← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14510/2016dismissed

Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And ORS v. Permanent Lok Adalat Public Utility Services And ANR

2023-08-22Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj11 pages



 

     

         



 !"# !$%&%"'())*  



   +, 

  -  

 

+.

+  ++- ,-

 -   

( / +

) -, -)

)              

      !" #   $%& 0000 , -)

1 ) +    '

((                 ))*)%*)+,- ./012  3(,

 0   ( $4)&.5%*)6   12 (5 $%&*7))%*)6 8 (2   9                    1       " 2   :

( 2%**& :

  $% ;    < ((   !             $ .*).)*)) ,=(  $ .)40   ! (>>4#<    ' 2  (  %>*7%*)& !  1 12  $%     2  ,: '=0     



 2: '=!  %%*>%*%&:  (2!      %4*/%*)&  1 (1(    $%2 ',  (2'

 0!

   &))%%*)&!   $%(!

   , '=0! (1  !      )&*%%*)6   !  (2  1(  $%  (     '=$*)5)4/! )>)*%*)6:

 (2!  ((2 (2*7))%*)6  (  (21((     2    !  1  12    .  1      ?32   ((  

 %%.'    (       )/4>  ((   %7/7>&+5.    @ %*)&*7))%*)6?    1      %*)&.)6    (1  (25.   2  (2  ?: '=     ((2      (2:

2

 A   1!  (21  (( 2 

 (     ( %*)&$1 %*)6!>>4#< !   '  ( $.&*5%*)&*7*>%*)& :

  !   1B     (( 1    3(,  0    ((  ((   (  %>*7%*)&  1 (  12  : '=1 -  )%  



      ( 1 ( (2      :

 1 C

)%>7**5.     !       ! 

 !  :

  !(     !

 (  1(           (     ( ! (2        ! ((1( 2    (2  (2 -)1⁄2  *)*+%*)&:

(  !  3(,  0  

   

        

 

                

         



  

              

  



  

   !

   "   

 

        #

  





  # $          %&$

 #     !

  '"    ()*    

   



     

 

 

 

 #   

   $  



   

 

    

#    

 

 #   

    * ++ !

"    



      #     ,

          #

    

   # 

    - .

      #   

     

         

#    

   *     



   

  

  

       

 

  /



   

 # 

      0 

 

    



  



     



    

     

    

        +1 )  223/

  

#

  +

  

#

  4            



     / 

   * !

"    



    

 #  

       

    

        ,

      

      

       #

+

  

  !

 



  "       

   %&$#        /



  

 

 #  

               

              



 

    

   ,

      

    5 



 

 6 

#     



   #     

  

      



 

   7  23            

   

# 

  

                

 



 



 

8 





        #  7  23     

  +

   

 

 

    



 9  2   

 

#    

         

      # 

 4    

 

  

             

    # 

            

   

           

  6 

#   

       

     



#    

 

  



 



   



    # 221 23       6#    



   

  

          



                  

   

     

  

  

 

  

#

  5 

        # :      

  ;

          

 

<      !  1( ' (              (   (  $&*5%*)&*7*>%*)& (     12 " 2 ( 2  ( 2'  (2 %*)&.

)6:

     2  (2 (    !

",!

" ((((( ((((( (((((( 



 !""!#"

$ %&

!

" / 



    0

 

  

   

   #   4

  

             % &



 $   !$  "!%&$!$=""     



   #

 

 

 



  4 

 

              

   



        )  ) 

  !(  !$="" 0



#          /  4   

 

        

      

        %)     >

 ) 

  !>) !$=""      .

  

   4   

 

     #

 



0

#?, !

" /        @  A#        



!

" /     0

 

  

      B;  :

C  > B   4       4   



          

  !

" / ; :

C >      

  # 

   #

?,

" D;/ ) 4 0 

 "   >



 :



     .

 :

>

  8  



 " ;

% 0@0 !

",!

" ((((((((( ((((( !" ((((((((( ((((( !" / 

 #

 #

 

  #  

 

 

 E 

28,   F.         

        #

  

#



 

 

 #

 



#       !

",!" ((((((((( (((((" '(  %&

  82   1  (        3(,  0   (   A   (   1

( '  (        .( !  A     1   (     2   (       .  1 < (   A    2   ! A  ((       .  1   !

         

(  .  1 (        %%*5. #<     ( "!    .(   (  2    .  :

  2! ((2    '(  ??   ( '  (      A   12  :

 .  1 (        (2 1          2  "   .  1 2(  (( %)*4%*%&  2!%%*>%*)&"!   3(,  0 ((! 1   ((  672(2!*)*+%*)& ' (     .(            A  : '= 1 1%>*7%*)&((  ((    1 (  :

    ( (        = 1   $)%+)  %**+%*)&  

-    ((  1(    (   1  ! 2 :

   !  ( 2:

  (1(            1  (   : '=     (2        :

 !    (1(2 :

 A   (  12     -    '=1  12!

 1((! < (    '(  77, ?0 -  1 ( ! (('( >)%  !

  

 )  >    0 

 

  B  B      

   

   

 



)

  # 

  

      ,+1  )   223 G          %  ,+1  )   223       

  

 #

  4                



    /    

  

     , 

   

       

       #

+

  

   !

   

     "           

  %&$#         /      

   ,    





 

  

     

   D  

 

   < $!  1 ('  ( 1( 2        .  1     2       2  .2( 2  )7 2D!  B               "         (   1  ( 3  2%>*7%*)&((   1( 2   21((!   @  %*)&? (  .  1 !(((2 A     2           ( 2  (2 " 2!(2       !   (           !      

( 2%**&:

( (   !              ( :

  .

 1 1 31  !(-2

*

?    (  (           (1((!   1(  :

!

        ,0 :

    1( : '=%>*7%*)& ,0 ((     ('  ( &*5%*)& *7*>%*)& : '= 1(  ,0 :

 (  : '=  ( 1 1  12     ,0 :

  (2  ! (1( ( (      ((!      !

  : '=  ((!$  (2   (1(    ,0 :

('  ( (   21((  (  ( 2  1   2    ,0 :

    ((          2    ( (   2 ,0 :

=   : '=@ %*)&1  ! (2%%*>%*)&:

! %4*/%*)&$  1  (2 (     ( 1(  ,0 :

       (2     1  (( $1  %*)6      '  (          (2  &*2 : '=((!



,-0 =(2  1(   5 (5  ( 1      ,-0 :

1((2( ( (2 ,-0  3(,  0 (

 7+  :

( 2  %**&  (   !

   2 1((    !  )7 2  (2    1 "  (2 (E112 )7*>%*)&!

1((@ %*)&! ,-0 :

     (    : '= !     (   2   1((  @  %*)&       ($  1 !!

2  (!! 3 (((2!

(

 1  1  %>*7%*)&      ! (      %+*+%*)& :

    (2     ( 1                 ! ( %7*>%*)& ,-0 "!   (( !  .2:

!((212 ( (    7+ :

( 2  %**&   )7 2E   (    :

 ! (

)7*>%*)&   !

 ( 1 ((  (2   ,-0 :

    1 !     (   '  (  1       7+  :

( 2 %**& ! (1   1(



!2(   : '=    ('  (  $.&*5%*)&     2  ! ((2 ,-0 :

 3(,  0  1     B  12  (    

%%.  (    )/4> ( A 21B2 ( (B    ( B  ?  1( A  3 1(!

 ( 12  ( :

 ! 12  3(, 1( (2  01A 21B2  (  (B    (B :

 - 12   3 ( , 1( (2  0 ! (  1   (2    !   (2       2      ( 1(

(  !         (((2   2   2     12  ( ?- 2    ( 2!   !   !  :

  (2 2     (,0 ( ,0    (2        , -)

 ))*)         

+"

  .

  

8    ?H8* .

      ?H8*