← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18658/2013dismissed

Abohar Coop. Cotton Mkt. & Spinning Mills Ltd v. State Of Punjab & ANR

2015-01-28Mr. Justice Hemant Gupta,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan8 pages

 

     

  



    !"

##$%&'

(((  )$*$ "+ , '$ (((( $ ' $  !"#$%&'" ()*+')!*+)#,("! "+**!& #$%&'" ()*+'''!,)+%!&

$ -

( . $#/'

0/ + (

(.(.(*/''#(((/ ,(

(" , "&/'

0/ +$ ' (1( (( )!*+)#,("! "+**!&     !"

##$ %&'$+#' $ 2 0##  $+"0 3 45 +  ,   0*#*#  '*0 $ 0/6786  4 + +'$90+678695 $+$ 0#*'$ 0$$'

 0*#*'*02 '+ +: 0*#*#'*0;( $#$0## ' $+ <6=+"0'*#+ 0+6786 $+$ 0#*'$  

$  0*#*# '*0(

   &##$0$$ * + 

*

'

0 (($ 0 $' '0 +&*

$0$+ + 

0$$+$ 0 +&0 $'/0 $' '0 #$$00 +  0*#*#'*0(+0$$/0&&'$2*#'  '*$#'*0$ '*$$&0*#'   0#*'' "0'*#$ 0*#*#'*0 '$*# #<0&### +&+$ '' #& 0$$(

 '/$$ '+$ ' $0 +67862$ 0'<"+ , $*,020$ " #$ '$$*0"% $# $0& # $# $*,0 +0 # ' *# +'  0*#*#'*0("0 345+ 0+6786'+ $: 0*#*#'*0;& ##'*0/2 0$$' /+ 0*#*/0*#*/ &#*$ '<+$$ $0+' "0'*#0 ' "0'*#0'0 &(6=2$'''$  0*#*#'*0($ $'2 0 4*

5$* '$*'#<  0*#*#'*0$$  $'<+& '0

*$'0 $*&' $'+&( * $&##0$$/0 +$$'+&0 $'( 2 '*0$  ' + $ 0  *     0*#*# '*0$$ 0&0#<$0#0 + 0$$( +/ 00*&$ 0$2'*0$0 &'$ '*$# '*0$(" 0$2'*0$+$ & $ 0*#*# '*0$/$&  #< ''' "0'*#&(6= '  0*#*#'*0<### <+&+$

 '"0 31+0+678620 '$$* '-> :

&- (>&&$##/$*,0$*0 *#$$&<&'<" &  $ #+/# < '> #&$$> 45 +$  0*#*#'*0*  $#'<#0 $  +'&  ?0' 2*$+ < * ''*$@ '

45 #$  '' #  +$       0*#*# '*0  2  $#'  <    '*0     #0 $  +'&

  ?0'     *  +   <   * ''*$(

 ''> 45

+$### # $0+  $0    20  '# <  +    0*#*#'*0* $#'$  0*##<&'@ '

45 +$### # #< $  $0 20'# <$0*##< &'(;

$ +* '* *# 1A+ ,  0*#*# '*0 $4 #5 *#$/67834 ++' $9 *#$+678395 '$+?& +&<& +&+$/ 20'$$* '-> :1A(?& +&<& ++$(>B"0 $31 '

C14354 D(>3465&+$### ' $# *0$+ < 0*#*# '*0& *+0*' ?0'  +&    0*#*#  '*0    $0  + 20$*0+$#'< ' $& +'

&  < +'&2

. "(;

E#+ $ $ $/$ $'$ '*# ? 0  +&+ 0$$'0 0 $'+ &+$#'< ' *

 +'

&($ +*$'* '+$' $ $ &+$<#  0*#*#'*0 '+ '

 0*#*#'*0/$&$# #  0*#*#'*0 & *+0*'?0'+& 0*#*#'*0($ $0 ? ?$$ 0$$' '* 0$$'$ *$' "0 345+ 0+6786(+/ $ $+"0 345$2##$ <6= +"0'*#0'0+6786+0#<# #( E '# '0* $#+$( *    0*$  +   *& $/  # '  0* $#  +   &$$'+0$$2'*0$/ &#</0

$' '0 +' &  0*#*#'*0*<$$*& 00+ '*$#'*0$(+/ +$2 '*0$ "0'*# ' +0 ''38 </6786$## # '<$00' # '0* $# &+0 # '

  '*$#'*0$( $0   +# '0* $#$   #(0$$+ 

+20 $ <$&#(0 ' & *##<&0 0##<( * 2/ 

0$$$  * 0$$+$   +$'$+&0 +( +$ 0$$/'*0$' #$00/ ' #<$'$ $##'  *  +    0  +  2*    # 0  +  < 0&0# & ( * 2/$ #& +& *+0*

# '

  0$$  +  

$ $    <0&0#&    '' 0 +0&$ /+/$'0 +0

 &'$ 2'*0 '*$#'*0(0$$$$&$ *$' ''<20$$'+&''<*$("*00$$ $'$ 0*#*#0$$("&#$0$2 2+& #<$$'(+/ +$ /'*0$ & $ 0*#*#'*0$ '<  #< ''' "0'*#&(6= '  0*#*#'*0<## # < +  &  +$  * '  "0  31  +    0  +  6786/  $*,0   ?&   '  * '  *#  1A465 +   *#$  +  6783( $  +  $ # $# 0& 0+"+&0+6786$0 0 '/ $&$  0## '($ #< $''+

+: 0*#*#'*0; ''* '"0 345# 2 <6= +"0'*#$* 0 $* # '*# $( *  /2'

: 0*#*#  '*0;  $    '+ '    "0  345  20  $  

0 +&<2 $ $0  ' :" 0*#*# '*0

 4 #& !  *# 50/3AA1;202$&*# '

 $$+0&& ' $&'<?0&&

67(63(3AAA/ '< & + '/ $<+ 0*#*( '+ +: 0*#*#'*0; $'0$$* '-> :3465  9 0*#*#  '*09  & $  ##  '*0   '

0&&'$/  2  0$$'    * 0$$'/  +  0*#*/0*#*/0*#*/$0*#*/# $0 ''*0$+# $0/+#0$4 2E#5 '$ $ &#$/  +$  '*0/  0(  $    $0+'     $0'*#'0#'< & < +0

  +&&& '#$ 0#*'$&?*+2 & 2$*0'*0$(;

 $ 0$ &##$  + &&/(" 0 

/200  *$   0*#*#'*0$ * +&*$'"+ *0$   '  '# '  2    +'    +    &&/ /'& '+&+ ' *# #&  '$ #<  &'$ *#37+ *#$+6783($ 0$+ &+$ ' *



2 "+ ,( $&#'$*0&*+ 0 $' +?* 0$+.$ %#)$*$" + ,$  '$ 677A4"*5"=C3 2 & +

,$ 0#*''$* '*0' &##$$ 0*#*#'*0

#$ ''* ' ,$  0*#*# '*0 $0/6786( ?*,0'$&#0## $' < ' '+ +: 0*#*#'*0;2#$ $* '-> :C("* $ +&$202$ 0#*'' "0'*#0/$*#</ +&$ 0 "*0 $+* ' $/*,/E$  #/0(E2$$*$F* #<'#'

> 0#*''> *'2$'''#2$ &&#$"0 CA+0&2'"  &     & '     0#*'   <  &     "0'*#  +   0*#*#  '*0(  ?$ 0  +  $*0 '# '  2  $  *$*#  +*  +    $*$(   ## #< +&<0*#' '* ( 0## /+/+* '' ?0$$ '#  + # $# 22$&$0 0 '(

/ G( +$*  "0'*#2$* ' <$2$ '*0'*+$#$0 '   +   0*#*#  '*0(  ##0<  +   $*&$$ $ $2$ 0&#'$ '+ '+ +2': 0*#*#'*0; 0 20   0#*'$  ##  '*0  2   0*#*#/ 0*#*#/ &#*$ '<2$$$0+'

"0'*#(# $# 2'' 0#*' ''+ 2' +0##<//'+

20$ ?*$ * 0#*$  ?0#*'$ <&'*0' &##+0$ 0 + $$ 2''*0+&$#(+0 $*0

 ##&$+ &#*$ '<$##$ '?0#*''(   +*   #$  ? $  +    ?$$  : 2$$$0+' "0'*#;($20 +&   '  *$  &'  +  '*0   <   $0 +0    &0 0#  &'  0 $    00( . '$$* /20$'*0'<  0$$ '$ '++ +&$* '*0'< 0**&

0$$  ?0    0&$ /  +##<   '

0 '*0 <$#'   

2$#'

     0*#*#  '*0    $&  '0$ $(   '$ 0 2$&' &'+'*0 / &#</ <&' #  '&0 <($</+/ $*  '*0' &##+0$0*#'  '&' 0*#*#'*0$  $ $*<# *  ',*'0#  +$&#  $ $+0 $*$+"$(;

"&##</0'#'*0' 0$$ * $ #$  #' 0*#*#'*0 & '.#$.*&!( )$*$ "+ (/67HA4"*5"3= ' .$ ' '

  "& ( # ## '(/467HC5C"G68( */. '$ $* /20$'*0'<  0$$ '$ '++ +& $* '*0'< 0**& 0$$?0 0&$ /+##< '0 '*0 <$#' . '$ '< )$*$"+ (/ 467HG53"CHG2$#' 0*#*#'*0(*$/

+2'*0$/ &#</0 $' '0 +0

$' ## #*# $"0 345 ' <6= "0'*#+0 +6786(  2++$'$ $/2+ ' +0 2  '$&$<'$&$$'( 4"".

 %5    *<3H/3A6G 4 ."%5