High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-CARB/18/2020disposed of

M/S Rays Power Infra Pvt. Ltd. v. M/S Landmark Infonet Pvt. Ltd.

2020-10-05Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan5 pages

!"# $

% &'

( ) ) "#

*" ))*

+ )() $ %&'(!)*+

,(-*+

....... &)*,&-.$&'

/'( ( ! & %+ ( 01 2 3 243 ' 4( ( +(!( ( + * 556 2'( 7+ 83 ( ' 1 &&

4 '!( (!)( (+ 9&+&"(( 9&* % +(! ""+(! & :&&" 2' ' ""+(! & 3*(4( (, ;

(!&%+ (5

' ( (" & 1 ' &&

' ! ""+(!& (+ (

2'( 7 !!

83 ( "#

2'( 7

!83&( 4!+&( (

' ' 4# & & * 0*16*1 * & &('( '(+'* ' ++& ' !!

(+ < '

& '(+ (+ =&(( 4# & ( &(' ( ("* ' ++&

'!! "(

+' ' " ( >

/' ! ""+(! & ! (& (+ ( (( ' ( &('(+' '(" &&!"((+* ' (&( '(+'

!+&!(# (+!& !"

# > ( ( '( *( ' '(!& (#

(+!&( '( ' ( &! ("

, (+" ( ' )'(*+ ( ( , -*%(+ *++ (+4'!

@( '+ +&!* ' !( #& (!'( ( !

/' 4( + + ' & '( !

!( ' ! (%+ ??*:&&" ' ( '& &+ &4&(!

'& /' ( '(! '4&(!(* (+!&( '+ #(&+( '4" #( ' + ( ' ( ' ' 4&(!(* & 4

4 ! + 4*

! ( 5 " '! 1*50*

*>+!&( '"( ++' * ;*16

/' ! ! (( '" 0A0A0*( '(( (! ( ' 4( '!+#( (*'(+' +""+ + 4*

++& ' !+# ( ' # ( 5 "(+*

> ( (4(!( "# " ' & (+''( !!&&'

"" ("4 "(! 0 ' (!*

/' ( &4=& ! ( & *( '4( + ((

/' 4>"( '( * (+ ( &! 4 ' &4B+ "

' +( ' !* +" !( ' 4 (! ( ' !+! !(+ ( 4

!!4

!( +' ' /'( 4>"( '( '&!4 '&4B+ "

& ' +((+++( '! /' "(

( (* '* ( 5 ' 9&*

! (& (+

#( " 0;*5;* ?

( '( ( ;" ' +( ' (+ /' !!

!( '( (+

' 9&*

' ( !*

B& '(

0 &"" '+&( ( ?1*;5*

*!(!4!(

/' + ' "

(

+!(" 4( (

5 '9&!

(!&( ( & ((! 9& 29&( )(((3* :&&" ( '(+'

! 1 '9&!*

(! !(+ ( &%+ ( * ( (& '>( +4( (+!& ( ' ! ' >

! (! 4( ( , ;

( ""+(!& &%+ (5 !( ' !(+ ( ( ("!(

'9&!

*( (" 4 '""+(!& <( '4#++&

(4 (*

(! !( '(& ('(+' 0 9&!

*(+ ( '!""+(!&

# +(( ' !(+ ( & %+ ( 5 ' + C !( D* ( ' !(4 4( (

(! !(+ (<( '++& '4( ' ! #(

' !( ' +( /' * 1 '&&

* '( 4 '(* '(" & 4 '""+(!&

' !(4&4 %&'(!)*&! (

*++ 4(!( '( & /'& ( ' ( ' (& ' ' ' ( & 4 ' ( ( 4( 4! * ( " ' 4( ( +!& ( ' ! * ( ( +4&4

4 '4(

,> *( (&4"(

4 ) ' ( &!!

' ( +!(" "&

! 4( &'

4 +& 4 ' (" & * (+&!! (+ ' ( ( ( ' 4( (!( +!(" ' 4 # 4

E =&4("4 '(& * ,-*! %(&!* (

!+!(( (+ ' ( " 4( ' 4 (&

++(

' & ( " +'*

+!+&! '4!+!+# (( (!!

'% "4

*&!#& 4" '

'(&!4>+!&( '"( ++' -*'* +!(( '+&( ( ( '&" ?1*;5*

((!4! (

(& ( ' 4""4!

'(+' (!! ( ' "( - +!(" ' # "( (!!(

)*'*( &

'( ?

-(' '4&4"((* '& ( '( =&( ( &! 4 4!+ ( ' !!( (+ ( (& ( &4 & ( ' (+ ( (& 4 ' 4 (" & 1 &&

'!""+(!&

++(!*( ((+

$ 2(34

'+ 4*

$0 "*

(!!

!&" ;

*'(+'&"'!!

'4# 4

!((> ( 2)3*(( "* ( ' + ' (> ( +( (

/')'!!(( (!!4 ((!! 4# &( + ( /'()(!! 4 +'&( ' + ( +( 2((3

'+ 4*

'& '(< ( 4

! '!! "( ' "( /' "( (!! 4

(!!4 "(

"!!( "4! '( +&!! ( '& '(+ ( (!! 4

; ' ( " ( 4 4 ' ( '( >+( ( +" ! * ' "((!!4 #4

!4 !+( ( !+# E +" ! ( ' 4 ++&

'!! < '

2(((34 ("( '(" & 1 '&&

'""+(!& (!!4 ( + (

'( (! "( ( '(&(4 ' (( 4( ( +( 2(3 (!!4

(!! ' !( "' ( ! ( ' 4( 4(!( ' ( & !!

! ( ( ( &+' !* 4 ' ! 4( *'(!!+(&+' !(+++( '!*&(!&+ 44 (( '(" & 1 '&&

23/' (!!4&4B+ "((+ (4 '4( ( !(+ ("4( ' &%+ ( 1

2(3/'! (+ ((&4 '(" & 1 '&&

( ?

2(((3* '> =&((

(# ' 4( ( +!& ( '( 5 ' (" & 4( *'!!"( /' !(( ( '4 " /)*

+ 0 /()0 # $

% &' 12 @' ' #( F , @' ' 4! F ,