Rahul Goyal And Others v. Ut Chandigarh And Another
!"!
#$%%
)(#*
+" ,
-"%
&#*!.+&#*#
,
#*
+0$ #12( +%'"
%3%4(!% + $ +%-
#5'0+6*-
+"% 7777 %3%4(!6%89 : %
"
!"2 !#. ;
#'/ +& +!#. &+ '.&9!*
# !#.
2+ ; /#* 0!
-!*<% % +) +!#
#'#* +3
#=> +%% %!" +?'"&!#.
%@*
*%%<6+ .!"
*'#* +3
#=@6=<> 6>@6 3 #6 3
&#*!.+& ( #. A!
& (( "'2"
*!#."6 2"!" ## C*
*=%<%% %
0
#% =% +% D!- 9!D6 **(% &#*!.+&6 " #
&( #* %6 A&!( +% +'# 5'0+6 *-
6 /'
" !# // +# #2 &( #* %% % +!
"
+
+ % A" 0++!
#* % #%>%%
+ "%#*+ +!#(A#*
+!#(A #* %% %@*
*%%<6A"+ .!"
2) + #* % .!#"
(( . & + &-!#.
# "'2D
+'
) #* +!0!#( 2+ & +'"
!#!#.
& %E +# '#"
(
#*" A!
!#
)2 "!* " 0!()0
&"!* "6*!"/'
0 #."
" &" 2
# 0! 2() + (- *6 -!* ##
=%<%6 #* /+ " &- (+ *) !( * /
C" !#*' ++!.
6<6 +*!- 2)A) 0'
'( #"
#* "!*/
!" / #*!#. 2
"% #!"& !#6 **(% !"
+!
'*.
&#*!.+&%
-#
/+ "+ *"'#* +$ % BBB BBB % F& # '# *!
" !# !+
0/ +0 "6 &2!
"6 '.&
%6 !
&" 2
!0/ ""!2(
(!- #* "
)
.
+#* !"# &# !+"
)!#.
.
+"A!
#*&'"2#*%& 0++!.
)(#*+
!&" 2+ ;
# !++
+!
-2() + (( !#
" #* /'+/ "% '
0/ +0 ( *!
#* "
0!"'#* +"
#*!#. 2
/+ "6 ( #"2
+".
+!# *G "'( # ()6 " "
+
(!- "
/+
()% A6
# #* & (/
0 0!() #* +!
#*"60
+&"2
#"
*0! 2()A!
!+ +
A!((#*
#"
6 A!
#) /+ ""'+ (( A!#.
#"$ % &
&/+ "&- .+
A!
&*+A(( "
"C 0/(!# #*!#. .!#"
&
+ 2
+# #* '
+!
"%
& /+ " &- ("
.+
.
%@ *
*%%<6 C"=@6=<>%3%4 # 3 #6
&#*!.+&6 ?'"& # '# 0!2(
+* *!# &!""
*%
- +6
#*/+ )"&((2 (!2 )
(!0((.
(*6 "!(- + D (( +) !# ('*!#. * A+) + ! ( " '++ () !# / '"
*) # %@ *
* %%<6 C" =@6 =<> %3% # 3 #63
&#*!.+&#*2
&/+
.
!+ (!0"/ !#!#.
#)* A+)+ ! ( 6D (( +)
% ! !
0!#" !# '"
*)
+ /+ )% & "
#* /+ ) "&(( ("
.
& + 0!#
## (!0 '#* + !#*' ++!.
6 <6 +
4 # + 0 ! 9!
6#*3
# +%% %.!#"
!+"
/+ )% 2% & !
&"2
#* !*
)(#*+
!A!(( !( D
# '#* + 3
# !#*' ++!.
+.+# 0'
'(*
*!- *!""
('
!+0++!.
%
#*/+ )A!((#
(!0#) +!.& !##)0 -2( +!00 -2( ""
!+"
/+ )
!+ 0!() 0 +"
+ !#(!H 0'
'( *!-
C" !#*' ++!.
% !+"
/+ ) "&(( .
" & + (!0 (!0 #)6 /"
6 /+ #* 0!#
## ?'
#*/+ )% % & #"
/+ )&"#
!# *2)
+'* +'#*'
!# ('
%
/+ "'#* ;
) "&(( *&
&!"
C"
*% *% &
" "&(( 2 + !+ A# B/ #"
#..!#.*-
C(A) + !(!#.?'"&!#./
+
= %@ *
* %%<6 C" =@6 =<> %3% 4 #6 3
&#*!.+&6 #* ("
0'
'( *!-
C" #* ++
+*!#."
"!#
(A#*
/+ ! !
/!
D'*.0 %I @%
2 * "#!#
.+(/+ &!"
+* +% % +# * **(% %%6 6 &#*.!+& #* ( +# '#"
( // +!#. #2 &( #* %"
)&- # 2D
#! * "A (("(("'2"
/+
*!#."+!"!#. 06 + ?'"& *6 2"!" 6## C*
*=%<%% >%
/!#.!#-!
A 0
+&"2
" -!* ##
=%<%6
+" &- (+ *) !( * /
+ 0'
'( *!-
0/
!#
+0" 6/+ "&- !*
.
?'"& *6 " ("
*&
!" # !0/ *!0
&!"
+ !"!#. !
" !#& ?'"&!#. #*(("'2"
/+
*!#."!#+
!#
D'"
!# -!
A * !"!
# !# 5'(A!#* + 3!#.& #*
+" -"%
'#D2 #* #
+ 8:
8 +!0!#(: " # '"
'( /'+/ A '(*2 *2)/+ #.!#. (!
!. #%
-# + * !"!
#!#5'(A!#* +3!#.&1" "
8"'/+:!"+ *"'#* +$
!
# # $ % & ! '%
! % ' % %
!
!
) ! % & % * + !
, % +*!#.()6!# (!.& "!
#"#
*2 - 6 %@ *
*%%<6+ .!"
*'#* +3
#=@6=<> 6>@6 # 4 3 #6 !"
+!
3
&#*!.+& " A (( " (( "'2"
/+
*!#." +!"!#. 06 + ?'"& *6 2"!"
6 ##
* =%<%6 ?'
+"6 "'2D
" *&
% %
#"
#*"*!"/ !#
+0"%
%% -. &. / 4&
+"/ ;!#.C+ "
$ "C 4&
++ $ "C