← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21837/2012allowed

Rajbir Singh & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-10-27Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma11 pages

 

           !" "#$%$&'  (   

                  

             ) )    

           ) ( )   !" #$$            * *) )   # %

&            ( *)  )   !  

              )* )   !" % '%($             *+ * (    #            

 + +)* (   %               +

   !"!%) *$            '  ,-. / ./0  ,-. / ./ --   

                  



        

   

   

  

       + !  , -   (*& ! %- (*. !/, -   (*& ! 0 , - (*. !, !

- (*. !0$* - (*. !   #- (*. !0#% - (*. )  !(% #-   !0!

-   !$0  

- (* 11  /0 1  234 *##   (6* &   *- 7% & * *   &   *7%   # (%  * 89284    

  ) #    5  *   $

-  # *-8:3; %

  ( *( *#   &  ( % * ;3284 *-

  3<=9(## *(

&  & **# *&:3:38:39 284 >** *?* *+6   2;4       % &  ( %     @#- * /%%0 - % *   68    &  & *7%      ( &  8<3:8::A ( * %*  *          *7% -  * * &*7%-     5  *   &    # *7%   8=338::B5    (* & * & 

 %   #   * % & *  5 *#      *  %     *        *7% ( *( *# %  294 *  &  & *    &  (    ( *(  *7%     *% ** *&  * ;3284 3<=9 * 2A4    -      2 %0  

4   (

& *%# 2 3 84*#

# *(%  51 *-& **(#  

(   #% *# 5  # *( %  51**( ?*3: #   

  *(  #    % #

   3:   &     ( *(  

 2B4 %

 *%  

 -  & % *0 &  ( *( & % * ;3284 3<=9 *    2C4   %* 6  %   ( %     @#- * /%%0  & *7% ( &  8<3:8::A  > *#

 *  %%  *   (   *7%  -     ( 3::;8:39 **(  * *( #%  #  & (

%" % ** *&  * ;3284 3<=9 *1  %  (  (      * &  *# - #-@  2<4 (6(#  (  * (   1 *%

*% 

-&* #       *#   &   *"

( % ) ) 2=4       (  ! - 5   * %   %* 68 & %& ( % ( &*7%( & :<388::B1 6= & - * *(   *7% (&294&

 #  * 

 *7% 

%-  * *( #%  

8D$ *& %7% (

 #% & (" % * ;3284 ;9 3<=9 *% %* &0  23:4  # %         -  "%% (6    5  (#    % #  (   # 5  - %

 *%  

-  & *  #    #% & && (" % ( ) 2334      6*#  %   ( % ( 

%-5  * %  %* 6; & &*7%( &8C:38::B294 **( 6< &   &       ( *   *(      *  1  %  (     &    (" %  ** * &  *  ;3284    3<=9 *  1   (   *   *  %&  2384   ( #  6B&  39:A8:3A  *0 &    6*  *#    5  *D 11 &   6<  -   *#         &%1 & ( #% &(& (  % *) )

 23;4 &    ( !

%-5  */ %* 68 & 5  &*7%( &83388::9  (# #  3A    &  -       #%   * * *( #- && ( % * ;3284 ;9 3<=9 * 2394 *  & 8C:88:3A  63A-#   *(   & *    

   *## **%  * *)  ) 23A4  3; (   -&  9B ( $&%- 5  *  5  %* 68 & - %& ( %( $&%& &    3  ; %  & %7%  %*   

9B5  &*7%(&:3:A3==C5 *7%  *#   * 

    %  ' ;;8C  3==C& * &# :;:B3==C&   & 

  % * &   23B4 >*#

% % *   - (**( 63A &

*# #%   # 23C4 *-@ E- 0  %:A3:8:3B  9 (- * 

  *0 &           &  #% 

&

* **%  )* ) 23<4  *# !"  021 4 ($  

%!"> 1  2(4$ # #& 6 #  23=4 !"> 1 2(4$&   %* 68    &   % &  ( %   (

% / - 5   * %    5  (6   & *7% ( & A  88:C8::;  5  & 6*#  * 

 *7%  %& ' 3;8;:8::;  &5 #&

&

##  *      (% *# 0         *#    *#  &  **-    *   % ' ;8:B8::<% #&#  :;:;8::< 28:4   =    &  -   (  (   #    &  -    *   *(  #% & ( (  % * ;3284 3<=9 *1% (   3:    &     *% # 

&  *- #- 11  2834   &  & * %

&*#  * & ( 11 %   -# B (

  & #     *(           %    * ,% - %      3:338:39#%*  & **# * :3:38:39 2884 %

 *%  

-    *%   *0 &  * *# #%    *+ * ( 28;4       &  - #- 

8 ;     (  /

- * %    5   #%

 8 0  B # *    8    &   & *7%( &8;:;3==;1 < & - ((  ( *(  *7%  #

& * %   *  *7% &  2894  $ *- @  E- %   &   A #- #      ( *   *(      % % #%   

    **%     $

* +)* ( 28A4      (  (%- 5   *  5  #%

<0 %* 8 & &*7%( & 3C:8:;8::B5 

   *#      *      *7%  - 

 #%   (# #  = &  28B4 *- &  :A3:8:3B  ;8# (  #% & * 

**% #   $ * +

 28C4 6 #  *#     &      %* ; & %& ( % (  %%-5  *  5 ( &*7%(&89338::95 D& %6 *%#6(*# *# (  * *7% 5 

*%   &  (     %  *     * ?*  (# # 6;

9 !6B3C:6 '68:39-& * (       *(     &  & (   %  ** *&  * ;3284 3<=9 * 28<4 $ *- @  E-  0    * & * #0

# (  #

(# -##  #%         &   %  ** *&  * ;3284 3<=9 * //./ . .   28=4 ' (  *%  *  

  %

*&  *

  2;:4  *%     #    *   #   (* *(*#   *7%      # &          *#  *%   *  ;3284    $

*-3<=95 - &(-%%&  

  *       *7%    0        * *   (* **#  (0 (  * -&%#** #%*

* * 89284 8:3;

* 2;34 )  

%  (       

           !"#$  * 7% F# *# G& #

 * ;3234 2843<=9 *- *  *%    %** *# % %   6#       ** * &  &-  *7%  ( * "&-& 

( ** *- # ( 2;84 (

-&%  (&  * * 892848:3; * # &* # 6 *7%   " *&  (%*7%

- ** #     + *  

.0  "#  *%# * *

 % "       # &      6  #-  %*   

   F%* %G-    *7%  %*   *  

 

*   %#%*   *

(0   (# &0 ( ?*% ?*(  "   5 (# &0%

*# %*   * 7% *

 (% *7% - # %  %    ( #  *" *-&% & %*  "&    #%  8:3; * 2;;4 **

 /234 0 &!

256"   ( !

  " /25$7892: 9$ 

256" 66