High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22145/2012dismissed

Rajiv Bhatia And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2017-11-01Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages

!""#$%$&' (

)$*+ !$ &!+", -- "!$!$&",% .",%/% 0! !" /&) 1 &2 &!+", -- "%3&2"&!%

,"%"&!'-

, /, *0+ ,4 52*# !",!+"3"!$!$&",%

,*$&$!* %!+$55 /&) 1

"!$!$&",% +","$& 7"," 33$&!"2 % 0/3",*$%,% /&2", !+" %#+"4"%3&%,"218!+"*!&2$ 9&7& %"&%/%04 ::0# :" &2/%!,$ : &$!%/&2",!+" ";$%&2/%!,$"%"3 ,!4"&!50! !" /&) 1

3& 1:$!$&!+"%#+"4"3"!$!$&",%7",","!,"&#+"2,4%",*$#"& <(== 3:$#82"#$%$&7 %! 9"&18!+"0! !" /&) 1! 2)/%! ::

!+"%! 57+7",","!,"&#+"2,4!+""&%/%0#+"4"!+"&2/%!,$"% "3 ,!4"&!9""3$&;$&*$"7!+">/ :$$# !$&%3%%"%%"218!+"4&!+" :$;+!%/#+3:$#82"#$%$&+ *$&;1""&! 9"&51!+!+"3"!$!$&",%7"," 2)/%!"2&!+"3%! %!",%# ,,8$&;3 8%# :" %? -=*$2"

,2",%2 !"2== &&"@/," -? 0/1%">/"&!:85&!+"1 %$% %"&$,$!8-#/4-4",$!$&!+"# 2," %!",%53"!$!$&",&7 %3,4!"2 %A"#!/,",*$2",2",2 !"2? &% , %3"!$!$&",&$% #&#",&"25+"%/1)"#!"2+$4%":! 3,#"%%%":"#!$& ; $&%!!+"3%! A"#!/,", !+ ! 7 % 2*",!$%"2 &2 7 % 2/:8 %":"#!"2 & !+" 3%! &2 33$&!"2 % A"#!/,",*$2",2",2 !"2==

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

#&%$2",+$% #: $4, 1%,3!$&& %/$! 1:"3%! %3",>/ :$$# !$&%3%%"%%"218 +$4 0 !& 40$&;+57++ 2" ,:$",1""& 2)/%!"2 % &00 %!",& ==5 ##,2$&;:857 %","2!+"3%!0"&$,%%$%! &!# ,,8$&; !

0/#+ "43:8"" !+"& 3,"",,"2 ==<

, $%$&; #: $4!+ !+"/;+!!+ *"1""& 1%,1"2 % A"#!/,",$&%#+:# 2,"$&!+":$;+!!+">/ :$$# !$&%2!+ ! +"3%%"%%"2 &2/,!+",, $%$&; 3:" !+ !!+"3%!A"#!/,",$&%#+: # 2,"7 %# ,,8$&;!+"% 4"3 8%# :" %!+"3%!0"&$,%%$%! &!*"& %/#+7,$!3"!$!$&7 % ::7"2*$2")/2;"4"&!2 !"2= 53 %%"218 ,2$& !""&#+!+$%/,! !&&"@/," -= &2!+","%3&2"&!%7","

2$,"#!"2 ! 2)/%! !+" 3"!$!$&", !+","$& $" 0 !& 4 0$&;+ % A"#!/,",

%#+:# 2,",4!+"2 !"+"+ 2 #>/$,"2!+",">/$%$!">/ :$$# !$&%

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

%!",%&==*"&&%/#+2 !"1!+!+"3"!$!$&",%3%%"%%"2 !+">/ :$$# !$&%2 "!+ ! %$!4 85!+"8 ##"3!"2!+"$, 33$&!4"&!$&!+" %!",# 2," "!$!$&",&18*$,!/"%"&$,$!8$& !+" %!", # 2," 7 % "*"& 3,4!"2 % A"#!/,", & ? &2 3"!$!$&",&7 % 33$&!"2 % A"#!/,",&== % ,"%+,"#,/$! !&%! ;"2$2!+"3"!$!$&",%#+%"! ;$! !"!+"$,#: $4!$%&:8 !", !+"2"#$%$&$& ==<

2 !"2= $&!+"# %" 0 !& 40$&;+!+ !!+"3"!$!$&",%+ *"79"&/3! ;$! !"!+"$,#: $4 +"$%%/","; ,2$&;2": 8$&$&*9$&;!+""@!, ,2$& ,87,$! )/,$%2$#!$&/&2",,!$#:"?!+"&%!$!/!$&&2$ !!+"+ &2% & "43:8""18, $%$&; #: $4!+ !%$4$: ,:8%$!/ !"2"43:8""%+ *" :," 28 1""& ;, &!"2 ,":$"5 7 % #&%$2","2 18 !+" &C1:" 3"@ /,! $&

! "#$%&' # ! "#$

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

"#$ %%& '() *

+ &( & % ,& %-& !$ .( / )0011*5$!7 %3$&"2!+ !3",%&% 7+ 33, #+"2!+"/,! ! 1": !"2%! ;"3: #$&;,":$ &#"/3&!+",2", 3 %%"2$&%4"!+",# %"" ,:$",5# &1"2"&$"2!+"2$%#,"!$& ,8,":$"& !+";,/&22": 8 &2: #+"%+",":"* &!1%",* !$&%4 2"18!+" 0/3,"4"/,! ,"#&! $&"2$& , %5? &2?!+")/2;4"&! &2 ,"

"@!, #!"2+","/&2",'-

! " # $

" %&''()*##*''+

, 4

6 &&4

7 6

*'4&''*)9&''

&'')&''&&''* &''0&''

&'' &''4

, 555555 )4

-4-

;<$ = +"$%%/"2": 87 % :%2" :!7$!+18!+$%/,!$&&$

%& / 01##$ "'$"2"#"

#$! !"#$& )*-3(3, 3-.&!+"# %" ,%"4 :

%/3, 5!+"3"!$!$&",7 %%",*$&; % :",9 7$!+ !+" ,"%3&2"&!-,3, !$& &2 + 2 ,"!$,"2 & < <

: $4$&!+"7,$!3"!$!$&7 %!;, &!!+$4!+"1"&"$!3,$#$"&#8%"! /3$&!+"3 8%# :"&#43:"!$&<8" ,%%",*$#",4!+"2/"2 !" % 3",3:$#8!+",3, !$&/,$&;!+"%",*$#"# ,"",5+"+ 2&! ;$! !"2 !+"#: $4,$&#,"4"&!% ,!+"$,%!!$4"5%/#+#: $4+ 21""&4 2"& B

$")/%!&"4&!+3,$,!%/3", &&/ !$&+$:"&&-%/$!$&; !+"3"!$!$&",& ##/&!2": 8 &2: #+"%$!7 %+":2 %::7%'- ))>

)84

&''

*)*&''

-9-

)* #

;

&!+":$;+!%/#+#:" ,"&/&#$ !$&53"!$!$&",%# &&!1" 3",4$!!"2!; $& &8$43"!/%,4!+")/2;"4"&!2":$*","2$&!+"# %" 0 !& 40$&;+57+!+",7$%"7 %%$4$: ,:8%$!/ !"21/!+ 2 33, #+"2 !+$%/,!$,%!$&3$&!!$4"18$:$&; ( ==B &2 ::7"218 ==<

2"#$2"2&= &&"@/," -= +",":$ &#"3: #"218#/&%": 33" ,$&;,!+"3"!$!$&",% /3& /::"&#+)/2;"4"&!!+$%/,!$&( 2/(3 %%& 4 25 .

1 ! *",#4" !+" +/,2:" 2": 8 $% :% 4$%3: #"2+"$%%/"$&( 2/(6 # %" %/3, 7 % %,"; ,2%3 8 $@ !$& &2$!7 %+":2!+ !%/#+4 !!",%$&*:*" ,"#/,,$&;# /%" #!$& &2 %%/#+57,$!3"!$!$&%,%/#+#: $4# &&!1"2$%4$%%"2&!+";,/&2 2": 8 &2: #+"% &2!+"/,! !!+"4%!54 8,"%!,$#!!+" ,," ,%/3! <B4&!+%,4!+"2 !"$:$&;!+"3"!$!$& &22$% ::7!+" ,," ,%, !+"3",$2,7+$#+"*"& %/$!+ 21"#4"!$4"1 ,,"2 *"&%/#+ 1%",* !$&% %,"; ,2% %3"#!2": 8$&( 2/(6 # %" %/3, 7","

$&!+":$;+!!+")/2;"4"&!!+"&C1:"3"@/,!$&7+%3

-7-

%"&( 1 0 &27+","$&$!+ 21""& # !";,$# ::8+":2!+ !%:&; % &"43:8""$%$&%",*$#" ,"%+# /%" #!$& ,$%"%"*",84&!+7+"&+"$%;"!!$&;+$%4&!+:8% : ,8&!+"1 %$% 7,&;# :#/: !$&4 2"#&!, ,8!,/:"% +")/2;"4"&!$& ( 2 /(6 # %" %/3, 5 %%/#+57/:2+ *"& 33:$# 1$:$!8!!+" #!% !+"3,"%"&!# %" &%$2",$&;!+"2$#!/4: 7 %: $227&$&"( 4 $8!6 # %" %/3, 5!+"3"!$!$&",%+","$& ,"&!"&!$!:"2!!+",":$" %3, 8"2, &2!+"3"!$!$&$%2$%4$%%"2&!+";,/&22": 8 &2 : #+"% ,2","2 ##,2$&;:8 ( , *---)*-4 :/#98 +"!+",%3" 9$&;D," %&"2'

"%D +"!+", "3,! 1:"'

"%D