Welfare Society Of Retires And ANR v. Union Of India And ORS

  


  


     

 !"# $#%&'&()*

 +  #, !-#  .%&#"/    -#"&-##'    !"&(!,  ('&"0"#    #%1(&%!,  #!%1#- -!&(&(2!($#'#!-%1!($!("1#- #"&"&(#-' 3#-'0'

(&( ($&!!($"1#-'

#'4($#("'
 ) 5 6 .
76. -#'#(") -70"(#8!9 $:%!"#9 -"1#4#"&"&(#-' (# --#'4($#("  - -&8#'1;!-.&(217!(;!-9 $:%!"#9."!($&(2
0('#,9

--#'4($#("'!($* -..&$109 $:%!"#9 --#'4($#("<

 1#"1#-"1##4-"#-' ,%!,(#;'4!4#-=!/>#!,,;#$" '##"1#80$2=#("? #'  >#-# #--#$""1##4-"#--(" #' * 1#"1#-"1#80$2=#("'10,$>#-#4-"#$&("1#$&2#'"? #'   76.9  1#  4#"&"&(#-9  !  #, !-#  .%&#"/    #"&-##'    !"&(!, ('"&"0"# #%1(&%!,#!%1#--!&(&(2!($#'#!-%1&('1-"559 "1-021  &"'  -#'&$#("  !,(2;&"1  "1#  -#'&$#("    "1#  '!&$  .%&#"/9  1!'

&(:@#$  "1#  ;-&"  80-&'$&%"&(    "1&' 
0-"  0($#-  -"&%,#  +    "1#
('"&"0"&( ($&! -A0!'1&(2"1#-$#-$!"#$ <+  ((#B0-# <!($!,' -&''0!(%# ;-&"&("1#(!"0-# =!($!=0'$&-#%"&(2"1# -#'4($#("'"#B"#($"1#>#(# 
#("-!,:#-(=#("#!,"1.%1#=#&(

 '1-"5
.5-!44-4-&!"#=#$&%!,-#&=>0-'#=#(">/-#'4($#("< ""1#4#"&"&(#-'0($#-
#("-!,:#-(=#("#$&%!, ""#($!(%#0,#'1# 4#"&"&(#- .%&#"/ 1!'>##('#"04>/"1#=#=>#-'9!'$#"!&,#$&(

9;1!-#-#"&-#$#=4,/##' '" "1#=!-# 2#""&(2
#("-!,
&:&,.#-:&%#'#('&(&('1-"5

.#('&(5!($! #;

!-#2#""&(2 !=&,/4#('&(!($! #;1!:#4"#$ -"1#
#("-!,-:&$#("

0($&('1-"5
5"&''"!"#$"1!"-#'4($#("<;!''#"04 !'!.%&#"/>/"1#(&( ($&!9!($"1#>8#%"' -;1&%1&"&'#'"!>,&'1#$ &'2&:#(&(&"'#=-!($0= ''%&!"&( ((#B0-#1#-0,#'!($ -#20,!"&(' "1#'!=#;#-#!,' -!=#$  '4#-0,#<9"1#2#(#-!, '04#-&("#($#(%#9$&-#%"&(!($%("-, "1#!

!&-' "1#.%&#"/!($&"'

&(%=#!($4-4#-"/'1!,,>#:#'"#$&("1#:#-(&(2 $/ "1#.%&#"/9 ;1&%1&'%!,,#$!'  :#-(-' 1#:#-(=#(" ($&!1!'

!0"1-&"/"!44&(":!-&0'4#-'('&(%,0$&(2"1#
1!&-=!(9";=#=>#-' -#4-#'#("&(2  "1#  &(&'"-/    0=!(  #'0-%#'  #:#,4=#("9  "; &($0'"-&!,&'"'9"#%1(&%!,4#-'('(=&(!"#$>/"1#:#-(=#(" ($&!9(# -#4-#'#("!"&:# "1# 
("1&';!/90" #&21"$&

#-#("%!"#2-&#'9 ;1&%1%!(>#!44&("#$>/"1# :#-(-'9 0-%!"#2-&#'!-# !44&("#$>/"1#:#-(=#(" ($&!9 &:#=#=>#-'!-#!44&("#$>/"1# #2&(!,  ."!"#'  !($  ";  0"    -#2&(  !-#  !44&("#$  >/  "1#  ."!"# :#-(=#("9(#-#4-#'#("!"&:# "1#(&:#-'&"/9";1&%1"1#&('"&"0"#&'

!

&,&!"#$9(#=#=>#- "1# !%0,"/!($(#$&-#%"- "1#&('"&"0"#1# >/#,!;'%!(>#%('&$#-#$9=$& &#$-%!(%#,,#$;&"1"1#!44-:!, "1# :#-(=#(" ($&! 1#!%%0("' "1#!-#!0$&"#$>/"1#
=4"-,,#-!($ 0$&"-#(#-!, ($&!&('1-"5
5-!(/4#-'( !44&("#$>/1&=&("1&'%((#%"&(-"1#'#-:&(2#=4,/##'9"1#
#("-!,

* :#-(=#("  #$&%!,  ""#($!(%#  0,#'9  !'  !44,&%!>,#  "  "1# 
#("-!, :#-(=#("#=4,/##'9!-#!44,&%!>,#;#:#-9"1#-#"&-##' -#'4($#("

<('"&"0"#!-#(">#&(2#B"#($#$"1#=#$&%!,1#!,"1'%1#=#!($!-# 4!&$ &B#$!=0(" '* 4#-=("1!'=#$&%!,!,,;!(%# 1# &(!(%#
==&""## -#'4($#("<('"&"0"#-#%==#($#$"1!""1# #=4,/##'4#('&(#-' -#'4($#("<>#4-:&$#$"1# !%&,&"&#'!"4!- ;&"1  "1# 
#("-!,  :#-(=#("  4#('&(#-'  0($#-  "1# 
.  '0>8#%"  " 4!/=#(" %("-&>0"&(!"4!-;#:#-9"1#'!=#;!'-#8#%"#$"&''"!"#$ "1!""1#
#("-!,:#-(=#("#!,"1.%1#=#;!'&("-$0%#$&("1#/#!-

< -4-:&$&(2=#$&%!, !%&,&"&#'"
#("-!,:#-(=#("#=4,/##'!($ "1#&- !=&,/=#=>#-'1#'%1#=#9;1&%1;!'&(&"&!,,/&("-$0%#$&(#,1& 1!' (;>##( #B"#($#$" C "1#-%&"&#' &(%,0$&(2 
1!($&2!-1 1# #=4,/##'4#('&(#-'!:!&,&(2"1#'!&$
.%1#=#!-#-#A0&-#$"=!@# !(=&(!,%("-&>0"&(#:#-/=("1$#4#($&(204("1#&-4!/4#('&(1# -# #--!,'/'"#=&'!,'>-021"&("4#-!"&(1#-#'&$#(%#!,(#&'"1# %-&"#-&!  -  #,&2&>&,&"/  -  !:!&,&(2  =#$&%!,  !%&,&"&#'  0($#-  "1# 
#("-!, :#-(=#("#!,"1.%1#=#("1##,&2&>&,&"/%-&"#-&!9%#-"!&(%!"#2-&#'!-# =#("&(#$9;1&%1!-##("&",#$""1#>#(# '!&$
.%1#=#9;1&%1 &(%,0$#'!(!%%-#$&"#$80-(!,&'"9;14-$0%#'!%#-"& &%!"# -="1#-#''

0(%&, ($&!'"!"&(2"1!"1#&'!=#=>#- "1#-#'' ''%&!"&(9#;

#,1&   1#-# -#9  "1#  4-!/#-  &' "1!"  "1# 4#"&"&(#-'9  ;1  -#"&-#$  -= 9'10,$!,'>#2&:#("1#'!=#>#(# 
#("-!,:#-(=#("

#!,"1.%1#=#(4!/=#(" %("-&>0"&(0" "1#&-4#('&( 1#-#'4($#("' "*%("#'"#$"1#%!'#";!''"!"#$&( "1#-#4,/"1!""1#4#"&"&(#-&'!.%&#"/1#-#!-#";=#$&%!, !%&,&"&#'9 (!=#,/9
#("-!,:#-(=#("#!,"1.%1#=#!($
#("-!,.#-:&%#'#$&%!,

<

""#($!(%#0,#'9 << 1!:#1#!-$"1#,#!-(#$%0('#,' -"1#4!-"&#'!($1!:#!,' %!-# 0,,/2(#"1-021"1# &,# ($0>"#$,/9!'4#-"1#,&'" "1#=#=>#-' "1#.%&#"/  9'=# =#=>#-' "1#4#"&"&(#-.%&#"/!-#,&:&(2!"

1!($&2!-191!,&!($!(%1@0,!9;1#-#!''=#!-#,&:&(2&("1#-!-#! &#>#/($"1#"-&%&"/ 
1!($&2!-191!,&!($!(%1@0,!1#-# -#9&"

%!((">#'!&$"1!"!,,"1#=#=>#-' "1#4#"&"&(#-.%&#"/!-#,&:&(2!"

1!($&2!-1 $=&""#$,/9"1#4#"&"&(#-&'!-#2&'"#-#$.%&#"/9&(;1&%1"1# (&(  ($&!1!'!=!8-'!/ ;#:#-9"1#-0,#'-#4-$0%#$&("1# 4-#'#(";-&"4#"&"&('1;"1!""1# :#-(-'-0("1#!

!&-' "1# !($"1#4-%#$0-# !44&("=#("&'!,'2&:#(&("1#-0,#' "1# .%&#"/($#-0,#  "1##=-!($0= ''%&!"&( 9"1#!44&("=#("'9#B%#4""1!" "1#&-#%"-9!-#=!$#>/"1#

:#-(-' $=&""#$,/9"1'##=4,/##'9;1!-#("%:#-#$0($#-"1#
.%1#=#9!-#2-!("#$ &B#$=#$&%!,!,,;!(%#"%=#'0" -="1# -#4,/    -#'4($#("     "1!"  !  -#A0#'"  ;!'  =!$#  -  %:#-&(2  "1# 4#('&(#-' 0($#-"1#
.%1#=#9>0""1#'!=#;!'$#%,&(#$ >/"1#&(&'"-/ #!,"1!($!=&,/#, !-#("1#&(0"#' ##"&(2

==&""## .#%-#"!-&#' ((#B0-#9&";!'$#%&$#$"1!""1#
#("-!, :#-(=#("#!,"1.%1#=# !%&,&"&#';0,$(">##B"#($#$".'!($

0"(=0' $&#'1#&'(# "1# 0"(=0' $/1# #,&2&>&,&"/9">#%:#-#$0($#-"1#'!&$
.%1#=#9&'4-:&$#$&("1# '!&$'%1#=#&"'#, ;1#-#&(!,&'" #=4,/##''#-:&%#'!-#2&:#(9;1&%1 !$=&""#$,/$#'("%:#-"1#4#('&(#-'  $=&""#$,/9$0-&(2 '#-:&%#9"1#=#=>#-' "1#4#"&"&(#-.%&#"/;#-#2#""&(2"1#=#$&%!,

 

!%&,&"&#'!"4!-;&"1"1#
#("-!,:#-(=#("#=4,/##' 1#-#,#:!(" %,!0'#'!-#BBB&&&!($BBB&:9;1&%1!-#-#4-$0%#$!'0($#-) DBBB&&& #-'('  #=4,/#$  &(  '#=&2:#-(=#("  !($ !0"(=0'>$&#';1!-#4#-=&""#$"8&("1#
.%1#=# BBB&:

(  %%-#$&"#$  0-(!,&'"  ;1  4-$0%#'  !

%#-"& &%!"# -="1#-#''
0(%&, ($&!'"!"&(2"1!"1#&'!

=#=>#- "1#-#'' ''%&!"&(9#;#,1& -!($!"

6'4&"!,E "2#'"'1;"'1;"1!""1#4#-'('9;1&'#=4,/#$&( .#=&:#-(=#("!($ 0"(=0' $&#'9%!(!:!&,"1#
.%1#=# ;1#("1#/!-#4#-=&""#$"8&("1#
.%1#=# 1#  ,#!-(#$  %0('#,  -  "1#  4#"&"&(#-'  1!'  -!&'#$  '#-&0' >8#%"&('""1#&(%,0'&( "1#!%%-#$&"#$80-(!,&'"' -!:!&,&(2"1#'!&$

!%&,&"/ != "1#:&#;"1!"& "1#!%%-#$&"#$80-(!,&'"'!-#&(%,0$#$ !'(# "1#>#(# &%&!-&#' "1#'!&$'%1#=#9"1!"$#'("=#!("1!"!(/ =#=>#-9;1%=#'""1#
0-"9'10,$>#2-!("#$"1#>#(# '!&$ '%1#=#!($>#%=#'"1#=#=>#- "1#'!&$'%1#=#!= "1#:&#;"1!"

"1#%!'# "1#4#"&"&(#-.%&#"/&'("%:#-#$0($#-"1#-0,#'  "1#/ ;!(""1!""1#/'10,$>#%:#-#$0($#-"1#'!&$'%1#=#9"1#1!'" =:#""1#:#-(=#("!($"1#:#-(=#("!

"#-!%%#4"&(2'0%1-#A0#'"

1!'"=!@#(#%#''!-/!=#($=#("'&("1#-0,#'1#
0-"%!((""!@#:#- "1##B#%0"&:#-A0!'&80$&%&!, 0(%"&(' "1#:#-(=#(""'!/"1!""1# -0,#''"!($!=#($#$9'!'"&(%,0$#"1#!,' 1#  ,#!-(#$  %0('#,  -  "1#  4#"&"&(#-'  1!'  -#,&#$  04(  ! &:&'&( #(%180$2=#(" "1#&=!%1!,-!$#'1&21
0-"9.1&=,!9&(

+
   



   

 9
<+



9$#%&$#$(C 

1&'%!'#-#,!"#'" ,,($&!!$&1# 4-#'#("%!'#&'$&

#-#("#-#9"1#4#"&"&(#-&'!-#2&'"#-#$.%&#"/9;1&%1 1!'&"';(#=-!($0= ''%&!"&(1#!44&("=#("'!-#!,'=!$# >/"1# &-#%"-'!($"1#-0,#' "1#=#=-!($0= !''%&!"&( $("4#-=&""1#4#('&(#-' ">#>#(# &%&!-/ "1#
#("-!, :#-(=#("#!,"1.%1#=#("1#2-0($ 4!-&"/;&"1"1#80-(!,&'"'

!($ ,,($&!!$&#=4,/##'9"1#4#"&"&(#-'%!((">#-$#-#$"># >#(# &%&!-/ "1#'!&$'%1#=#

'$&'%0''#$!>:#9!'4#-"1#,&'" 9 !,,"1# =#=>#-' "1#4#"&"&(#-.%&#"/!-#("-#'&$&(2&(
1!($&2!-1 1# '%1#=#&'(,/!44,&%!>,#""1#,&=&"#$C%&"&#'1#-# -#9"1#-#!-#( =#-&"'&("1#4-#'#(";-&"4#"&"&( %%-$&(2,/9"1#'!=#&'$&'=&''#$ 76.   *

 + '8@' 1#"1#-'4#!@&(2-#!'(#$ ) #' 1#"1#-#4-"!>,# ) #'