Manish Dhingra v. State Of Haryana And ORS.
!"!
# $ $ %&'
CWP-15694-2015 MANISH DHINGRA ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents %'
CWP-22689-2015 SUNIL JAIN ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents %'
CWP-22769-2015 BIJLEE SINGH ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents % '
CWP-22799-2015 JASBIR SINGH ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents %('
CWP-33315-2019 PARVEEN KUMAR ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents
-2- % '
CWP-32807-2019 RAJESH SHARMA ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents % '
CWP-32778-2019 M/S MAPCO PRECAST ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents %)'
CWP-32827-2019 TARUN KUMAR BHATIA ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents %*'
CWP-32850-2019 SATYAWAN SINDHU ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents %&' CWP-995-2020 AMAR NATH ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents %&&' CWP-32814-2019 YOGESH KUMAR ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents
-3- %&' CWP-32831-2019 RAMAN NANDA ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents %&' CWP-10959-2022 SUNIL KATYAL ......Petitioner V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
......Respondents + ,-+$. /
.$0 11111
Mr. Ravinder Rana, Advocate with Mr. Naveen Kumar, Advocate for Mr. Vivek Khatri, Advocate for the petitioners.
Mr. Pankaj Mulwani, DAG, Haryana.
Mr. Ashok Singh Chaudhary, Advocate for the respondent No.3-M.C.
/
.$02$%34'
A
! "
!
"# #
$ %
& ' ( )
-4- % * "
* * + ' +"
# $
% &' % ()) &' * +% &' )
$ ,
$ - %% %& &%. ( % * # # $
% &' % ()) &' * +% &' )
$ /## )
$ 0). 1
2
#34 0).(%* # # &
1 % &' %()) &'
) & 1'
-4 0%56.* # # $
% &' % ()) &' ) 7 .
%-
1 0 1 .* # # - 7 1 1
)&*% 5% . ## )*
&. 8 - &. 9 - &.:#!#- &.##5% .#9#* # # - 7 1 1 7
&# 1 '
;##5% <:!. - &.#9#* # # -
*' $ =)+. #9# * # # $
% &' % ()) &' * +% &' % 0
,.* # ' % ) % +
( ) % ,
"
+
- .
' ( + %
-5- -
& ) %
%
/0 "
12 3 "
+ , * '
' ( * * '
& 4 5 #,
+ ( + .
*
& +
*5 ( '
+ % %6 77 '* % * 7 (
5 ( . * ( 8 9 7/0 "
:1
"
+ 0* 6
( 3 9 *
2
-67 0 : : ; ( ) %
< * 8 9 7 +2 "
+ * =
)# /) #+1
- &
.
* "
+
*
) % .
+ % , ) 0
%88
.
+ - %
**
* "
+
*
#
+ % +"
"
+ 2 ' + +
- %
) #+2
*
> 0 *
2 %
+
*- &
.
-7- % .
) % * "
% 2
+ * "
+ * ) % + *
+ 9 0 % * :
+ > + + "
"
+
; 0
8 ( 3 * ? % ( * " * % "
+ *
) % + * .
? <? @ - "
.
+ : ( >< >
* 9= ;
8
-88 5 *
"
+ <
- 6 ) %
3 "
+ '
) % + "
?
"
+ + * *
*
+ +
, *
(
+ 2 "
% A "
+ "
+
% 6
< "
+
" < , ( ) %
* "
+ ,*
-9- ( ) % " . + ) 0
%88 ) %
,
% ) % *
+ ,* + %
, 0 "
) % ? % ( A 0 +
) % .
% ( ) % ; + <
"
+ * "
+ *
( *
% * ,
( ) %
* ,
2
< ,% "
-10- < , <
2
,% ' * "
*< #9
. * & %
+ + 1
1 * * >
& # 9 . 4 &
1 + *&
*& & %)
%
* %1.
% .+
4 & * +
)
+ * #9 *
1 ) * +%
$ 1 )&) * +% * >
& # 9 ) *
**%%
) & %%6 # 9
.
+&
&&* &
/ -* +
& )* . 1 % &&
1 * % +& )) &
+ '
*
)# +. &
'*%&+ )) +
'
1 ' ?& ) )
)1 %
) +%+
) * +%
1 * .+ &* && % + ' % +
) ##. +
+
?* *&
)) & &
# . * * *
-11- '
/1 ( ** + * = /1 (
+ + 3 * = /1 ( + * "
* = /1 ( "
+
2 3* /1 ( ) #+ 2 ) 0
% 88 *
-
. 2 + 2 /1 ( 0 88 * ) % /1 ( * "
#
/1 '
0 "
<
? % (
) % /1 (* "
+ 3 + 3 *
-12- /<1 ( * +
* % 0 :; $"
*
# /0 "
1
- 6 ( ) % ( ) % , * *
2
= 2 +"
=
= % + 5
.
> +
. <
1 % ( %
" "
< 0 9>; %
. '
< * 5 + * ( *
2 * ( ) % % * *
- 6
( ) % '
-13-
( +
? % ( A -*
- 6 * ( + - 6 . *
"
+
< -*
* 2 *
"
- 6
2
$ *
-*
? % ( * *
.
* * - 6
* * *
"
+ 7 ' ? &
4 5 #
"
+ - 6
* *>
+ + 0
+ ?
B # 2 >. *
" %
-14-
? >0 %? &
4 5 # 9 + ( 2 * 7 * * %
+
>%
' ' %/
.$0' - 2 3% ) 6 + > C>( 6 D
C>(