Kanwaljt Singh v. Shri Guru Ram Dass Hospital Charitable Trust And ORS.






      


   

   !

"# $%&' ()  "

*"+ ')",+"+-./0%
)"1%2"+ )" -0  
 




 " "-)+)& 34 

")0 " "# $%&' () ' "34$) ""+ &' () 34

""0  5 

  2)0 ")" 6)%% (""!! 3

7+"  8   1  $))  )  )  1  " ""  ".  0 "

,+"$""91 6,+"0+"0 "

')" 26)'" #,"(')1')"3 0+"')1-0"

2)0 "$00 . ""$)')",+"+ -./0%
)"1%2"+ 5 )" "0". %+""  %'+"("

 ) " ' )0 " )" $"%. ("4  0 % )%"+  %(

1$ )0 " )"0  "+:%%() +  . .1 )0 " ""4  )0 %))$ 1 ()"3" """!!  $+" "" (

).$).++%  0 "

')"26)'"#,"(')1 ')"3 0+"')1 -0":  ) ". )(". )+% % 1" ""

)".%" +  ). ( . 2)$"60 "

 ')"26)'"#,"(')1 ')"3 0+"')1 -0"$ .%")$"6)$ ( %+"" )"$ $"+1%$"6 ").) " 0 "

"4" )" "$ $)).++%   %%( 5 "  #.%&  ' ()  %"

 ' " 
+ %  $)  "

"+ &' () 34 1)% )-0  2"+ " 0"%. "

1& ).  1% )$"0 : +"())-0  2"+ + 0"4 + "4 (

("   ".)' + &1  "+ + ")(

')",+"+$""1 )6
.. $)) "1+) + 

)2"+-% )1 0% 


   !"#$%& !'$"()*+ , )-.

*-* )

& - /)0) , * $)" %"

' (%9 ) )
+")%))" 0+1%%$%.  4%4 0"42"+. ( ()%%( )0% ". $ +     ".',
2) &+(.  $+0)%

 $$#'&!'$2   ,()*3 , )-.

*-* )

& - /)0 ) , *, 4, , '%'5!'$2 ;+")"." "% )%1

0% &+(. " " *) /-1)6)) , *.

*-* )

& - /)0) , * 3

, !'$"789
!!2"(+) + %%($+% 1. 1%$"&+"  ) ". $+%%%$)"

 "   "  "  -)+  )&  %"

  + %  "  ) 0 " 4). %   )$"$+%1.  1%(  )-0  2"+1 "%  (+0 )4 9 )&+(.  ) +"" "  )3

)-  *-*:--)6()***3 )
1) )0 -*  3

, !''"789
;'5$)" ( ) .2"+ )1 )%)/()
+")4)0$"+$"

 % +"

+)"  "+. % )'1+% <

)"0" "1 0"

". (0+1%+ =:+"()) 4 9 )  )3

)-<*4)* +0")0"+)1& "  " (+0)-0  2"+ .) %+

)) + 0"

". (%+1%)"1%"% ")".  )+.  +

" ( ".4"+%.  $)"+) + .0".%+  0"

".4%0+1% +   0" ( ))%) )  +) + 

"1""% ">+% + >+%%  .6" %%$"+%)"%"% 4%4 ) 0")1 .1 0"::: )
 +  9 "( ( )." ) $))")""

" "!!  4%"  )>+ ) 1  $))"$"$+%1.  1%( )"0  2"+ ."$))  0"  0"

".   0+1%

+   "  0+1%  +  1+  "  +      (".   1$  )  ( (
..  .0%  .% )0 ")" 

:

)%  ,-= )),>--1

-= )/

.

,)*  +)6  -) )  )?)   )1 *)  6))=  -*     -,) 7$5#59!

2# $)%)4 0+"% 0"41

$)")')  "%4" "

%

" $+%1. 1% )&+" )/()
+"+ "3"%

)
 +

:

 "+  $" . .+ 0"4  +" )0"4 1 0"

". (0+1% +  $))" ".%% 701 0"

".1 )'+)"2)'+0".
+"+ % 0+) +1  )0%  "4"  ) %%$ ($"
 



  
     



 

    

    

         

  

  !   "  # $    "

       

   " %



  " 
  

  
      

                  



   

   & 

        

 

     

  '     

     

 (       

"   

      

)

"        

 



  
! ?4"

1 $)0"

". (0+1%+ "0"

". ( + )'. 1%)&+" )/()
+"+ "

3"%

/$4" 
+".+7"""  7") 0$" %  $)) 4%40+1%%$0+1%+ 2)" " )  " 46 ()$"&+"  $))").0%  

))"( 0+1%+ "0+1% +  " :

&+(. " "1 )/ @1%'+0".
+" :,))->)*

,.* 1  )

&)1))*1 )7!'$$9!

8"5)1 )%) $)")%)0+1%%$)""" 4%4>+ " (+

)0+1%%$ +   &+1 $ 0+1%%$".

+ "3"%

$%% 1  A :

" &+(.  '+0".
+" *1 41 > * 

 )  ) 4.*  & ,)7!'$%9;

;!#))% + "

B
    

*                  ""              

  

  "

     

 "   

 +  

  " 

 

  

         "     #   $  "    



      ,  " 

    "  

   -

.    $

"      / 0  

    

  &       

    



 10&   

  

   

       

    102 " +   

          

 

    

    +  

   3 

,   

 

 +     

 "

      

  , 

  %

"             

      $  ,       



       

    10'

 (  # $   "

              

   

 

 10'

    "

 

  



4



    

  

  

   

   (      "  



 " 

   "   ,       "

       /         "

 

   

        104 

"   

   

   

   

 

 

 



    

  4  "   

 

     



 10  '

          "            

  "     

    +

   " +

   "  "     

  "

" 

 

   

(  

       

" 

   

(   10    

                      



           

       



!

   

              

     

  

     

         !!
  



   

  "

 #  

 10   "  "    "   

 " &    

#"       

 "  

 

       

     $    

        "

         

  5    "  "    "    "    

        "  "     "   

  "                   " 

          

   

               $



              





               "        

     !!
  



      

    

   



   

#  % 

    





  

 

 

   

 



    

  



  



   106      

    *  



       

       "    



  



  "  +    

   

  



   %



 10 (  "     

"   

 

 



       



 

 

(          

(   

 &  ' 2)0+)" "+ " """)$+1 ) . (.   + %%($))"+ ) + (4 1

)')",+"$""1) 6
..2)" '" "% 4") +   ( )2"+ "1.  "+. % ) ' )  :  "80+1$ ). (. )0 "$))%" 0"40+   0+1%%.  4%4:

 )"0  2"+)"1""% "%%(%%

$)"("

+  0+1%. %6 )   ("   .   + (    7.      )  %6   %    ) 4 +%  $"$+%1.  1%)%  ,-= )4)*

7*-3)93.%"4$)1 6  (1)6) *-* 1 <* >141) , *!''!7"9
"!8

3 ,        "

   



   



      

            

          "       "  

   

        



" 

  

    " 

    

   

 "

    

  

  

             "   

 

  ,  "         "         (        #   $

   $  '  "  

   "

     , "

      "  

           

  +

 +

"







"  7       

  # $ " 

    8     



"

       

       

   

     # $ "  

       $          

,      

  

      "    

 

 " 

     

(      

    

& 9:#  &  "                  

   , 

         "     

 " 

   



     (   2) #: 5  8   (         ) 

     )         *  + ,  - &./'.(01!2!

)   ( 

    /%
 

             



     

  

         

 

   

                    



   

                      

    



  

   


 2)%$"%+0 1 )0 "  )3

)- * +0"$+%1 (+)1%  )4 9 ) $C ."$))0" . 1 ( :$

)   7  )  ) 
+"  )%  )     +  0"

". (    +



".%% 0"

".1 )'$+%170.0% $)) .  3"% )
 + :

  "1""% "

">+%+ >+%% 2)0+)"( " """.6 ( 0+" (+ "4    -+% % $)+( ( )." ) )% ) $"$+%1.  1%+ "3"%

)
 +

:

 )%0+"% 0"4 +"   4%4 %+"

)0" )-0  2"+0"

".0+1%+ 2)0 " "%(". 4%1%+ "4%%$  2)$"0  0 )14". )?$5!'$; 7

9
   ))"06 (D"  E