High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/639/2008allowed

Ayodhya Devi & Others v. Raj Kumar & ORS.

2025-12-10Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages

!"# $%&

'' ( !$%$)%*# $%& '' ( +,$-## %& '' (

& .

/ 0'

0 0 0

! $%&' ( )))) 0 0

+ ! , # -.**/--0 + ( +( ,

*..! 2 *3445! 6 +78! !

!/*9%*.:&,#

;0<= !

( 2 -.-4/--< / !

> !

# + +

! ! > + ! !+

0 000

! & + + # + ! + # !

+ # 9 ! $%&' ( # ,

# ,

! ! ! < ' !

# ! #

+ 0/

/1 0 . ?7+ 1 ( ! Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 2 0)+!3 $)!4 - 5 # # !

! & @30

!"#$% &$ !"#' % '( !"#) %

* +

),- . !%

/ 0

),- ),-

* * * * * * 42. * !'% !

2 %

6 "3! ")&, &" &) % 4 "5 &($, 4 "($"$) 4 ")$(', 4 "''"') 4 "$'(),

4 "")")) 4 6 )((, 4 5("() 4 )((5,

0 ?7+ 1 ( !National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 2 7 0 5 !

*..*.%&*.4! 2 *344 !# , & 58

, A

B 5"8 1

,, ! B 5(8 , ! + ! ,

B 58 + !

! A #

B C ! , ! ! !! , #

+B !& !

! , & @52. 7 conventional heads 8 0 + 8 &) ,,, 8 "

,, ,,, 8"

,, ,,,

8 0

1 :

(

;

8 ") ,,,

8 ', ,,, 8 ") ,,,

= *

",- *

> > > > >

59.3 * ),- 0 ',

$,- ',),

+ ),(,

")- 7

59.4 + !%

',- ',

7 &)- ',), ",- ),(,

59.5 / $,$&1 ? @

59.6.

1 ? A '& 0

59.7

59.8 8

7 ") ,,, 8', ,,, 8") ,,,

",-

4 ?7+ 1 ( !-83- %!-, % )!-%* $3+-%9 /:3:4# ; '

-%) -3 -,:- <)<!) -3

4<!

0 5 !

,0-!,- ;!3- )+!-!-%-9 04<:

0)+!-

# , ,

! & C21 7 = 1 9

< + D D D D D D D D

Spousal consortium

0 D

& Parental consortium D

$ Filial consortium 7

40 E 40

4? 7 +

7 7

D D 1 9 +

8 ', ,,,

3 ! # # + <9 !, # ,<--- ?# , & 5 A"8 , ! #.< *- '

!# +?7+ 1 (

Sunita Vs. Vinod Singh 2025 INSC 366# ?7+ A(

+ !

, +

, ! A ! & C""

8 ) 3"6# !8 /

F% 8 ", ,,,# !8

% 8 ) "$5# !8 /

1% 8 & ),,# !8

8 ($5# !8 1

1% 8 ,,,# !8 1

') 48

" $,

&)$,

"65, Moreover, in the absence of material indicating to the contrary, there is no inhibition to accept the age of the deceased as per the Post2Mortem Report

"' ') *

1 ! % 8 ', ,,,# !8 /

% ",- 4 G + H F 8 !&,"3%"31"$,

I8 '3 ,,,# )J 8 & ', ,,,# !8 H /

% ** '

#! + ! , , !

+ ( 9-! */ $# , ! # , , <---:& + , ?#

# +

D +

! !

! ! D + ,

! %---:& *% C ! # +

, # A

( , + ! # # #

=!# + # A

*9 ! ! # + #,

!4 , ! E , A , ! , ! + ,.< !,

+ 0 *< ! ! # + ,

, , !! A !

C , !! ! # >

, ! ( /0 *. '

#! # #+ ?7+ 1 ( + ! , # # -.**/--0 !

, &

& & Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded * ' %---:& %

# A

*:% *---:&5%---A*:%8

' /---5%---&*---8 <

*.4---:&5/---F*/F08 D!

*4*<-:& C A *4*<-:& D!(

*9</--:&

949--A/ 1949--A* $4-, $3+% -4:$% '>6>( =

#)*4:$%

'>6>= # + + %<-%*# -3$)%4 '>(> 6= >6>( >6> *0 1! +?7+ 1 ( Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma 7 R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation

( 0)+!3 $)!4 - 7>

& , ;3= ! !!

&' (

! # ! ! ! ! ,

+ + !

! : : ! + + *3 ?# $%&' (

! $/ # ! !! , # -.**/--0 /- ,

58 ! ! '' (

0 0 1

,:&