Renu Gupta v. State Of Haryana & ORS




    
 

"#$$%&'&()* 

+ $(,,-#"

..

$#&#&($+ /$+','

0#"#$"+1"(""(2#3$+'

..

$'-(2$(#'

 


     

+$'$(#).

+0"+2"4&(2$+1"5624%"#$+#3$-$#&#&($+ + "4& +"#"-0&(7366"+1"(" +0 "8"#624%"#$++$'-(2$(#(        ::;

--5&%"#&(&'"558$2',<=$%##"55=,'#$>%$-#&(' %,?$(#'"#(($>,+$' .# .

"+$#"@$((+$%+2  :: 

--5&%"#&(&'2&'?&''$2"'(#-+$''$2 "&( $#&#&( +0 "8"#624%"#$3"'-,#&("--$"+"(%$(<$3"5 #3$%(#$'#&(7A"5"A"=-"# "& (&4$+'&#1/$#$+&("+1(&?"50%&$(%$'6 &'"+.+$'-(2$(#( "(23"'&5$2"8+&##$('#"#$?$(#0"?$&'#"@$(( +$%+2-13"'<$$(,+(&'3$2#5$"+($2%,('$5+#3$-$#&#&($+ 3$'3+#%(#+4$+'1+"&'$2&(#3$-$#&#&($?"("#$'+?#3$ &'',"(%$"?$?2"#$2

&'',$2<1#3$+$'-(2$(#.,(&4$+'&#1 &(4&#&(7(?&("#&('+?#3$&(#$+$'#$2"%,5#1?$?<$+'+#+"&(&(7( B(&?"5+"(',(2"+1"(2?$+7&(7&'$"'$'C'#"+#&(7+?;:

#

&(
'+"$53$%+&#$+&"+%('&2$+"#&(#3$"--5&%"#&('8"'"'

.

.

558').

  

            



 



 

    

 

     !"#$%&"        

   
' (

)   

&  * 

+
#'#+"('-&+$'#3"##3$-$#&#&($+6838"'-"+##3$$"%3&(7

"%,5#1/ /$#$+&("+1 ,<5&%$"5#3-&2$?&571!"5'',<?&##$2 3$+"--5&%"#&(&(+$'-('$#?$?2"#$2

3$  7+&$4"(%$  +"&'$2  &(  #3$  &('#"(#  -$#&#&(  &'  #3"#  #3$ "--5&%"#&(#3$-$#&#&($+3"'(# $4$( <$$(%('&2$+$2 "(2-+&4"#$ +$'-(2$(#(*&$+?"(D,?"+6''&'#"(#0%&$(#&'#6$-"+#?$(# (&?"5&$%3(5713"'<$$((?&("#$2#"##$(2#3$#+"&(&(7'$''&( 8$;:

#

&(
'+"$5
(#3$8+&##$('#"#$?$(#&5$2(<$3"5#3$ (&4$+'&#1&#3"'

<$$('#"#$2#3"#-+&4"#$+$'-(2$(#(*8"'$5&7&<5$&(#$+?'#3$%+&#$+&" 2&'%5'$2&(#3$?$?2"#$2

"'3$<$5(7'##3$ "%,5#1 (&?"5  &  $%3(5716  83&%3  #3$+8&'$  &'  &(454$2  &(  +$'$"+%3  ( B(&?"5+"(',(2"+1"(2?$+7&(7&'$"'$'C"(2"'',%363"'<$$( 2,51%('&2$+$2"(2(?&("#$2
('"+"'#3$-$#&#&($+&'%(%$+($26#3$ '#"(2#"@$(&'#3"#'3$2$'(#-''$''"(1$>-$+&$(%$&(#3$%(%$+($2 &$52"(2"'',%33"'(#<$$(%('&2$+$2$4$($5&7&<5$+%('&2$+"#&( 3&',+#&'-+&?""%&$#3$4&$8#3"##3$"%#&(#3$ +$'-(2$(# (&4$+'&#1&(3"4&(7$>%5,2$2#3$-$#&#&($++?$4$(#3$E($ %('&2$+"#&(&(-,+',"(%$#?$?2"#$2

%"((#','#"&( 5",'$*#3$%+&#$+&"8"'&(%5$"+#$+?'&$#3$(?&($$?,'#<$+?#3$

"%,5#1 &%+<&571F/ F"(1#3$+"%,5#1&(454$2&(+$'$"+%3

.*.

3$+$&'("?<&7,&#1&(#3$5"(7,"7$83"#'$4$+'-$+#3$,(&4$+'&#1 &#'$56(?&($$'+?#3$"%,5#1 &%+<&571F/ &("(1%"'$8$+$ $5&7&<5$
("22&#&(#3$+$#(?&($$'$4$(+?#3$+"%,5#&$'%,52"--51 ',<=$%###3$-+4&'#3"#',%3"%,5#&$'"5'&(454$2&(+$'$"+%3(#3$ +$5$4"(##-&%F&$523$-$#&#&($+638$4$+63"'<$$($>%5,2$2+?#3$ E($%('&2$+"#&((#3$-+$#$>##3"#'3$&'"?$?<$+#3$#$"%3&(7 "%,5#1"(22$'(#-''$''+$'$"+%3$>-$+&$(%$3$%+&#$+&""'+$7"+2' +$'$"+%38"'+$5"#"<5$##3$"%,5#14$("'-$+#3$%+&#$+&"(?&($$'+? <#3#3$"%,5#&$' &%+<&571"(2/ 8$+$&("(1%"'$$5&7&<5$ 3$( #3&' ?"##$+%"?$,-+3$"+&(7  + "8"#65$"+($2 %,('$5"--$"+&(7+#3$,(&4$+'&#1',73#2$$+?$(#&(3$"+&(7+"$8 3,+'#%?

-5$#$&('#+,%#&('"'+$7"+2'',%3-'&#&( + "8"#3"'(8 "--+&'$2#3$,+##3"#"#$+3"4&(77#&(#,%38&#3#3$/&%$3"(%$55+ #3$+$'-(2$(#,(&4$+'&#13$3"'#$5$-3(&%&('#+,%#&('##3$$$%##3"#&( %"'$#3$-$#&#&($+',<?&#'"%?-+$3$('&4$+$-+$'$(#"#&(8&#3+$7"+2# 3$+%5"&?&(-,+',"(%$#?$?

2,+&(7#3$%,+'$#3$ 2"16',%3+$-+$'$(#"#&(8,52<$2$"5#8&#3'#+&%#51&(#3$5&73##3$ %+&#$+&"?$(#&($2&(#3$?$?2"#$2

"(2"&("52$%&'&(8,52 <$#"@$(8&#3&("-$+&2($8+@&(72"1
&(2',%3'#"(2#"@$((<$3"5#3$,(&4$+'&#1#<$"&+"(2 "%%$-#"<5$ 3$&('#"(#-$#&#&(&'6"%%+2&(75162&'-'$2&(#$+?' 7+"(#&(75&<$+#1##3$-$#&#&($+#',<?&#"+$-+$'$(#"#&("'+$7"+2'3$+ %5"&?+#3$#+"&(&(7+?;:

#

&(
'+"$5(#3$',<=$%# B(&?"5+"(',(2"+1"(2?$+7&(7&'$"'$'C
(#3$$4$(#,"5&#1#3$

..

+$-+$'$(#"#&(  <$&(7  ',<?&##$2  2,+&(7  #3$  %,+'$  #3$ 2"16 #3$  /&%$ 3"(%$55+#3$+$'-(2$(#,(&4$+'&#18,52<$<5&7"#$2#%('&2$+#3$ '"?$6##"@$"&("54&$8&(#3$?"##$+"(2#%(4$1#3$2$%&'&(##3$ -$#&#&($+&(#$+?'"8$55+$"'($2'-$"@&(7+2$+-'&#&4$51(:

$#&#&(2&'-'$2 %-1#3&'+2$+<$,+(&'3$2#5$"+($2%,('$5+#3$ -"+#&$',(2$+#3$'&7("#,+$'$(%30$%+$#"+1          

5,%@1 3$#3$+'-$"@&(7F+$"'($2) $'

3$#3$+ $-+#"<5$)