High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1689/2007dismissed

(O&M) Bhura Singh And Others v. Ranjit Singh Etc.

2018-09-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

"#$$%&'&()$*#$+,$-. /0-"&(1/#/$-'

**$22"(#'

3$-'0'

"(4&#&(1/ '&(%$5$%$"'$5!#/-01/6 '#/$-'

$'*(5$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

-$'$(#) -'/7&(12"58%"#$ -"7"'/&(12".58%"#$.

-#/$"**$22"(#' ($-#/$-$'*(5$(#' 99999 +*,&-( **$22"(#' /0-" &(1/ "(5 &77"- &(1/ 2$1"2 /$&-' 5$$(5"(#:/$-&(1/!"(5+"-4&#&(1/ 2$1"2/$&-5$$(5"(# ;:/"(5&(1/!/"8$*-$$--$5#/$*-$'$(# $102"-$%(5**$"2 "1"&('##/$4051+$(#"(55$%-$$5"#$5

<.=/$-$,>#/$6=$- **$22"#$0-#/"5*"-#2>5$%-$$5#/$'0&##/$-$'*(5$(#:*2"&(#&

"(4&#&(1/*2"&(#&&('#&#0#$5#/$'0&#-4&(#*''$''&("(5 *$-+"($(#&(40(%#&(&(-$'*$%##/$'0&#2"(5(#/$*-$+&'$#/"#,/" &(1/"(5"(#"&(1/"2(1=&#/5$$(5"(#'#;=$-$=($-'&( *''$''&(#/$'0&#*-*$-#>#$-#/$5$"#/,/"&(1/"(5"(#" &(1/."&?"0-.#/$&-'&'#$-.&(/$-&#$5#/$&-'/"-$"&?"0-&2$5"&8&20&# ,$"-&(1 @ -*''$''&(A0"2"(5+$"'0-&(1@,&1/"'

,&'="'-B;#/'/"-$"(5<,&1/"' ,&'="'##/$$C#$(#B#/'/"-$ "(58&5$4051+$(#"(55$%-$$5"#$5@ .'/$="'5$%2"-$5&(4&(# *''$''&(B#/'/"-$&(#/$2"(5+$"'0-&(1@,&1/"' ,&'="'"(5B#/

'/"-$&(##"22"(5+$"'0-&(1<,&1/"' ,&'="'#="'"22$1$5#/"#"& ?"0-=&#/#/$/$2*-$8$(0$&%&"2'$(#$-$5&(#4&(#*''$''&(#/$ '0&#2"(5/$5&$5(

"(5"#$-#/"#.+0#"#&(<="'

'"(%#&($5 &( "80- #/$ *2"&(#& ( @ 2"&(#& &2$5 "( "**2&%"#&(-*"-#&#&(,$-$#/$''&'#"(#22$%#-'#-"5$."-("2". ,0##/$'"+$="'5&'+&''$5( </$22$%#-0,&8&'&(.

"-("2".8&5$-5$-5"#$5

.-$2$1"#$5#/$*2"&(#&-1$##&(1#/$ A0$'#&(#&#2$5$%&5$5-+#/$%&8&2%0-#8$(#/$-$8&'&(*-$$--$5 "1"&('##/$'"&5-5$-="'5&'+&''$5#&'&(#/$'$%&-%0+'#"(%$'.#/$'0&# ="'&2$5#="'0-#/$-"8$--$5#/"#50-&(1#/$*$(5$(%>#/$'0&#.$= #/$-$'*(5$(#'/"5'252"(5+$"'0-&(1@ 7"("2'+"-2"'#5$$(5"(#'

@#"(5.#/$-$-$.#/$>=$-$&+*2$"5$5"'5$$(5"(#' /$"-$+$(#&($5'0&#="'%(#$'#$5,>"22#/$5$$(5"(#' $C%$*#5$$(5"(#' "(5 .=/=$-$*-%$$5$5$C:*"-#$"'#/$>"&2$5 #"**$"-&(#/$%0-#5$'*&#$'$-8&%$(,4$%#&(A0"+"&(#"&(",&2&#> #/$'0&#"'*$-#/$*-8&'&('$%#&("(5 -5$- 02$ ="'

#"7$(#="'"8$--$5#/"##/$'$%(5'0&#(#/$'"+$*&(#.&(=/&%/"& ?"0-/"'"2-$"5>"8"&2$5#/$5$%-$$.%"((#,$"1&#"#$5"'/$-'/"-$="' %(&($5"'*$-#/$5$%-$$ /$"-$+$(#&($55$%-$$="'(# $C$%0#$5=&#/&(#=$28$>$"-'.#/$-$-$.#/$"**2&%"#&(,$-$#/$-$8$(0$ "0#/-&#&$''$$7&(1*"-#&#&(#/$2"(55&5(#2&$0,'$A0$(#8$(5-'.&$. 5$$(5"(#'@#"2',4$%#$5##/$+"&(#"&(",&2&#>#/$'0&#"(5 %2"&+$5#/"8$,$%+$=($-'&(*''$''&(,>8&-#0$#/$'"2$5$$5 5"#$5 < < &(%$#/$*"-#&$'=$-$"#8"-&"(%$.#/$#-&"20-#-"+$5#/$ 22=&(1&''0$'):

. !

D/$#/$-"&?"0-/"51#B@'/"-$&(#/$'0&#*-*$-#>"' "22$1$5"(5'/$/"51#4&(#*''$''&(#/$'0&#&($C$%0#&( @ 5$%&5$5(@ "'"22$1$5E

D/$#/$-"#/$-5$$(5"(#'#;"(5<#/"5 ,$$(*">&(1%/"7#"B,"#"&#"&?"0-"'"22$1$5E

:! D/$#/$-#/$'0&#*-*$-#>/"',$$(%"-8$50#"1"&('##/$ *-*$-#>%+*-&'$5&(5$%-$$5#; <&('0&#B@ <<B<<E

/&'&''0$="'-"+$5(@! @!

D/$#/$-5$%&'&(-"5$."-("2"5#<. 22$%#- 0, &8&'&( "-("2" 5# "(5 ++&''&($- "#&"2"5#< .8&5$=/&%/"**2&%"#&(#/$ *2"&(#&-*"-#&#&(#/$'0&#*-*$-#>/"',$$(5&'+&''$5&' &22$1"2.(022"(58&5"(5(#,&(5&(10*(#/$*2"&(#&E

D/$#/$-5$$(5"(#;/"(5&(1/.5$$(5"(#< "1"(&(1/"(55$$(5"(#/$-&(1/=$-$5$"5,$-$ #/$&2&(1#/$'0&#.&'#=/"#$$%#E <!

D/$#/$-#/$'0&#&',"--$5 B "(5 B

02$#/$ "'"22$1$5E !

D/$#/$-#/$'0&#&'=&#/&(2&+&#"#&(E

D/$#/$-*2"&(#&&'$'#**$5,>/&'"%#"(5%(50%#-+ &2&(1#/$*-$'$(#'0&#"'"22$1$5E !

D/$#/$-#/$'0&# &' ,"5 -((:4&(5$-($%$''"-> *"-#&$'"(5+&':4&(5$-#/$*"-#&$'E !

D/$#/$-#/&'%0-#/"'(40-&'5&%#&(##->#/$*-$'$(# '0&#E !

D/$#/$-#/$("+$5$$(5"(# /"',$$(=-&##$( &(%--$%#.&'#=/"#$$%#E !

D/$#/$-#/$5$$(5"(#'"-$$(#&#2$5-'*$%&"2%'#'E

D/$#/$-#/$*2"&(#&&'$(#&#2$5-4&(#*''$''&( #/$'0&#*-*$-#>E @!

D/$#/$-#/$*2"&(#&&'$(#&#2$5-#/$&(40(%#&(*-">$5 -E

$2&$ /$#-&"20-#.(#/$,"'&'#/$$8&5$(%$,-01/#(-$%-5.

/ 5$%&5$5&''0$'"(5.&$.=/$#/$-"&?"0-/"5B@-5'/"-$&(#/$'0&# *-*$-#>"(5/"51##/$4&(#*''$''&(&($C$%0#&( @

"(58&':":8&'%"-8&(10##/$*-*$-#>"1"&('##/$*-*$-#>%+*-&'$5&( #/$5$%-$$.&(*0-'0"(%$##/$5$%-$$./=$8$-.5&'+&''$5#/$'0&#(&''0$ <"'&#="'/&#,>5%#-&($"7&(#

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

"'*$-*-8&'&('

$%#&( .#/$-$="'(%%"'&(-#/$#-&"20-##"%%-5#/$ '#"#0'B@-5'/"-$#"&?"0-=/&2$-$(5$-&(1&(5&(1'(&''0$'"(5 "&?"0-/"5"''$-#$5#/$-&1/#&(%2"&+&(1+-$'/"-$&(#/$*"-%$2 #/$2"(5=/&%/="'(#1-"(#$5.,0#%(&($5#B#/'/"-$"(5B#/'/"-$&( #/$ '0&# *-*$-#> > '$##&(1:"'&5$ #/$ -5$- #/$ -$8$(0$ %0-#. &# #"(#"+0(#'#1&8&(12$8$-"1$##/$*2"&(#&#%++$(%$#/$*"-#&#&( *-%$$5&(1'"1"&($%-$#"2#/$'0&#,>#/$ 6=$-**$22"#$0-# "+0(#'#$8$(0*'$##&(1#/$$"-2&$-4051+$(#"(55$%-$$C "(5 .=/&%//"5"##"&($5&("2&#> 2"&(#&%025(#,$"%%-5$5#/$-&1/#

0 #%2"&+B@-5'/"-$=/&%/="'"1"&('##/$4051+$(#"(55$%-$$C "(5 *"''$5&(&8&20&#B@<051+$(#"(55$%-$$#/$ 6=$-**$22"#$0-#&'(#'0'#"&(",2$"'&#/"'(#5$#$-+&($5#/$'/"-$ #/$*"-#&$' /$-$&'(-$*-$'$(#"#&((,$/"2#/$-$'*(5$(#' /$ "**$"2 ="' "5+&##$5 ( ,> -"+&(1 #/$ 22=&(1'0,'#"(#&"2A0$'#&(2"=):

D/$#/$-'0&##/$*2"&(#&%025,$5$%-$$5$'*$%&"22> =/$(#/$&''0$-$1"-5&(1#/$'0&##/$*2"&(#&,$&(1,"--$5 0(5$-$%#&( "(50(5$- -5$- 02$ ="'

5$%&5$5"1"&('#*2"&(#&E !

D/$#/$- #/$ &+*01($5 4051+$(# "(5 5$%-$$ "-$ '$2 %(#-"5&%#->"(5"-$'0'#"&(",2$&(#/$$>$'2"=E @!

D/$#/$-#/$'0&##/$*2"&(#&%025,$5$%-$$5##/$ $C#$(#B@-5 '/"-$,$&(1"%:'/"-$-&(#/$'0&#*-*$-#> $'*$%&"22>=/$("&?"0-.*-$5$%$''-:&(:&(#$-$'#="'5$%2"-$5 "' =($- &( 4&(# *''$''&( &( *-$8&0' 4051+$(# 5"#$5 ;

<##/$$C#$(#B#/'/"-$&(#/$'0&#*-*$-#>E ;!

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

%"((# -$2$1"#$#/$*"-#>-%2"&+&(1 #&#2$=/&%//"5 "2-$"5>"##"&($5 &("2&#>%:=($-%"((#,$*-$8$(#$5#7$$*4&(#($''#/$2"(5"(5 %"("2=">'"'7-*"-#&#&(/"#-&1/#%"((#,$#"7$("=">#&'&(#/"# %(#$C#.#/$6=$-**$22"#$0-#%--$%#2>'$#:"'&5$#/$-5$-'-$4$%#&(1 #/$%2"&+*"-#&#&("(5#/$&+*"%#&(5&(1'(&''0$'"(5 -$'02#&(1 &(# 5&'+&''"2 #/$ '0&#. &( '0%/ %&-%0+'#"(%$'. =025 (# "58$-'$2>$$%##/$-&1/##/$"**$22"(#:5$$(5"(#' '"(0*'/#+>"-$+$(#&($5&(5&(1'.#/$A0$'#&(' 2"=-"+$5( "-$"('=$-$5"1"&('##/$"**$22"(#:5$$(5"(#' /$4051+$(#"(55$%-$$#/$6=$-**$22"#$0-#5$'(#'0$--+ "(>&22$1"2&#>-*$-8$-'&#>**$"2&'"%%-5&(12>5&'+&''$5 123- +*,&

245 ()67'

,515489 :4

;4:

,515 13"

;4: