Ram Dev Soni v. Pspcl & ORS

 
   
 

! "#$#%&'

(") *







      

    

 
'& +,'-
 .-,

 



 !  " # 




   " #  

.-,*  $          

!    

  % &

$ # '( ')+',

- .'/  " 

 $0" $  

1 #, "/#"  

 #'20 # "  $ 



#0 &

$ #  #  0      "

&   

##"0 "



   # 3


! 

 +454

 " #    

  ,

## 1  

1/  

 %      $        #   # "0      # "  

 # $0 # " '+ )6 +475

   . 

 

"

   '2 )6 +44) # $  # $0"    0# "  

 #48+*8'20 # " "" 

$ 0!

1  #$ 9    $0" #"  

 #4 0 # " #+*0 # "$ '

     $0"   $ )'

'))6,

- .(/!

"  

 #'20 # "!$   # $ 0"  '+ )6 '))'

#!  '7 ++ ')++! 

1     #    ##    

        #   " 

   " ""   ## 0"

" "!"

 "" "

 #

# # $   

""0 .  

  #     #   #    

 #        #    0

#!"  '( ')+',

- .'8/  $ "  #    $0"  0$       #  #    

         )'

'))6  

'+ )6 '))'!      #" 0      9   

# 

 " #  '( ')+',

- .'8/! 

#  0 " "  $  0  

0 #

$ 9  $ 0 "

  #  !" 0 #
'!)7!*248. 0   #  0   :# 3


"  $   " #  #  !-  )+ ')+2 9 

  "

" "  

 # 0

   $  #  #

 

9  "   #        "$  $"  #"

9   

   $ )'

'))6  # $0" #"  

 #'2 0  #   "     $       

1     #  

'+ )6 '))'!  # "  0#   $0   $   $   '( ')+' $  

## $ 

## #  

   # "     ## 

 0')++

9 # "  #    #       #         "  "    

0 #

$$  

#

;

" #"  9  

 

$  """ 

#"  00

##   $0"    % 0 ""    # &   9       

#$   # 0    <!$  #       "      "



     

$  #   &   

    "





$

$   

 #

  #   "   "

$   $0$ "         " "     

0 #

$

/   #0 "

!  0  ,/ #  " '7 )5 ')))  " '7 )5 ')))

 0!

 " .

 



   

   

 !"#!"""# $$ %  &'!# # ()!)%*!+ , !"""

- ./   0 %121% %%--3 %$/$$2 4  41  %%  -  -  3   $  /$  $ 4   41      420   42$!&0 11 51513%1 # &+6# # ()!)%%"' )) )'''7/ 35 %/0-$73%1*(  -#1--1-5 $- 2 41/ -1  %-  3  2 41-1#-

3  1 5$ 4-%$.3- %   21#  0  -  21  12$0 % %  1  %   21  $  3 3  4 / %2 4#%51%2 41  -#1--1 %- %2 4-1#-

3  1 5  /7  )8- %  !& % 0 1  $ 1 5  -#1--1/2%17--1 -3- --1$-1#- 9-3- 21 5 - 41  -

$%5 4/$%//1 /%-9

3  2 4 ,/-17-$ 32 41-/% $ -1/$ :

! 

-1   %  7  /  $$5  $ 4  ) ) '8 7-   2 .

%    -  11

%   

 3 11  -4    /  %51%  1;



2 51$2011 &

-  -  %1  1   2    $$   %   )',# # ()'++  %% !& 6 )''" %4%% $ 44 47

4 (-3%

-

 1

3$ 4 ($9$20 3 %$%52 4 41

7/ %%< 1$-4201 $ 7- 5 < 191%20/ 17  $ ) + !"""  -  %4201= -

 17/2%112 913 20    0=  ./  0  %=  :

9 #   # #   # $

$  



#$  

%

$    "  $ #'20 # "

"

 # .

  

 #  " # ,/ # "  '7 )5 '))) "

" !"" 

$ !  "

    0

" ## #  

# $ 0   0# $  #

 $ 0"  "  

 #'20 # " !  " #           ,/  #     "     '7 )5 ')))    "

0  # %

$$  0

#   ## $

$ #  

   # "     ##"   "  $  #  "

 $0" $ #'20 # " " !# 9 "#      #  %

$! "  " .




- -$ 3 1  = << =23

/*(3 %3$ 3-2 4$  11 1 ;

1%--5/2 4%1

   11  5%  2 %3  3 # 1= >( $$ %  )8) !+())())% -5$ 3-14$ &0 17-4077140 $40  411 $5

/%% 40 $40/31 1!&0 1 %5 4  4117-% 712 -%1$-1% $$ % %1

1$ 

 % 5 01 4%-1$$7/.-14 1=7 032 %31-1 3 %  

1-$ 0= %#(

%#( 1-=

%%= 2 %3 3

 0=

?=   #0 ?=  = @A=<< =23

<< =23

B42-111 22%C :

  %

$ ##" ""   # # $

$ #  

0

1 #! #! 0

"

# .  



 $0 "   #  '2  0  #   "  "       !       #    !    

1     #        

"

 0 !

"

 # .

1   

 

  $0" #'20 # "!

"! ## #  

# $ #" ""  $ 

=   !  %

$"

  



   %

$$   

#

 0 

 $

  %

$" 0"

  "

 

$

   

# "9     



$  0 $  0#

  # !  '( ')+'

,

- .'8/ & "    "%  

 $ 

 #7>

#  #" 0   #" 0  

          "

&   

$  #&

$ # '( ')+',

- .'8/

 

  

 

? " 

.-,3   '

(") *