Vinod v. Kuldeep
*
IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND ANDIGARH HARYANA AT CHA
+,- .
/) *0"
1"
2 """/,- -
())
""") -
!"
#$!%& &!
% +
"(! &!
%'
#"
, & & &$
/ /
0 #0##( &$ $
& & - 2+!
0 #0 3(
(
- & '
("&$ &
"
# . ( $ (
$
!
" # #
&
$ & ' " (
(" $ $ )*&
!$ % ' ( )
* & +, , -( &&$ ( # &'
!" !#$%$ ( &
'!$ % * ()*&
# & (
# # ( &
, )*&
&
" 4
#, &
& &
"
" 3()-4(
&
" &
&&$$ ' ( ( ( $ " &$ "
( $(
(" & !/4( "
" ("
"( ! & & &5 $ $( ( " & (
$
%5(4(
& # " $
&
&$ " 6
$( "
2 $
( (
(
"
)" ( "$ $
7 " 8 ( / ) "
& $"&&$ $ &$ # 3(-54(
& 8 5 "
2 ( #
3.-54(
!
&$& , & #00
!
&$ $6
,( ( " & #"
#" 1", & $ &$
$ $
& & & & !
# ' ( & % "
) ( $ &$
&$ & & #
("6 0"'
(" !
& & &$
" 90 ( (
& &$ ( $( " " & ( # ( ! $ (
& '
( &
# &$
' & #(
( "
( "
& &$)
"
"
& &
2 ( " $ $ & ( # ( "(
/ ) '"( "
( ( #" / $ ) $ ! " #00 " &
&$ "
!
( 9 #
2
" * "
! $( # & / $ "
# # #003 , &5
&
&$ ' "
(" # ( " ;
(
# & < 2
& ! 6 (
- '
!
&$ % $
" & # & &&$ 0
7
( !.'./ .!'.- '1
3
0
(!.'.-.( 0# 0 #0#9 1
!.'.-4.+56 6! 0 0 #0#9 ' "
& & &$) *&
!$ % *
( "
$
& :
(7" " & # , :
7" $ =
5
6
-
$
.
( ( & (7" , &
:
(7"
09 #0#9 , > $ &/ :
(7"" ?
(MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE *0"
1"
Wheth er speaking/reasoned Yes/No Yes/No Wheth er reportable