← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18703/2013allowed

Moti Lal v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-09-20Mr. Justice Darshan Singh16 pages

    

!"#"$% & '



 

     

 

 (%)*(+,

   

 

  

   ,- !

#

#

 



$%& $%$

#

$' ( 

)

 *  !+!,-$ 

    . 



    # / .  0  1

 2  2



#

 3 # 

 **

4#    # #   "   #

      

     

    

*  

 # #

&5561   .*





!$!,-7 % (       ) 8



#



 # 

 ( #



#    .*



*!7!,--  $

#*



# 9 *:  ;  "

      "   

 

   

  







8

0

!-!,--# *



  <

   # 

# .   !,,$0 

#  #



'

) 

8 -++ !,--



. 0





# 0)  "

# 2  2 #0 





 / (#

  !555561 "

 

# 

   #









*

0  

 



  #



!555561  "

 

) : * 8

 !-%55$  

*  



  "  

# 

.

+  

   #  

0

    *   

 = 0

$!%55+ #



 

0



  

  2  ;#1((  #   #    #    

 

   

   



*    >(8 +$ !+!,-$

*





 2 #   

1 

#

*  & (   

#0

#



 7 % .0) 

  1!

1! 0   ?+5@ 0 #  8

0

!,!,--A 

B>  %-!,,!





0 *

7+@#  

5!!,,!= 0

$!%55+ "# 

 *

 

*0!7 

*    * #

 *

#

 . #  02  2

C

D 

 

9

   

 E  =

 # #9   0

%7%55+#

  #  



 9 * * 

 7   )  

  F 

      G     !,-7             * # #

0.



  "

 

 

#  #



 

0



*

  = 0

$!%55+

0 

-

 # 

D    





0

0  #9



 * 



%5%55& *

D    





  

 0

#

 " 

  ,  # 







  

  )  )< 8 !'$!5%55& 

 #

 #       0      ;

  

0

 !,  %55&

 



9 

 * 

# 

  



!5 ( 



)      

%7%557



.



#  !$!,-7 "





0 *)< 8 !$&$,%557 "  # 

 H 9   *





#

0



  0 * 

 * 

 = 0

$!%55+

  #

#





)   #     

*      *

  

   0

# #

#  ;

  D   D

 

 

 

*

#    0  * :*   

   



  0 #  

# # *



#



  

0



 *# 

 ##



 # #   

 

!!

  

  8

0

!% %5!5     )<

8 !$&$,%557



#

   *  

#

  0

%-%5!! #



0

#

  9 * 





  !,7$!,--

#



0 9

 





0

 !,7$%55+ 

  >

 **





  # * 

0

*

 :%$%5!%0    





!% (

 

 

.  

/ 

0

# ,   *!7!,--

*  %&  !,--  #



   #       0  #  





*   !$ 

 *

 !,-- %55+  

#  !,7$!,--   D *





*

* 0

9



  !,7$!,--

0  9 





* 



#



 0 * * !7!,--0 

:8

* *  



)  

8

0

!-!,--#





+- *

!'

  

 *

0

#9 



   *

# 



0

 



0   *

 (   

 * :*

C

* 

 %557

  







# # #  

0 *

  "



8

0

!%%5!5 )< 8 !$&$,%557 

    A

C B0

0   8 0 0

 *) 

#



1  

  %5!5   #  0   8 



  * 

* *



0

#

 0) 

'   9 

 #  # # 

0

%55& (

* 

0  

    # 

  0

 *        #      

    *   

 = 0

%55+#

 #



 

0



*

# 







 0





* 

*   

 0

#

 #





!+





 # 



 

 ( 

C





0





 7 $ .0) 

  ! !# 

0 #1 

         



 



    

    

!

"  "

        "  

      "     

"

" " "

 "!

  

!  # 

!! $  %% !

   



 



   

       !

 " !!  "

&   

!

" 

 %      

             

"

" ! 

    

    



"

'  "

 " "        



 



  

  "

(   ! "

  ")"   







 %

 "

!

! "

  

 

   

!

"   "

  !  * + !   



 %

"!

 "! !

"!!

 "  ! ,   

!

" " $ "  '    " $"       " ) !       !" !"!!

   

,  " "!  "!  !

   "  !

  !

   " "  '

-+! %" " $" ' 

   !

 "   

 

" "  

.+! %" " $" 

   !

 "   

 

    "  "   "!  !

  " 

!! !    

!  "  ,          



 



     "!"  !

  !

 " !

 

#"

     







/ !& 





!!%5!!

 0  E

 E  =

 # 





0 0 

   

 7 $F$G ) 1! 1! "

#1   123, 4 "&  1235  , 67 5  !

" "

  7!8"!!

9" 9 8$.   "

  ::&;:;<&:-:$.-     :&&=::

 :&&=::!!" ! !  %  % " 

!'&'-&-+,4,!

6 3 >  ,") ?%4" 4%4  9 :..=::  

  @  ;=&;&';;'" *$ 0@ A"

  !

"

  % ")" " 66"





 % % ! !!" !

 !  !!" !

# !

 "= %

 

 "%

 +             )"!

  

       !

66"



 " "     !

( %"



 5 ;

;;;&$  " 

 66"

 " %" %"



 

  @   !!%  3    !

 



              

  "!



 " %  

   !

 

 

" "   5 ;;;;&$ ! 3   " 

  )" 

" ) !  

!   !



   /

 "%"

 

 ! >  ,") %4" 4%

!

   "

 

        



:&&==:&;&';;.!"  "

  "  " "  ,") 4 

!

5"   B$+,$+                !

          !

     "%   "



"  !

!

/ !7  

                %%  %5!& 



!!%5!!#



#   

#





 "

# 

 

 0 * 

#

 0  0 9 ( *  

 



#

0

"

 9 # * #

# 



# 0

&



 "   0

0 *

 /

 

 





# 

 

  





 

 #

0

* 

 0 0

   *0

  0



   .

8

1

 *# 

# # 0 * 

 

0

0 0 *





 8  

 

 * 

 #

 

 

  

 

0 *





# 

0

9  #

 E

 E  =

 #  0   

!-  D   #       

     #

 

 *

  9

 

 !,--%55+ 

#  !,7$%55+ #





 *



0

 0

 *D *

# 

 

!,7$ !,-- *

!, (  

      

             



 

 7 $  %5 (    

       

 #  9   

#

  . 

 !,--%55+ *





.  # *

0

   * .    "















#





%55%#

) 

C

 



*

%!

( 

   





 0 D     0 

   *



0  " 

 0  # *

 *

# 

  



  #  



  #

 /

0   0 





0

#

?+5@

7+@

!7 

* +- %55+ "

  

#  0   0   

    #

    #

#  

 #   0



 



 

  

 #0

  *

 * 

 = 0

$!%55+ 0  

# %%   7 $        #      #  #

  



 0 F$G 7 $ ) ! !

9

!!%5!!  7 $F!G #  #

 





#

0

 0 

 

 # 



 

 





 

9 



*  #

0 









0

*#





 

 

 

0 #

0





  %$  7 $F%G # 

*  

#

     

0 F!G   



0

 /

 

 ## .   



0 *

 #

#  #

0

  

 



 





0

%'

( ) D



 7 $   #





 (#









   

 7 $  



# 



# *

  0



 * 

#

 





8 

  7 $ #

 *  



 " 



     

  * 



*  

 1

 

* D   0   )  )   /

 

   

 / 

# /



  

 D

  9 E/



#

     

  

*  "

   /

  3

/

4  7 $

  *

*  0   1

     0)  )  

 D  #

 



9 





.  . 





   

19 *#





 0

 





  

# "   0  # ./ *

 

# %+    !7 0

#

#

# # 9#9

 # 0  #    



/





 

.  0  

9

 *





* 

  0



 =

*

9

 * 





 

 

 !7 



  

 .  0 #.  "

 

   0 HH



 0

  #       *  "  

 #    



    

  

 *   

  

0 

  0

 0

 

*

# 

 

 



 . 

# *

0 ) )  0 *  0 



* 

%& (



 

  0



 !!%5!! # # 





/1!  * 0 * *

0 0

*



 # 

  9 

 ;

  #

0  0 9

#



 #    

 

 9   *

  

     

  

    *  





   0

0

#

 *



*

<





(9 %7 (##

 





 



  0  

# 



 



 *0

#

 **   0 / D

 # 

* 

0 

0 9

 *



 !7 #

   %- (

0



 #0

  

 .0) 

  ! !0



$!!F%GFG

)  ( #

  0

 #

/

0   #  

(

0 *

* 



*   *  )  %5!5

0

 

0

*

#

  0 

#  

 *  

* 

. #  02  2 #

#



/ 

*  

#

!555561  



0

9  # 



(# 

 !,--%55+## . 

 

# 



 

.   #      

/  #    

         #

   

   

*           

  0

 * 

 # 





    



  #   #  

   0  

   

9 # *# # *0 #

 . 

 #

##

 



* #   0





     E

   

   *  :*      

  8

0

!%%5!5 )< 8 !$&$,%557



  

0



 *#  

 #

 # #  "



  0

# 0

  "

#

 





D



= 0

5,%55% )  

8 -++!,--



C

 









*

0 " 

0

 0 

9 



 

%, (  

 





# 0

#   *  0







 * +-  %55+* #  



 

9 

 #



 # ( 0 9



 #

 #  

#



0

 

*

      #  (   9  0

     









0



/ 0 

# 0 

 "



0







 !7  .  (        0      

   (



   # 

*   # 

  

 

D 

 

.

 /   (

 

0

  *

. 0



   

  ###  0       

        # *  

      *    

  *  

0 .  "    

#

*  0

# 



!7  

C 0

    0

 

 

 *#

C   $5



.

00

D  .  



.



 

 



0

0 *



 !,7$%55+D *





/1!



0  0 * * 





*

  E



*

 

0  7 $F$G

0 

   

#

0







 *

9 

 

 



  0

#



  

*



=

  0

%-%5!! 0

 

 >  %7!,7$

' = 0

$!%55+ 

#

D

0

 0

  1

  

  

  0

  0

/     



         

# *#

9  



  

"

 0   *   0

# 



 



  $!

# 0

 0,1      & '

 . <

 9 *6



I <

 0

I