B)*/  6)*  3  5/ /C);,-/.&  -  ,3*  )B3*  +6/36/(  36/  B-3()B31)9  (/9)3,-* 5/3+//-36/<)(3,/*5/)(,-*,:-,) <159,B/9/;/-3-B/- 36/ )B3* )<)(3,B19)(B)*/,3,* 1-.36)3-)31(/ 36/ )B3,2,3A(B-3(2/(*A,-292/*<159,B9)+/9/;/-3&36/-36/ ;)33/(B)-5//C);,-/.5A36/,:6
1(3,-+(,3</3,3,-* 1-./((3,B9/

36/
-*3,313,- -.,)3*//+6/36/( )B3,- 36/%3)3/)-.(,-*3(1;/-3)9,3A():/-BA 36/ %3)3/,* ),(&41*3)-./D1,3)59/(36)3(/9/2)-3 )B3(*)(/ 3)?/-,-3B-*,./()3,-)-.,((/9/2)-3 )B3(*6)2/-3:-/ ,-336/./B,*,-;)?,-:<(B/**(36)336/./B,*,-,*-3 )(5,3()(A 4!5 9   




!     2       
        

  

  

     

 
 

   

  

/        




!  
 

  $   4!5 "

          

 




      
 
 


     

 
 



 

   

               

 /;<6)*,*)../.  "



        

   



    

  

  

 : ; '





 "

  

    

 

"  

  
  
  

 

  

$ 





 

   



        



"

 

    

 

      

 
 '

    
 

!
  

'

  

     
  

  -.,1?3)B)*/ *1<()   
  

'

  %6)(;)2/(*1*%36->*,:6%B69)-.36/(*

' %
'

 # 1(6 
    

 
    





  

            

     
      " 

 

   

       




     



  



              
   
     



         
 

    

 
    



  



  

  *



 

 

  
 



   


 






 

/   / '  
     

: 
        





 < 

         

      




     

         

   

 

 


    

  "

   
   

  





     

 

  

 




   


  





       "

   

        

    = .

     





   

 
 



 

=   



  

   

 


 




    "

. 8 <   16)13,,:6
1(3,-)-):,-:

;;,33//&  %,9B6)(  /.,B)9 
99/B:,)3/  2  /5  ).) 6)33)B6)(//& == )16)3,$

   + (

   #$ %



 

     
      
       
   

    



 "

      

  



     

 "

  





        








     

 

% :  
1 
 1 


! 


 *


'



 
#  
 '
%
!  %

'
+ 

.


$

   


0 ' 



# 1

# ,

 '
 # ' (&


'  #!
# % 
'

1
&
#   

'

, 

###  !'1

'
 , 
 +'

1*

 
#  
'

# '



%,
 '

!













































 

 















































 

 :
#9 / '

> /8 :
#% > /8