Bindu Khurana And Others v. Mohmad Chand And Others
!"# $#%&'&() * * +," &($-./-0!(!!($"/#0' 11#22!("' 3#0'-' /,!$/!($!($"/#0' #'1($#("'
0#'#(") 0'/&"!2&45$6%!"# 0"/#!11#22!("' 0 -(&" !&(5$6%!"# 00#'1($#(" 77777
/&' !11#!2 /!' 8##( &2#$ 89 "/# %2!&,!("' '##4&(: #(/!(%#,#(" "/# %,1#('!"&( !;!0$#$ " "/#, 89 "0 %%&$#(" 2!&,' 0&8-(!25 .-0-4'/#"0! <0&8-(!2= 0 '/0" 6&$# !;!0$ $!"#$ ( !%%-(" $#!"/ !6&'/ ./-0!(! &( ! ,"0 6#/&%2# !%%&$#("( > /#%2!&,!("'5;/!0#"/#;&$;!($%/&2$0#( "/#$#%#!'#$5
&2#$ ! 1#"&"&( -($#0 +#%"&(
"/# "0 3#/&%2#' %" '##4&(: %,1#('!"&((!%%-(" "/#$#!"/ !6&'/./-0!(!&(!,"06#/&%2# !%%&$#(";/&%/"412!%#( >
$!"#$ > ;!' 0#:&'"#0#$ !:!&('" 0#'1($#(" -($#0 +#%"&( >?5 @5>5* !($
> !" 2&%# +"!"&( .";!2& #/!"5 &'"0&%" +!/!0!(1-0 /# 2#!0(#$ 0&8-(!2(%('&$#0!"&( "/# !%"'!($#6&$#(%#(0#%0$/#2$"/!""/# !%%&$#(" &( A-#'"&( "4 12!%# $-# " "/# 0!'/ !($ (#:2&:#(" $0&6&(:
#($&(: 6#/&%2# 89 0#'1($#(" /#0# &' ( $&'1-"# 0#:!0$&(: "/#
!86#'!&$ &($&(: "/#2#!0(#$0&8-(!2("/&'&''-#5;/&%//!'!""!&(#$
&(!2&"9:# "/#$#%#!'#$;!' 9#!0'!""/#"&,# /&'$#!"/#;!' #,129#$ !' +#(&0 -$&"0 &( B%!2 -$&" #1!0",#("5 !09!(!5 #!0(&(: ' 5C@1#0,("/#%#!'#$;!'/!6&(:!6!2&$$0&6&(:2&%#(%#!""/# "&,# !%%&$#("2!&,!("';#0# -229$#1#($#("-1("/#$#%#!'#$ B#!0(#$0&8-(!2/!'/#2$"/!""/#!:# "/#$#%#!'#$;!'&( 8#";##(
@ 9#!0' !" "/# "&,# /&' $#!"/ ;/&%/ ;!' 106#$ 0, "/#
&%&!20#%0$!';#22!',!"0&%-2!"&(%#0"& &%!"#B#!0(#$0&8-(!2/!' -0"/#0 /#2$ "/!" "/# $#%#!'#$ ;!' #,129#$ !' +#(&0 -$&"0 &( B%!2 -$&" #1!0",#("5 !09!(! !($ ( "/# 8!'&' "/# '!2!09 %#0"& &%!"# D
5 10$-%#$ 89 E +-8/!'/ //40! %(%2-$#$ "/!" "/# $#%#!'#$ ;!' 0#%#&6&(:!'!2!09 ' >*C@1#0,("/#$-%"&( C0$;!'!112&#$ "#0 !1129&(: ! ,-2"&12� 5 ""!2 $#1#($#(%9 ;!' !''#''#$ !" ' 5 ?5 C@ ("/#0 '-, ' 5C@ ;!' !;!0$#$ ";!0$' "0!('10"!"&( !($ 2!'" 0&"#' /-'5 %2!&,!("' ;#0# /#2$ #("&"2#$ 0 ""!2 %,1#('!"&( ' 5?5 C@ !2(: ;&"/ &("#0#'" F ?G 1#0 !((-, #'1($#("' 5!($ ;#0#H&("29!($'#6#0!229/#2$2&!82#"1!9"/# !,-(" %,1#('!"&(""/#%2!&,!("' B#!0(#$ %-('#2 0 "/# !11#22!("' !0:-#' "/!" %,1#('!"&( !;!0$#$""/#!11#22!("'(##$'"8##(/!(%#$-2"&12� &('"#!$ /!'"8#!112&#$&(%0#!'#(!%%-(" -"-0#10'1#%"'/!'8##( !
0$#$5 "/-:/ &" &' (" &( $&'1-"# "/!" "/# $#%#!'#$ ;!' ! 6#0(,#(" #,129##"&'"/-'10!9#$"/!""/&'!11#!28#!22;#$ B#!0(#$ %-('#2 0 "/# ('-0!(%# ,1!(9 /!' 0# -"#$ "/# !86# '!&$ !0:-,#("' ;/&2# '-8,&""&(: "/!" "/# &,1-:(#$ !;!0$ /!'
%00#%"29 8##( 1!''#$ !($ ( :0-($ &' ,!$# -" 0 #(/!(%#,#(" "/# %,1#('!"&(!;!0$#$"&'"/-'10!9#$"/!""/&'!11#!28#$&',&''#$ /!6# /#!0$ 2#!0(#$ %-('#2 0 "/# 1!0"&#' !($ /!6# :(# "/0-:/"/#0#%0$;&"/"/#&0!82#!''&'"!(%# :# "/#$#%#!'#$&# 9#!0'&'("&($&'1-"#(%,#/!' 8##(%00#%"29!''#''#$!"' >*C@1#0,("/(6&#; "/#:-&$#2&(#' 2!&$$;(89"/#(=82#+-10#,#-0"&(!"&(!2('-0!(%#,1!(9B"$ 3' 0!(!9+#"/&!($"/#0'5 > &6&2 ?5G&(%0#!'#/!'" 8# !
0$#$ ( !%%-(" -"-0# 10'1#%"' 2!&,!("' !0# #("&"2#$ " ' 5C@#!%/ 02'' #'"!"#!($ -(#0!2#D1#('#'8#'&$#'' 5C@ ""/#%2!&,!(";&$; 02'' %('0"&-, #$-%"&( C0$ ( !%%-(" 1#0'(!2 #D1#('#' ;!' H-'"& &#$ ;#6#05 ,-2"&12� &('"#!$ /!' " 8# !112&#$ !:# $#%#!'#$8#&(: 9#!0'!""/#"&,# !%%&$#("&(6&#; +,"+!02!3#0,! !($"/#0'3'#2/&0!('10"010!"&(!($!("/#05
11#22!("'@%2!&,!("' !0#5 "/-'5 #("&"2#$ " %,1#('!"&( ;/&%/ &' 0#@ ;04#$!'-($#0)@
(%,#
5>*C@1, &# 55 C@1#0!((-, 55 55 G I 5??5 *C@
"!2&(%,#!
"#0!$$&"&( !""/#0!"# G( !%%-(" -"-0#10'1#%"' 5??5 * 5??5 * C0$ I 5 5?
C@ (%,#!
"#0$#$-%"&( C0$(!%%-(" 1#0'(!2 #D1#('#'
"!2$#1#($#(%9!
"#0 !1129&(:!,-2"&12� 5 5?
I *5 5> *C@ B'' #'"!"# 5C@
B'' %('0"&-,";& #
5C@
> B'' -(#0!2 5C@
! ' ?55> *C@ /#!,-(" %,1#('!"&(!20#!$9!;!0$#$""/#!11#22!("'5 (##$2#''"'!95'/!22'"!($$#$-%"#$ 0,"/#!,-("%!2%-2!"#$!'!86# 11#22!("''/!228##("&"2#$"&("#0#'"!""/#0!"# >G1#0!((-,("/# #(/!(%#$!,-(" 0,"/#$!"# &2&(: "/#1#"&"&("&220#!2&J!"&( 110"&(,#(" !,-(" %,1#('!"&( !,(:'" %2!&,!("' '/!228#&("/#'!,#0!"&!' &D#$89"/#2#!0(#$0&8-(!2&0#%"&(' "/# 0&8-(!2 &( 0#'1#%" " ,!((#0 $&'8-0'#,#(" %,1#('!"&( !,-(" " "/#%2!&,!("''/!22#(-0# E&"/"/#!86#'!&$,$& &%!"&(&("/#!;!0$$!"#$ 5 10#'#("!11#!2&'$&'1'#$ "
# $ %&%' ()*(+ '/;!0 ,-. -.'/.
&.
'
.
23.' ,-. -../ 4!.23.'