High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2156/2009allowed

Jatinder Gulleria And ORS. v. Kulwinder Singh And ORS.

2025-09-22Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl13 pages

! " #

$% " & "$% ' ( ) * $ +

+% , -'-$ % + +

*." / + ) * $

'$'$01

) . 2

. +

* *

/ )

.* $

. .++

, ",

' 3

$+ ('* . *.) *

+ (4 %* 4( . +5

$ .+ (01 '01 * $ + .*

(7$01 5

*+ +

+ * % $

$ +

+$ %*

($44$01 8 47$01 6 '9 5

* * % $ $ :

+ % * ,

+ +

.* 4 5

+ * , * '01+

% +

+* + 701 +

, /++

$ +

$ ;1($ ;1 ;14 5

*+ ;1( 3 $ !* < $=! < $ = .

/++

+ +*

*.! < + (>1 ?6(

.+ ++

($-'01 .1> ($7701.>1-5

*+ ;1!+&

$?6 %!/35 3 + $= $ * 6+

$ % + ?6'

.+ ++

>-01 . >1- 5

% ;14 "

", &$

# " $ 35/ = * 6+

$ % . @+ ?6> -

6 $>4'01 + ++

$'(-''

.>1- 5

*+ + % * % . >1- ..

+ + /++

. >-$016 +. $ % %

+ 01+ 5

.+ + * %*. $*,

% *% % $

+ +

+ 701 + .

%. * 5

*+ + *

: 5

+ $

*.= A* +/

##$ "%#&! !&! %! !

'(() * +'+$ %! #,- !

% %

#/.

"% !

# '(+0+**1($ 2 3

#,- !

&. % %

# , %# ",", !

# '(+1+1+4(

> 3

+ .$ $ *+ % %

, %$ $+ .

+ $

701 +*. $

*+ % . . $>1- 1 > %

. 5

+6 * % +.

+ 701+ %

.1>* %

+ .

* ($018 ($-'01B ('-019 +

(> 5

*+ % ,

. 1> %$+ .

+ + (01+ 5

+ $ +

* /

. 6

% % * 3

+ . *+ %

* +

- 3

$ ,

+ .$ *+ %

!"# $%&'( ) !!)&*+,!-.(/'&.0% ! 11 234%.(&5+2. 0*&+3%, &( 4%' 6/,73%.5( 28 &'*& )%'3&9 '&.&: %5;+ - &73& %.%'&*.(/'&.0% .023% 2.5;*:(

2.5;*:(#

../&*(

../&* #

%,/05+2. !

/5/'%4'2(4%05(

< /*5+4*+%'

# 2((28%(5&5%

/.%'&*%>4%.(%(

2((2802.(2'5+/3 &'%.5&* #=

> @ 9##9

+*+&* 42/(&*?( 25&*0234%.(&5+2.

.5%'%(5

< &5%,(%45 &3%-+7.&5/'%(28,A20&5%B+5;2!

&*0/*&5+2.;&'5 .023% @ #

> @ #

4%':%&' /5/'% @ <

%,/05+2. !

%3&+.+.7 #

/*5+4*+%' > #

2.(2'5+/3#=

> 9##9

/.%'&* =

2((28%(5&5% =

25&* =9

*'%&,:7'&.5%,

.;&.0%3%.5 #9=

C+.5%'%(5

7 )

% %

*+ *.

% *

= A* +/

4 5#-# 9* % 1 D%5;%'%82'%;2*,5;&55;%3/*5+4*+%'52E%/(%,(;2/*,E%&( 3%.5+2.%, +. 02*/3. # 28 5;% &E*% &E2A% 4'%4&'%, E: &44*:+.7 /(&33& ;23&(9 '+*2F ;&.,'& &., ;&'*+%9 B;+0; (5&'5( B+5; &. 24%'&5+A% 3/*5+4*+%' 28 = 82' 5;% &7% 7'2/4(28 52 &., 52 :%&'(9'%,/0%,E:2.%/.+582' %A%':8+A%:%&'(95;&5+(

82' 52

:%&'(9

82' 52

:%&'(9

82'

52# :%&'(96+78!7+ !79.

#9 &.,

82' # 52

:%&'(9 5;%. '%,/0%, E: 5B2 /.+5( 82' %A%':8+A%:%&'(95;&5+(9 82' 52

:%&'(9

82'

:%&'(9

82' 52

:%&'(&.,

82'

:%&'(G *% 4(. $ + (4

* ( ) = A* + /

"%5# -# 8 9$ "

.A+%B285;%&82'%(&+,&.&*:(+(9B%4'20%%,52'%02',2/' 02.0*/(+2.(

;%5B2 "/,7%1%.0;+.&.52(;%A+(;2/*,;&A%E%%. B%** &,A+(%, 52 '%8%' 5;% 3&55%' 52 & *&'7%' 1%.0; &( +5 B&( 5&F+.7 & ,+88%'%.5 A+%B 5;&. B;&5 ;&( E%%. (5&5%, +. &'*& )%'3&9 & 6/,73%.5 E: & 022',+.&5% 1%.0; 5 +( E%0&/(% & 022',+.&5%1%.0;285;%(&3%(5'%.75;0&..255&F%&02.5'&': A+%B5;&.B;&5;&(E%%.;%*,E:&.25;%'022',+.&5%1%.0;

(&6%(;;&(.255&F%..25%285;%,%0+(+2.+.%(;3& H/3&'+9 B;+0; B&( ,%*+A%'%, &5 %&'*+%' 42+.5 28 5+3%9 5;% ,%0+(+2.+.&6%(;+(.25&E+.,+.74'%0%,%.5

D;+*% ,%5%'3+.+.7 5;% +.023%9 &. &,,+5+2. 28

< 28 &05/&* (&*&': 52 5;% +.023% 28 5;% ,%0%&(%, 52B&',( 8/5/'% 4'2(4%05(9B;%'%5;%,%0%&(%,;&,&4%'3&.%.562E&.,B&( E%*2B 5;% &7% 28 # :%&'(9 (;2/*, E% 3&,% ;% &,,+5+2. (;2/*,E%

<9+85;%&7%285;%,%0%&(%,B&(E%5B%%.# 52

:%&'(.0&(%5;%,%0%&(%,B&(E%5B%%.5;%&7%28

:%&'(9 5;% &,,+5+2. (;2/*, E% < 05/&* (&*&': (;2/*, E% '%&,&(&05/&*(&*&':*%((5&> 9)# -# "

- # :# # 86

&!.

! ! 8%;

#.9&.&,,+5+2.28# <285;%%(5&E*+(;%,+.023%(;2/*,E% 5;%B&''&.5B;%'%5;%,%0%&(%,B&(E%*2B5;%&7%28# :%&'( % %!!8'9<:"

- # :#=

2 !87( !9(.

#&., <B;%'%5;%,%0%&(%,B&(E%5B%%.5;% &7% 28

:%&'( (;2/*, E% '%7&',%, &( 5;% .%0%((&': 3%5;2, 28 0234/5&5+2. ;% %(5&E*+(;%, +.023% 3%&.( 5;% +.023%3+./(5;%5&>02342.%.5

2',%5%'3+.&5+2.285;%3/*5+4*+0&.,95;%,%,/05+2.82' 4%'(2.&*&.,*+A+.7%>4%.(%(95;%5'+E/.&*(&.,5;%02/'5((;&** E%7/+,%,E:4&'&7'&4;(

52 28&'*&)%'3&B;+0;B% ;&A%'%4'2,/0%,;%'%+.E%82'% 9)*"

# - %!!8 , %&% #"= #% %-

% "

= % :% " &2&" 7' !8 " >, 2

9)0"

2 !8 "

- # #"!, = "

=#%#8!&&.%2

, %&% 9)1 #!= 8%2, #!-!?

%!"

.!## !8 #

!##!8-!#! %, 8, ;& # ##"!, = #+9(((@6#7((((@6 #+9(((@6 #& - %?

8! #% !, ##"!, = "- "

!8+(<%

. "

;%'%8%'%.0%+(&.(B%'%,&002',+.7*:&55%'(E%4*&0%, E%82'%5;%&44'24'+&5%1%.0;G *% &+ * %*.= A* +/ + .

+ 2 * ,

+ &*0 1+. 6 . (( ) = A* + /

2 3

#,- !

&. % %

5#-# ,&* %

+$ *

+ )

* % % &+

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

42/(&* 02.(2'5+/3 +( 7%.%'&**: ,%8+.%, &( '+7;5( 4%'5&+.+.7525;%'%*&5+2.(;+428&;/(E&.,B+8%B;+0;&**2B( 0234%.(&5+2. 52 5;% (/'A+A+.7 (42/(% 82' *2(( 28 0234&.:9 (20+%5:902 24%'&5+2.9 &88%05+2.9 &., &+, 28 5;% 25;%' +. %A%': 02.6/7&*'%*&5+2.G &'%.5&* 02.(2'5+/3 +( 7'&.5%, 52 5;% 0;+*, /42. 5;% 4'%3&5/'% ,%&5; 28 & 4&'%.59 82' *2(( 28 4&'%.5&* &+,9 4'25%05+2.9 &88%05+2.9 (20+%5:9 ,+(0+4*+.%9 7/+,&.0% &., 5'&+.+.7G +*+&* 02.(2'5+/3 +( 5;% '+7;5 28 5;% 4&'%.5( 52 0234%.(&5+2.+.5;%0&(%28&.&00+,%.5&*,%&5;28&0;+*,. &00+,%.5*%&,+.7525;%,%&5;28&0;+*,0&/(%(7'%&5(;20F&., &72.:525;%4&'%.5(&.,8&3+*:285;%,%0%&(%,;%7'%&5%(5 &72.:82'&4&'%.5+(52*2(%5;%+'0;+*,,/'+.75;%+'*+8%5+3% ;+*,'%.

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

% 0*&+3( . 0&(% B;%'% & 4&'%.5 ;&( *2(5 5;%+' 3+.2' 0;+*,92'/.3&''+%,(2.2',&/7;5%'95;%4&'%.5(&'%%.

E% &B&',%, *2(( 28 02.(2'5+/3 /.,%' 5;% ;%&, 28 +*+&* 2.(2'5+/3&'%.5&*2.(2'5+/3+(&B&',%,520;+*,'%.B;2 *2(%5;%+'4&'%.5(+.3252'A%;+0*%&00+,%.5(/.,%'5;%05 8%B+7;2/'5(;&A%&B&',%,0234%.(&5+2.2.5;+(02/.5 2B%A%'95;%'%B&(.20*&'+5:B+5;'%(4%05525;%4'+.0+4*%(2. B;+0; 0234%.(&5+2. 02/*, E% &B&',%, 2. *2(( 28 +*+&* 2.(2'5+/3 #;%&32/.5280234%.(&5+2.52E%&B&',%,&(02.(2'5+/3 B+**E%72A%'.%,E:5;%4'+.0+4*%(28&B&',+.70234%.(&5+2. /.,%' I2(( 28 2.(2'5+/3? &( *&+, ,2B. +. '&.&: %5;+ (/4'&.5;%4'%(%.50&(%9B%,%%3+5&44'24'+&5%52&B&', 5;% 8&5;%' &., 5;% (+(5%' 28 5;% ,%0%&(%,9 &. &32/.5 28 (#

%&0;82'*2((28+*+&*2.(2'5+/3G *% &+ $ +

$ +

+ + +* + 0 % ( %

) *

. + (' + (4 % *

4(. ?% +

($01 '01 %.

2 $ + (7$01 *

2 * )) * .+

+$ +

$ $ + +

($44$01847$6'9

+)* :

2 * % + ) % *

/ (' ;

+ .

+ $ * %

% * 6+

+ 701+ ;1( 3

!* < ,

/++

+ +$ *

*. ! < % .+(>$?6( $

.+ ++

($7701.>1- ($-'01 .1>;1!+&

$?6 %!/3$= * 6+

$ + ?6'

.+ ++

.>1- >-01 ('-01.1>?% ;1 4 "

", &$

# " $ 35/$ = * 6+

*. ?61> 1-

6 >4'01%

* + ++

$'(-''

.>1-) % * .

*. ) * $

% *

*% *

++ .

01+ ++

)

$ ,

+ .

. 6 . .1>+ .

+ +

01$ .

*+ %

+ + 401 +

+ $

* % * ) $ +

4$7$01 14.

% *% + $

. (((7

+ '

. + +

4$7$01

+ +. $% &

()*(+,(- .

! &A+.,%'H/3&' ; ,

0 C 0D ;* C 0D