Joga Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"
!
JOGA SINGH # STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS
$ % &'% () ( *
!
" #"
$
% & ''''' ) ( * + #,- ( ) *
"!
+! !
,-% + + *
$ ! (./& 0
1++23
#
4!
56(&7 (88.%8(7!
,8. ,%8 6 $ + (-78 0
16+23
$
+
) 9
:
9
0
;! <(3 $$
4!
$
*
**
(-8-%8%(0
;! <&3
$
"! *
-2-
4!
!*
8/8%%8%8 0
;! <%3
) + =! $
> $
"! *
$$
+!
$
=!
% >
9 $ $ +! ?6$$4
(/8%%8%% &(8&%8%%
+!
*
**
9 $$ & ! !
* + =! $
* &,. %(8,%8%%> $
;
! !
< 1
!
" # $ %&%''%'%"
#
$
!
( "
)
# " #
"
!
* , @ !
$
!
!* **
*
) !
"
$!
!
*
A #"
$ $
-3-
% &
$ *
!
56 $$
4!
$
4! 7 B $ $
9
!
,-%++ !
,8. 6+
*
%78&%88- C $ ! * +! $ !
+,-
!
'/
'%%'
0
1 2-
3//4'%%3
5&64,%74,%64,3845, 9! 9 :
( (
#
(
#
;
4<
$
)
#
#
#
;
#
;
(
-4-
'/
'%%' ( 2 /
= !
<
-
. #
# #
- " "
#
" 33
'%%,"
#
-
>
#
< # #
" !
;
#
!
" # "
>
#
-
<
'/%40
-
"
3// 3& '%%3 9 :
"
-5- (
<
* / 5!
"! *
(.(%(..7
! "
##$ %&&'
$ (
+! $ !
+6
= !
$
=
" ; = !
" $
"
"
" !
#
$
"
$ " #
# * ?. .. .. .. .. ?. .. .. .. .. 33
"
#
3/%,3667( 90'
# # <
0
4
<
#
( 90'
# 3' ( #
"
<
8 '5%3366/ 9
@# 7"A
,%74,%6 9 ! ',3 '/3'366, 9
:
")
-6-
,'%4/%7 9 !
< <
* - > 56
!
,8.6+9 $ 4! )
+! "! *
(%((%8(&
!$ ##"
%#
$ (
)9
9
!
+= B
!
) # = "
'%%5'!! 888"
7
33" 10 +7 * + , - ! .! /
- 0) %&&" 123 44 1 3 "'%5 1%&& 3 "2&) !
) $ A B
#
$
,8' !
.
C.
$
"
"
# ;
33 .6 ! - 0
/ - 0) %& 1%3441 3 '
51%& 3%'& )
<
,8'" =!
;
$
-7-
- " !
"
#
; " "
;
#
"
" ;
"
<
*
0 ;
; 0 ;
$
<
(
"
3,7 53%8'%3' 9
" @ (
D
,%69! <
<
: <
* .
*
7 8
98
4$$## '
$
%,8&%8%( 569 4!
9
!
+
,8' !9! <
38/ '6%8'%'%
,%7",'%"3'%0)9!
,%69! 9
)
" E
%8%6'%'% ( 90'
* #
# "
0
#
"
-8-
) !
:
F 9 $ " '%%& 5 ! ! 3%/'" !
$
<
38/ '6%8'%'%
,%7",'%"3'%0)9!
,%6 9! 9
)
" E
<
* (8 > 5!$$
+!
*
+(6 /
1 989/ 35
"1#3441 3%
!
B'8 "
!
,8' !9!
" " 2
!
2 2
$
2 '6 : 6 8 (8 6 8 0) = B : "
1 + $
#
"
"
* 5%
$
#
$ $
"
" !
"
-9-
#
;
$
53 "
5'%6 !9!"
"
,8' !9! 5' " " <
# $
,8' !9!
" "
" 2 $
2@
" 0 "
!
,8' !9! "
"
$
55 # #
!9!
!
,8' "
!
<
0
5'% !9!"
$
5,
,8' !9!
C.0@
-10- !
.
#
0 = !
# ;
,8' !9! =
" = !
!
#
. 0
# !
#
" 0
" "
!
#
(( > $ $
$ $ 9 4!
"! *
9 $ ) C $ ! * +!
*
'Gian Singh Versus State of Punjab and another,(2012)10 SCC303'. Still further, the broad principles for exercising the powers under Section 482 were summarized by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of 'Parbatbhai Aahir @ Parbatbhai Bhimsinhbhai Karmur and others versus State of Gujarat and another" (2017) 9 SCC 641'. 12.
The petitioner stands convicted vide judgment dated 07.02.2020 passed by the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Shaheed Bhagat Singh Nagar and had been sentenced as under : Sr.
No.
Name of the accused Under Section Sentence Awarded 1.
Joga Singh 409 IPC To undergo RI for a period of
-11two years and to pay fine of Rs.
3000/-. In default of payment of fine, he shall further undergo RI for a period of one month.
420 IPC To undergo RI for a period of one year and to pay fine of Rs.
2000/-. In default of payment of fine, he shall further undergo RI for a period of 15 days.
(& > C $ ! * +! $
*
& ./$, 0# ) ( %01 #02 !
(
, (345& *
9 F $
!
*
9 !
"!
;
*
$
)**
! !
!
4!
9 9!$ !
$
+! 4! 56
9
$ *
*
>
C $ ! * +!
;
!
< 36 - 0
5'%!9! !
<
H
;" .
$
=!
,8'!9! # !
( 3,' ! "
# ;
5'% !9! "
. <
"
1
I $ " I
-12F
# IJ#!
"
4 '% = #
0
0
"
# ;
( 3,' <
< #
-
1 "
# #
>
# #
# I
" $
"
(
# "
.
#
<
#
I "#
$ " (
# I "
# "
" #
<
I "
;
;
'%%% 366/"
#
#
"
I ."
(
# 4 ; # " <
#
" "
# 0
I "
$
0
-13-
4
< (
I ; (, !
$ "! *
9!$
$
;
) 9 "
! C +! !
,-% ++
# )
!
&%8 ++ 6 !
$
*
$
$
<
!
!$$
$ $ )
$! **
!#
!
)
4!
$
> "!
!
,-% ++ ;
9
!
!*
9
" ! "!
6 *
;/ /<
%21#3441 3 " " 9 !
!
&%76+ 9
!
!
*
*
% )
**
!
) $
+! 9 $ $
$ !
"! *
, <
98
&1 3441 3 # / <
%&&"1 3 44 1 3 #& $$9 *!
&%76+ $$
9
* 9!$
*
*
5! *
"! *
8.8&%8(/
46! ! "
$ (
/< <8( )
+! $ !
< B
(87
<4: ( )
%%1 3441 3 & 7 < 8 ; ) *4
% 13 % &") # $ =!
-14-
,%3 !9!"36&5
$
"
<
#
# !
#
3,&
( 7 < 8 ; ) *4
% 13 % &"
<
<
!
#
"
$ 36%3'%3&
( " ; # #
<
#
$
3/K <
@ 9 B
A #
( "
<
<
B (A >
$ !
$$9 )<
+!
*
780 9# 0# ) ( :; 0# #$# !
+ - +#. ,-4"6 16.
Thus, it is clear from a perusal of the afore-stated precedent judgments that once the power to quash the proceedings in view of compromise has been held to be vested in the Court in a pending trial,
-15such power would by necessary implication be also available with the High Court in a pending appeal.
(/ > $$9
$
* * !
$ 9 $$ !
4!
$*
!$ *
9 !
,-%++ <
3 > 569
! *
)
!
!
9
9$* )
3 >
$)A8)
!
*
$
9 $$!
!
$ $
9 $$
9#$
3 > 569
) %8(7
!
*
$ $ 87 )
3 >
* $$
!
*
$
$ # $) $ !$ * $$ v) >
4!
!
9!$ #
)!
$ $ 6 $ *
#
+! vi) +
!
!
! *
$
$ # $) !
<
)$ !
$
-16vii) >
$ # $)
!
$
) 9
! !
3 $ !
$ ! 9!$ )
!
G ix)
! ) *
$
!$
) !
* $ !
)
56 x) > *$
$ # $) ! !
+
!
$ # $) 9
"! $
* > " $9
9 $$ 9
$ !$$) < ;
$
* ) 18.
In view of the report of the + =! $
a
$ $ 9 ) ; +!
=/<
1
% 3% # # 9 $$ 4 / <
8
% 0 #2 $ ) 5!$$
+!
(6 / <
)
"1#3 441 3%
$$9 > FIR No. 136 dated 10.09.2016 under Sections 409 and 420 of the IPC registered at Police Station City, Nawanshahr, District Nawanshahr (Annexure P-1) and all other consequential proceedings arising therefrom 0#;1<804!
on the basis of compromise dated 18.08.2021 (Annexure P-3) entered between the parties and the judgment of conviction and quantum of sentence dated 07.02.2020 (Annexure P-2) passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Shaheed Bhagat Singh Nagar is
-17set aside. However, the same would be subject to payment of costs of Rs.10,000/- to be deposited by the petitioner with the "High Court Bar Association Environment Protection Fund", within one month from receipt of certified copy of this order.
$$9 +) ( *- ' 2 !
F B #
? H ? B $ H ?