High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/533/2008allowed

(O&M)Geeta v. Union Of India

2016-11-22Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan6 pages

!!"##"!#$ ()*

"""""""++,,'

* -.

""""""" +'

* "%0!&'

()*

1.

"""""""++,,'

* -.

""""""" +'

*

) 23 )" 4 5 34 . 6 )."/,4"4

78 7.1++,,

911 )."1 4/.

78 7.. +"

#"

:11.1+..

, ,;

++.<=9,,;

1>/?<@ !"

9...1+..."

"

:11.1>/?< 1/,9.+. 1 @ 6"6 6"6 34 "'

3* =1

?,>/?<7 1,,

+ ;98<

++, "" 6%6!& 6%06!&7.

?/ 1 <

"

!A"#"!7

<+ 9=1.1/ 9- ..

< 17?9/!=.

7.8,, < 1, C+.

.< 1

4+ ?

8,

"0A0A0"

:11>/.=.< 4+. +,.<"!

6!6 "#"!7 9/ #! #% < ?17

. ? 1 ++,, 7 1.; 18=./ 1" 1

B 1 , ?1 .< 1 . ;. +,.< " #

" 1 <;1 ,71. . << ,=;

1/9,;

?=;1

,7 . /,;1

1 - .. 1

1,,;1 >

?. " < /1 5+ ,?

7;1

1; ./1./?14+. 7 <1>

?. B1 - ..1

1" . /,1

7911< "

1;.

<71. + 18B1 1911< /1 .; ?, "; 1 1 ,,;.<1. 1 < .

9/,'

1.21.

9/,2*7;1 ,

?1

B; .D/ ..B 17< .7?9/!=.

B18 ;11/?11 +=1.><, 1 ; +./ ;1. 1

;.B +

9=1+,

7 9/1

;.+./ 9=1++,

" ?. ?1 /;.

7?

1 '++,

*7., 51 ,7 4 ) .7 ; C< " 1 < .7 ;1 ;

.<,.7 1+.

,?;

1 69.1.

.<

7;

11. /,1 5+ ,?

7;1

1; ./ 1./?114+. 71 1 1= 1 ;=11 + ," 1..7 ; 1/,1 6 9. ?1. .<

"1.

9/,B18 ;1 ; ;

,,/, < , 1

1; .=

1. .<1

"

66 181.1,. / , .1+. 18,

./,,=?1./?11 ,"

1+. 71).+.

1 ,"1 += 1 +.

, .

1 1 1;

1 ;

;. . 8..<1 " 1 ;. <+/.

E

7;1

1;11/?11.

,

7;1

1;.;

11+,

7;. +./ /.

?18 79/1 ; 1, ?8,

11.171 1 +./ =8 1

..= <11

;..?"

;7 < ? 1 < D/ 1 , 9 = 1 71 '++,

*

11.1/ 9- ..

,?;

11.< 1,,;.<1. ;11.

/,= .;

1>.B"1=,,1>

?, ;.1 9= 5+ ,?

7;1

1; ./1./?11 , " 11.

171 < .7;1 <,.1 +7B1 1

169..<1

+,.<"!; .=

1. . +,.<"#"1..71; 1 9=1 ?

" 1

/.. B+, < ?1"1

C< 1 < . 1;

1 4+ . ,;= 7 8., +

?.

6. .<1

1 /9/.9.

79/.<,,=

.<< ,(C+.

.

"?

18 71.

1 +./ 1+

88 1;11

.. 11 ; .=

1. .

69. ?.<1

+,.<"!

+.

71;

9= 5+ ,?

" 1.1.

8. 5+ ,?

;

C< .1?/..1.

8. < 1, C+.

;.C< + 11 ; .=

1. 7 . 1+,.<"#"1..71<. < .7;1 ; +. 1 +1 <

7 9B9 .9/,1 <<9=1++,

"1

7B 1'< .* ; ,=;=.

?9 ?9,; 8=.

?;

+9,B;

?1 D/ 1

/, << =

<"

.

?1 . +11

1."1..78 1?, 1+.- ..

+.871 < /,9 1+.< .";8.7

71?,

+.8"

-.

.91B. - >= 5/<. 1.

7'!&*A4/+.< /. %!71+C /.1 B1 ;1 1.

8,8 1

711 .

, 9 = ./,=, -", 1.'#&$$*3# C!$%;

,,++,="1

8 1, 9 =,=

9,+.811 1

8./.1 8 ,/ +.8

4 #!061 7#A&A"4 #!061 7#A&A7,= ;

/. 6 F#!06"

<+

//;.

"6 :1 1 /.

;.B ?. ,;=/;.

/.

71;11..1.1 9=;.?/, 7 ?, ./,1+.1. ,;=<

. ;/, , +

?.;1 1 9 >/. . 1 ++

?.;11 9B ,,< . 8.<? . + 1.71. <

. 1,,7;

1 ?=1 ? =

6%6 1.,;79, 9,+= <+ 1C <= 9+.

91C,=.,

9=1 1 >/.=7+

?. . /, 1/;.

.8 1 <+ 1,,9+=9,/.

1

9=1. ,;=<

. 1+

?.

/.

>/.=/6 '*

.<+

9=1 <G '9*

, ,

>/.=G '

*

; < , G '* = << 9=1 < C

.

=G '* = /., / .

. <

, . /.?

, .< /,

1 .< 9 <

.= /

>/.= / 9=1 /;.

"

C+, "6 .1+/.+ 1

7F+

?.H

,/ 6 '

* . .8/=G '

* +.

;11 +/.

1 8,

B..8,, 9=. ..= ?+

?.

7=.8, +,.<

B9 < 8

</;.

"H 1+. 7

+.8.<1 <1 ++,

7 ;1

1 ; .9/ 9= 1 9= , ? ? 8 11

1,, ; 1

1. 7;1

19 ?C+.

. ?118

++,=.;< / "

< , . 9

6$6

,, , ,

>/.="1

,,.<1.

8. /.4 #!064 #!1 7#A&A"9

71 1.

9/,

.?...8.

"11++,

.,,;"1. + ...+= "077(6

1++,

(++,

;

1 . 1.AI+./< .<1 ?1 <+ ,,+=<"

11++, .,,;" '5 34 *

!!"##"!#$

>B :11. +B ?(.

:11.+.9,