Ramesh Kumar & ORS v. Financial Commissioner & Principal Secretary To Govt. Of Haryana And ORS.










   
  

!"#

#$%&%'(
  

)
!*#&+
,-*!.
!'/
"+#.&
00#"%"%'#.

1#.&-&

%'!'$%!2
**%&&%'#.
!'/
.%'$%3!2
4#$.#"!.5
"
6#.'*#'"
 !.5!'!7
'/-&".%#&
!'/
**#.$#
#3!."*#'"7
!.5!'!
0#&3'/#'"&


 


     

  .#&#'"(
&
'%"!
!25!'7
/6$!"#7
.
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&

&
!2%8!
'9!7
7
!.5!'!

4+.%
,!*!2
4#+9!27
/6$!"#7
.
4

4+.%
*%"
.!&+!.7
/6$!"#7
.
.#&3'/#'"
:


+#"+#.
#3."#.&

2$!2
3!3#.&
*!5
;#
!22<#/
"
&##
"+#
=-/9*#'"&>



;#
.# #..#/
"
"+#
#3."#.&
.
'">

+#"+#.
"+#
=-/9*#'"
&+-2/
;#
.#3."#/
%'
"+#
%9#&">
  
+#
3#"%"%'#.&
$2!%*
"
;#
%'
3&&#&&%'

"+#
2!'/7
<+%$+
<!&
"+#
&-;=#$"
*!""#.

!$?-%&%"%'
6%/#
'"% %$!"%'
/!"#/
@


%&&-#/
-'/#.
4#$"%'
@

"+#
A!'/
$?-%&%"%'
$"7
 @
 .
&+."
B"+#
$"C
22<#/
;5
"+#
/#$2!.!"%'
/!"#/
@@



%&&-#/
-'/#.
4#$"%'
D
 $"



+#
9.%#6!'$#

"+#
3#"%"%'#.&
%&
"+!"
"+#5
+!6#
$'&".-$"#/
&*!22
.#&%/#'"%!2
-'%"&
'
"+#
2!'/

!'/
+!6#
;##'


.#&%/%'9
"+#.#%'
.
"+#
2!&"
)
5#!.&7
"+#.# .#7
"+#
&".-$"-.#&
&+-2/
'"
;#
!$?-%.#/

'
"+#
<.%""#'
&"!"#*#'"7
"+#
&"!'/


"+#
.#&3'/#'"&
%&
"+!"
'#
!."+
#6%

!'/
"+#.&7
<#.#
<'#.&

"+#
2!'/
*#!&-.%'9
:
8!'!2

+!."
#6%
.#$#%6#/
"+#
$*3#'&!"%'

%'
.#&3#$"
 2!'/
*#!&-.%'9

@
8!'!2

*!.2!


'
"+#
.#*!%'%'9
2!'/7
"+#.#
!.#

"+#.
$E&+!.#.&7

;-"
'"
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&

+#
3#"%"%'#.&
!.#
'"
"+#
<'#.&

"+#
2!'/7
;-"
!.#
$2!%*%'9
"
;#
$$-3!'"&

"+#
&!*#



4%'$#
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&
!.#
'"
"+#
<'#.&

"+#
2!'/7
"+#.# .#7
"+#5
!.#
'"
#'"%"2#/
"
!'5
$*3#'&!"%'
"
%&
!2&
3%'"#/
-"
"+!"
"+#
2!'/
6#.
<+%$+
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&
!.#
$$-3!'"&7
!&
3#.
2!5
-"
32!'7

!22&
-'/#.
"+#
3.3&#/
:)

*#"#.&
<%/#
/#6#23*#'"
2!'/

!'/
) *#".#&

6%/#
9.##'
;#2"7
<+%$+
$!''"
;#
$'&%/#.#/
.
.#2#!&#

"
%&
!2&
*#'"%'#/
"+!"
'25
%'
"+#
2!'/
*#!&-.%'9

8!'!2

*!.2!7
"+#
&".-$"-.#&
%'
"+#
.*

+-&#&7
9!%.
9%"<!.
#F%&"7
<+#.#!&
"+#
.#&"
 "+#
2!'/
%&
6!$!'"
4%'$#
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&
!.#
'"
3.6#/
"
;#
<'#.&

"+#
2!'/7
"+#
32%$5

.#+!;%2%"!"%'
%&
'"
!332%$!;2#
"
"+#
$$-3!'"&7

!&
%"
/#!2&
<%"+
.#+!;%2%"!"%'

"+#
2!'/
<'#.&
'25

A#!.'#/
$-'&#2
.
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&
&-;*%"&
"+!"
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&
!.#
"+#
3#.&'&
%'"#.#&"#/
!&
/# %'#/
%'
4#$"%'
;


$"7
"+#.# .#7
"+#
<.%"
3#"%"%'
'
;#+!2
"+#
$$-3!'"&

"+#
2!'/
$+!22#'9%'9
"+#

!$?-%&%"%'
%&
*!%'"!%'!;2#

4#$"%'
;7
4#$"%'&
) 
!'/
) 
 $"7
.#!/
!&
-'/#.(E

G

# %'%"%'&
E

'
"+%&
$"7
-'2#&&
"+#.#

%&
&*#"+%'9
.#3-9'!'"

%'
"+#
&-;=#$"

.
$'"#F"7E

!




FF





FF





FF






;



"+#
#F3.#&&%'
G3#.&'
%'"#.#&"#/H
%'$2-/#&
!22
3#.&'&
$2!%*%'9
!'
%'"#.#&"
%'
$*3#'&!"%'
"
;#
*!/#
'
!$$-'"

"+#
!$?-%&%"%'

2!'/
-'/#.
"+%&
$"I
!'/

!
3#.&'
&+!22
;#
/##*#/
"
;#
%'"#.#&"#/
%'
2!'/
%
+#
%&
%'"#.#&"#/
%'
!'
#!&#*#'"

!

#$"%'9
"+#
2!'/H


FF





FF





FF






) 
   !"!#$%!&


'5
3#.&'
%'"#.#&"#/
%'
!'5
2!'/
<+%$+
+!&
;##'
'"% %#/
-'/#.
4#$"%'
@7
&-;E&#$"%'
7
!&
;#%'9
'##/#/
.
2%8#25
"
;#
'##/#/
.
!
3-;2%$
3-.3&#
.

.
!
$*3!'5
*!57
<%"+%'
"+%."5
/!5&
.*
"+#
/!"#
 3-;2%$!"%'

"+#
'"% %$!"%'7
;=#$"
"
"+#
!$?-%&%"%'
 2!'/
.

!'5
2!'/
%'
"+#
2$!2%"57
!&
"+#
$!&#
*!5
;#

 
FF





FF





FF







.
"+#
3-.3&#&

"+%&
&#$"%'7
!
3#.&'
&+!22
;#
/##*#/
"
;#
%'"#.#&"#/
%'
2!'/
<+
<-2/
;#
#'"%"2#/
"
$2!%*
!'
%'"#.#&"
%'
$*3#'&!"%'
%
"+#
2!'/
<#.#
!$?-%.#/
-'/#.
"+%&
$"H

+#
/# %'%"%'
.#3./-$#/
!;6#
9%6#&
.%9+"
"
!22
3#.&'&
$2!%*%'9
G%'"#.#&"
%'
$*3#'&!"%'H
'
!$$-'"

!$?-%&%"%'


2!'/
!&
!
3#.&'
%'"#.#&"#/
+#.# .#7
!'
$$-3!'"
*!5
;#
#'"%"2#/
"
$*3#'&!"%'
'
!$$-'"

!$?-%&%"%'

2!'/7
;-"
%"
%&
"+#
<'#.
!2'#7
<+
+!&
!
.%9+"
"
%2#
;=#$"%'&
"
%&
#6%/#'"

.*
&-;E&#$"%'


4#$"%'
) $"7
"+!"
.%9+"

"
%2#
;=#$"%'&

%&
$'

#..#/
'
!
3#.&'
<+
%&
#'"%"2#/
"
$2!%*
!'
%'"#.#&"
%'
$*3#'&!"%'
'
6%#<
"+#.# 7
<#
%'/
"+!"
&%'$#
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&
!.#
'"
<'#.&

"+#
2!'/7
"+#%.
$2!%*
!&
$$-3!'"&

"+#
2!'/
<-2/
;#
%'
.#&3#$"

"+#
$*3#'&!"%'

"+#
2!'/
'25

+#.# .#7
"+#
3#"%"%'#.&
$!''"
;#
3#.*%""#/
"
/%&3-"#

"+#
!$?-%&%"%'

2!'/


+#
!$?-%&%"%'
.
"+#
3-.3&#

.!/
$!'
'"
;#
3#.*%""#/
"
;#
/%&3-"#/
%'
"#.*&

"+#
4-3.#*#
-."
=-/9*#'"
.#3."#/
!&

!9/%&+
+!'/
6
4"!"#

!.5!'!7


)

4
D 7
<+#.#%'
"+#
-."
!22<#/

"+#
!-"+.%"%#&
"
.#*6#
"+#
&".-$"-.#&7
% .#?-%.#/
.
"+#
3-.3&#&

.!/7
+&3%"!2
!'/
"+#.
$%6%$
!*#'%"%#&

"
<!&
+#2/
;5
"+#
'C;2#
4-3.#*#
-."
!&
-'/#.(E

G 
'
6%#<

<+!"
%&
&"!"#/
!;6#7
<#
/
'"
%'/
!'5
9/
.#!&'
!&
"
<+5
/%.#$"%'&
!&
9%6#'
%'
"+#
$!&#

4-;#
4%'9+
6
4"!"#

!.5!'!7



:
4
)@)
&+-2/
'"
;#
9%6#'
%'
"+#&#
$!&#&
!&
<#227
&-;=#$"
"
$#."!%'
.#&".%$"%'&
"
"!8#
$!.#

"+#
32!''#/
/#6#23*#'"

"+#
!.#!
$$./%'9257
"+#


%*3-9'#/
=-/9*#'"&
!.#
&#"
!&%/#
!'/
"+#
!33#!2&
!.#
!22<#/
%'
"+#
22<%'9
"#.*&(


+#
4#$.#"!.57
.;!'
&"!"#&
#3!."*#'"7
4"!"#
 !.5!'!
%&
/%.#$"#/
"
$'&%/#.
"+#
;=#$"%'&
 !33#22!'"&
'25
&
!.
%"
.#2!"#&
"
#F$2-&%'

"+#
2!'/
"
"+#
#F"#'"
$$-3%#/
;5
"+#
&".-$"-.#
!'/
!33.3.%!"#
3#'
!.#!
!.-'/
"+#
&".-$"-.#
.
"+#
;#'# %$%!2
#'=5*#'"

"+#
!33#22!'"&
<#6#.7
"+%&
/%.#$"%'
&+!22
'"
$*#
%'
"+#
<!5

"+#
!-"+.%"%#&
%'
.#*6%'9
"+#
&".-$"-.#&7
%
.#?-%.#/
.
"+#
3-.3&#&

.!/7
+&3%"!2
!'/
"+#.
$%6%$
!*#'%"%#&


+#
4#$.#"!.57
.;!'
&"!"#&
#3!."*#'"
&+!22
/#$%/#
'"
'25
"+#
#F%&"#'$#

"+#
&".-$"-.#&
3.%.
"
4#$"%'
@
'"% %$!"%'
.
&-;&#?-#'"
"7
+#
&+!22
!2&
/#$%/#
"+#
#F"#'"

&".-$"-.#
<+%$+
#F%&"#/
3.%.
"
4#$"%'
@
'"% %$!"%'


"
%&
!2&
3#'
"
"+#
!-"+.%"%#&
"
*!8#
!/=-&"*#'"
.
.#!/=-&"*#'"

32"&
.
"+#
3-.3&#

32!''#/
/#6#23*#'"
!'/
%'
$!&#
%"
;#$*#&
'#$#&&!.5
"
9%6#
!
2%""2#
!//%"%'!2
!.#!
.*
"+#
32"&
"
"+#
!33#22!'"&7
"+#
!33#22!'"&
&+!22
;#
;-'/
"
"!8#
"+!"
!//%"%'!2
!.#!
!'/
!2&
;#
;-'/
"
3!5
$&"

&-$+
!.#!
!&
%&
$+!.9#!;2#
"
"+#.
!22""##&
+#
!33#22!'"&
&+!22
!2&
;#
;-'/
"
3!5
"+#
/#6#23*#'"!2
$+!.9#&
!&
%&
$+!.9#/
.*
"+#.
!22""##&
"
%&
3#'
"
"+#
3!."%#&
"
32!$#
/$-*#'"&
.
*!"#.%!2
%'
&-33."

"+#%.
$'"#'"%'&


#
#F3#$"
"+!"
!&
!.
!&
3&&%;2#7
"+#
.#&3'/#'"&
&+!22
".5
"
.#"!%'
"+#
&".-$"-.#&7
-'2#&&
%"
;#$*#&
/%

%$-2"
.
"+#*
"
+!6#
!
32!''#/
/#6#23*#'"
<%"+-"
.#*6%'9
"+#*
%'
6%#<
 <+!"
%&
&"!"#/
!;6#H
'
6%#<

"+#
"+#.# 7
<#
/
'"
%'/
!'5
*#.%"
%'
"+#
3.#&#'"
<.%"
3#"%"%'
+#
&!*#
%&
!$$./%'925
/%&*%&&#/

        ' (         )            '$*+ (         )    

)
!'=
+-"!'%J/&