Pal Singh And ORS. v. UOI And Another
!"# $ %%%%%
! & &'() & ( *
!"# $ $ + , & ,
& - . " / , &'() & ,#"
.0$ 1"
! !"#$$%## 1 , ,&'
(
)
* $
+ ! ,-$ "!"# ,$& &(& *)* &, &$, & , $, , & 2 1 " 3
! "# $ % %# $ & % '
( $ %% ) % * (
$ &% $ +# , "# *
$
*
$
%%
&%* &'
% '
&* - $ +# -( % - ( - -* * #* -$ '
#
$ * % . # $ % *
$
$ %% # - #-/ %% (#
0 - # ## -$ $ * % . #
#
%% 1 $ # $ - $ $ %%
$ ( (
% -$
"#
"# # &% * & ( -$ $
# #&'
# ! 0 $ $ % $& $ % $ ( -*
$ "#
$
$ $ %% 2 ) , $
! ! ! " ! &
+ $+4 5(5* (66'78
-9
(66':
!";!" + , (56-555 *6((6- & ( . " " &
, ( $
+ $+4
5(5* (66'78
-9 (66':
!";!" + 4 ** (6()78
9< (66': *
** (6()78
9< (66'
/ #$% $ #"
6) 7"
8 $
" ,
( 8 $ / &
( =&, &
$ ,
66)(66- $&
>"
4 $ 2:
,$& 4:
4:?
,4:/+<@
A" <5- 4 $& &".#/ +:
, &
, * = , $&
4:?
,4:
" "
B
, A" )6'5<94"$ ('6'5<9:
)6'5<94"$ 6*695<9:" " +-C'
&<5- "$ " & &
22@ A"
4 & $+:
, (<6'5<5 $ " ;*6D
;(D ,
"&$" <5-
/ " A" "
B
, 3
? 7*) " / 7) = 7(- - 8 , , $&@
4:
,4: " +< <5- / $
7" ,
66)(66- &
, 4:, / ";7'6
/ "
3
B , "&$" <5-
) 8 , , $&
7 "
, ' ' ( )* '++** '
* ,- ( ' " ,
"
4:
,4:"$ 7" , " $&
, E1 (? E1 (?*, ('6'5<9" " +-<5-
4: "
B ." "$ &" / " A" , A" $ "
, 4:
4:
,4:,$
, " $
)* + , '
( 9 ! " $
" " $& 4:
/ " A" "
B , 1 &7'
7(
,, & , " / ";
7'6 " " A"
, $ $
" $
, , .3
< " " $/ "$ "$ $
4:
,4: 5 = " &$ ( + " & & "$ 7 ?
" E17 * ,
,
, "
,
,/% 2%#3/0 01 $%4%%4 56% * 7%$3 %+#% +#%8%#% (*6'5<'
="
2 -F 76
7(6
6655<'
="
2 -F 7'
7( 6655<'
="
2 -F 7'
7(
(-6*5<9 ="
2 -F 7<
7'
(66-5<9 ="
2 )F ( 7*5
7(6
'6-5<9 ="
2 (F 76
7'
'''?
)(5<9 B <F 7(
7(
6<6-5<9 B F 7*
7( -9(?
6<6-5<9 B 'F 6 7-* 7(6 <-<?
656'5<9 B 'F < 7*) 7'
)'<?
5
&" $
$ ?
" 4E17 *:
"
& & "8" 1 " ="
2 , A" "
B
" $
4 "
B $ )(5<9 " $ "= , 1 & 7'
7( , , & $&@ "
4:
,4: " $ " " / " 4: / " 6
4:
,4: "
,46<: "$ 3
,/%012%#3/0 01 $%4%%492:;/$ 56% * 7%$3 %+#% +#%8%#% '6<5<)4 (?:
B F 7-6
7* (6
<6(5<'4 (?*:
B -F 7*6
7'6
)655<94 (?):
B (FG' 7-)
7 (< )9?
(65564 (?9:
B * 7-<
7() '6
6<6555*4 )?(:
B 6 7 (6
75 (6
)6'5<54 )?*:
B ) 7'
75 (6
)6'5<54 )?-:
B ) 7'
75 (6
6695<54 )?):
B ) 7)
7 '6
6 8 " $ $ '6<5<)4E1 (?: <6(5<'4E1 (?*:
1 " +- $ 8" " , A" 7 (9 (< *9 *< -( -*" ,"
B ,
5 '6<5<)4E1 (?: <6(5<'4E1 (?*:
7 *6 (5 &
2" 4E1 (? E1 (?*:, 1 & A"
" $ & / "
" , '6<5<) 4E1 (?: ,F "
B ,
;7* (6 & $ / " $ $ ?" $ 1 " / " A"
& , / , ,$& .0$ 1" 0 1
02 H ! // $ $( 3%.4 , " 1 $ ", / " "
& A" 7 (9 (< 14 4" : 1 " 3
4 6
'
&# % $ & % '
% - -
$ & &% !
&% & # '
%
&% & % (# -
$* & # - $ & &)
# #-+# *'
%% * +# # & , # $ $ #7 &* # - $#
$ ' 56 57 (
*78 !" % $$ /, ( "# ( $ (8 96
( 7&% ( $ & '
# $ 7&% '
$
$
- $ '
- % .
- &%# * ) (* $& %'
# ( &
:
*
( $
- $
-( (
%# (
-# & $ +# 9 5 ,
( -
011 (
'* !","9$$,# ( /# - $ "#
# % $$ &
#& ( &# % - $ '
"# *
# 7&% # % $ ( ( '
( # $
# &* - & ##2 ( 2 / " 4E1 (?:
'6<5<) , A" 4: ('6'5<9I 1 && 6 $, 4E1 (?: " " +-<5- 4:
;<D " $ , "
4:
,4: * 8" / " A" 4: "
B " (9( * / < , '6<5<) 4E1 (?: "/
";'6D ,"
",
1
$ A" - , A" 4: "$ " & " + " & , " " J " &1,
"" / / $ "&$"
" ",
$ 2" / " 7
-'
99)?
"
$ ,3
#3/0 ( + = !K '6<5<)4E1 (?:
7* (6
;<D& 6 * (6 66666L-'
5**** 4= !L :
K* ''
5**** K* ''
5*)?
4" :
"'6D * ''
5*)G( (6 ' 4!G'6D!:
K < <
%/53% $ < < "9 03 4%4011 )
& / " " +-<5- $
< < "98%#%
4:?
,
$
"&$
& " " <5- ' , " , &
, 9 8" "" &
, 4:
4: $$"
&
$ 1" , $
,I "$#" & & " $& < ! & 6'6)(6('
/
,. B /? M B $ 3 M