← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1480/2016allowed

Gurpreet Singh Saini & ORS v. Foof Corporation Of India & ORS

2026-04-07Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

 

       

 

 

            

!"#$%&'$($')$!*% +, 

!"#$%&-'*%* %.$!*% / ,

!"#$%& -0*1!$!*%   2$&2$'*-$'1&3)$*'4 005 !"#$%&

00 6 $0173%-'*%* %.$#$%&*44 005 !"#$%&1%!'$1(*%(8341%7

   9  :;< = <= << ; ****  



 ! "#  

$% ! "#    =1%!$$- * !"308 

'17$' &'(      *  # +   ! "+ ,,-.,,/ #    # 0

#  "#1

#  #2

'334,3'5&!

67(  '5.'-3-,3'8 &!

6 ''(     '934,3'4 &!

6 '8( *0  

1 " 02

+ "

"+ # 0 *0     #    #   0 1  "+

##" *   

 *  +*0 ++ 

1

 

1.&( &,(         : + +  

 # " ;

1  + # +<:,8-'8:,3'41 1 * 1  1  + *0  # +#

  3,',,3'4 &!

6 '!( 

" # +010 '9'',3'4

- 2 - &5(  " ;

    :   )"

"+ !   :   '739'7/-    #

  )"

"+!   5'',,337 =8  373',3',  + 49# & ##( +  '7/' &

    '7/'  + ( #   #    +0   ;

     ## + ++

  0 1  *+ # 

+ +#399>?#""

 '4"

  1    

" ? #

+

 "   # 

@+0 ,3'' #%

"

. :1

)!1  +0 

 &8( !

 01" "

  ++  

;

  1 "





" "  "

 1 +0   

 ;

  0 3,3,,3'5 &!

6 -(   " 2 +0    =8 1  " 

+#;



  

 '334,3'5&!

67( 

  +0#" 0 2

+ "

"+#0*0  # #  01 "+

##" &4(  #  #     # +    + -7./3# '7/' + *# =5 ,43-,3'5

         # 

"   5''3,3'5 )  ++  0     + # *0  #0

  +0 # A" 0 2

+ "

"+#0*0  # #  01 "+

##"BA" 02

+ "

"+ #0*0  # # 01 "+

##"B



   '5.'-3-,3'8 &!

6 ''( ;

- 3 - #

%  +  /8 #   '7/'  +    # + 

1  *# $#C =,  1   1 

'934,3'4&!

6'8( &-( D " 1   *%&$%&3*%(*4&2$-$&3&3*%$' &/( E " +#  "   ++ 



+ #   

 + # " "%+ 

@+0,3'' 1 "0 #:%

#"%&* 1

( +0+01 ## + 1 1 + "    "+ * #  #  0 

    + )

0 0 +#   "

 #

A1+

* "  # # &F(B ;

1A  * # 0B# "

. 1

0 

* " "+    A  "

B 1   ## 1  

   0 " "

" 

 1

#+

   

#

+0   &9( D# "  "

"

##  ++1  

  "        1  

"

 %   +" # #      *  

*+  + *+

+   1 1 ++0*  "

++01 ;

    +0 +0  ""  

0 0%

 + 

6 " "# ## + " "1 ++0

"  1 0++ "++ * 1   

- 4 - &7(        +  48&

( #   '7/'  +  " 0 +0 +0% 2 "

0+" *0 +0

"*"

# 0

 "      373',3',   2 #0  0 "

" +  **+;

 

" 0" #  +0 

   + + *+* D *   + 

   

    +0 "

    + 49# '7/' + 

@

1

 G G+ G ;

 "+++  #

+ #  "     ++  0  1 + 6 

 ":"

## +*06

* # #* "

 +0 #0& 

+( 

#;

*0

 2+ 



++0+"+

2 1  0"

++ 

 +



"+*"

#! "+'8 '-#    #  "

 *0   D

 

 A  

        

 !"#$%&'( 1  1 + ":"""

*

+#

1  

++0 6 

* "# 0 

"+ $(-*%!$%&(.* %&$' &'3( E " +#    * # +0# + *0  *   

0"

+;

#++0   *  + 0 "+" 0 + #

# "   *  ;

1"

"++0"

: #"

. 1



+

 E  & E (

   H 0## " #

- 5 - ##

#++

0 "

## + " "++0 + +0 # "

  2 +#" "

. 1

+++"%

"

"+."%1  +0 

1*0 ;

+0  *0 *0 &F(    1+"+

+ #  0

+ 

  ## 

 1  " 61  +  " +# *++

 1  &''(   #        + #        +0

1 .##"+* + *+# + " "

 " 0   + + "0     +  

 *0 %

"" + +#" 

 * 0#* 1 "

"+ ##?   "    "" "

  "      " "+ 

" "

"+## 

"+

;

+0 *

+  *+ #

"" "

.

+

 "+  +

  

  +)  I++  #* 



 # H 0## " #

+# *+

0*+  #     + + *     "  #   "   0  

  0  *+## "H 0## "  ;

1

#++

0    "

 0? +   #"*"

   "

"#

#

+ 

 2 ""*0 

0 ++  &',( D+ " +#    1%   3735,3,-

- 6 - %107(3( &'5(   ++" "#  + "   #

1 



"

*



 + ;

 ) 0  +0  "    1 A   * # 0B #   "

. :1

     "

 "

  + * "  # *0 &F( 0 

0  0  ++ " 

# A"

"B 1  #0

  0 "

"#

 * # "

" "*0 "

" "  "

*  "  &'8(  

"+1  

   #  " # **     #

      

*+  +      "

""

* #



0 0)

  "++0  1    "

 +0 

 # 

   *    +0 1

          +0  %

  + 

 

 ++ " " #  ##   "#" " ## "+" +1  0#"++  &'4(  

)$ $ *+  ,- %'"."  " "++0 + 

 "   

 "+# H

"!" +0  #

"

**   "

" **0+ +

" "   H 0## ""

 "+  0  " "+ +0   &'-(   / 0   1  *-  23

,-%''4"56.    J   +*

"  "



- 7 -

0 "

   1

"*     0 ## " #

 2 :

 + # "    +0   "    "

#   *    " # **       "

 ) + 6" :            

                

    

             

       

   

           !   

   "#           

  

                 

                $          

   

%             

 %            %   #          

    

 # 

&'

 ( &'/( +#

#"

*  #        "  *   A*#+

0B  ++ " " "

  "

"  

"  " ** *%

""    # "" *  "

  0  1  *-  ! &#6 "' 1 

1 + 

+ %"+0     " "+   

     I *#+

0 "

 * 1  * #  *  +  "

 ""  " *+

" %

1  

" " ** # ")  "  +

*+ :#""

*+

+0*    ## ""



- 8 - **   

 "

"+

# ") + 6" #   " : $                                         )

 *+ , - ) 

*'       (               #  

      

.  )                                        

  

)  

 *    *                )               

     

     

    / 

        

        01 200   )                    

       

    !       #            3    4 & &'9(   " 0+ # 

 " 0  + 48&

(# '7/' +  1 " +" 0 +0  %  2 "

0 + " A*0   +0B  ""  #

"  *"

 #      "      373',3',    *  2 #0  0 "

"

++

* "*0;

 ++0     # +

 6  &'7(    

2+ 0

   

 ":+

2  # 

   "

"

      

 "

 "+"

#

+ # " 

 @

1

  G  G+  G    ;

 0

- 9 - + ":"

## +16  * # #* 1 + +0 ;

I 

 1 



    # 1   0  *+   

" + " *   "

 

  #  ":""

 * " #  ## 

  +   *+  ## ! "+'8 '- +

2 +0"

*

1

1 

++0 ":"" * 

* " # 0"

++

 

#" &,3( 1+* #   " 

+"++*0  

7 8 93 +  0         !%'"#%"6%  "

1 ++

1 2 #  0





":+

2 

+



   ##

  :  *

!%'"#"6"  6+

    

 

0  0   "

 1

  "

  "   #   "

 * 6"



 

 +

 + "

 *1 +01   2+#

"#"

 + 

"

" " 1 + 

 * "    1     "+  0 *1 ":+

2   # " "  

   #* ++0   +0  #  1 + 1

  + 

  6 

   1   0  + 

 *   0 ##  ! "+ '8   ++ 

++0 "

" "   +*+ %

# +0) 

+   J*0  

7 893 + 0  :

- 10 - '($ '

(                    

       

      

     5 '()6

 

     7

                                           #        5 '(. #                                     6

5 '(                

                  

      

 

                 

       )6



               '()        '(         "     

                       "          

 )       

                     "          %               

                       



      

8"  

      



       

        #   & &,'( ;  +  " #*   " *       #

 

0 "

      + + 

"   "

 * #  +0       "

" ;    " 

+"%#

0"

*

- 11 -  1 +

 ++

"" **   ":+

2  

++0 +"

 " #   

   "

 "

 1  +*  ** " 

##

! "+'8#    )    #  

# "# A"

"B1

+;

 2+    " ":"

"++  + ++0 

*+

  6  0 + #

# +  +0

 + ;

  * "# " " 

" 

" + 

* 0*

* "

"   *%.0 (3*% &,,( !""

+0  1  ++1

  '334,3'5 &!

67( '5.'-3-,3'8 &!

6 ''(    '934,3'4 &!

6 '8(  2    )     *

 + +  

 # ;

  ++ *  +  ++ " 2 +  0 * #  

"+

  .:# 6  # 0   + # "

 +  *  # 

  +0  1 6"

 ++*"+*0  1

   #     #    # "  #  "  "0 # 

  &,5( 

+ "   #""

+0 /  + =1%!$$- * !"30

!"$

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

:

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

:

Yes/No