Union Of India & ORS v. Devinder Pal Singh & ORS
!"# %"&'()*+,# -#
"/%0120%3%%20 %4%5-%/%1'- 40
6'1'
/ %)207%0
'*/'
!" #$%&'"#()$ '&&!
!" #$%&'" '&!
***
'( 3
%8)0%+%-/&%- "0*'
3
%/%+9%4/-/&%- "'*/
::::: '&!+# *1'1%&0//%/#
;
.-3 <14%)20- '%2- =*14%'*'1%240&/%/ '%+4%'*1'/
0'0*/0*'4*'400 >15*&/2'%/%2%''*/
41/,/+/ ,>1%'0/"&+*20'%+400+"%+*'&,/,5 0%/+'%,1%-0%/2%0&0?"'0@AB 40/'*'2"
"# #///%/#
!40 %&%%0%&%'"C&&1'"0>15-0&0%2C'0 '/1*'*/
41/%1+%&%5,>1%'0/
3
%8)0%+%-%/&1'"0*''1,+/
0% &,- D.
- '*/
4%' %**/ %' '''%
+%'*&% =*1'-0 %4%5 05% # ;- -D # ;-40492%'))&2? C%5B- - ))E CE % =*1- %**&% &++/ '1'
2%'
&&/25-04%'&0%2C'0/,5'20"42 &0%2'(C
!"
#
%
&'
# $ (
#
& $ )
!"
$ $
(
%
* +
,-.+
$
# %
&&&&
**&%C'*/
&0%2/ 0 %"+/ &0%2C'0,"0%/+'%,1%/
?
B"# #%////%/#
!-0'%+4%'/'*'/",5 02%2"%**150+*105 &&1/0/*%+%*&/2'40+0"+#
!%/ &%'"C&&1'-0*&/2''0%'%/>1%'0/ &&/2 0%/&1'-"%&-0%"+//&1200% ,+0"+0/%"&*"&"/&*5"0/ 0 %"+//4%''120,4/,5 4**&% DE# ! '92 0 +0'G + &&1/ 0 /*%+% *&/2'-,1///%/;
$?H1 B-0'%+4%'
/'+''/-40&0'%'1/&0%2 4%' H &// 0% 0 // &'/ 0 /%/"%&'H*%/0%**&%'924"&+*2 0>15400'*1%/+ 0&*5"0//%/#
4%'&/
!%/0"+%>1/,5 %4%5%/- -2%7 &%'""
)204%''0 %4%5%/ #D
04'1++%&%'%/0%**&%"4 4%' "/ 02' "0/%- - '*' %9%" &1+%">15204'%+-4%'%'*%%/ *%&"0%**&%-,10'%+4%'%/0/ **&%C '*/
0%',+*'/% *%5 "# I&10+05 *'"%*/"05%'%/0/0%',&++1&%/
'*/
0%'%'*%%&%1'"%&&0%20'%+
&%- 3'
%/%+9% 4/- %/ &1' " '*/
0%'/%40%"0'10&'"
%%$"0%**&%'924"0/%'H*%%0%/ ,"1'0/%92%5""&'*'"+
!*2 "0%"'1++%&%'-40&0*/0"'49"15- 0&"/&*5"0/4%'**%/,50 2'5 #D
02 */ 0 /*%+ + % %**&% '92H'"+%/-01'-/*%+%*&/2'%/ *1'1%& 0 '& " 0 &0%2C'0- 0 >15 * %/ +*'"*%5/+/,>1%'0/ 0/*%+0%/, /%520&1+%"0>15*&/2'+%5&&%'' '0',%&9/*"0+%-02%/+0+%/-01'- 12/0'1"1*0/2"0/'1/&0%2
0%0%/0%/&1'"0*%'-%**%'/0 *%*,9%/%"040%0,1%1200%2 +0+"+0/%"&*"&"/&*5"0//%/
!-40&04%'&/,50*
0%+ " &* " &"/ &*5 " 0 /
! 0%' , &/ 0'40&00%/%9*%&%"0*%''2"0 /,50-H%&/04*-%*/1&/0 ,4(C + '"&/0&!1 )
%( & & +
#
+& &
%
%( 45
%(6 4 + & !7&/8&!1 9( /'&/0&!1 % & '0&/8&!1 % #
93)
: &
+ (
#
/1 /7 !1 +& &
& !"&/7&!1 )
%( 3
# 5&0"
'/!1
/'&/0&!1& '1&/7&!1
)
4-
93) %
$
# & '8&/7&!1
3# %
93) #
4 ;$
93) %
#
(
#
'8&/"&!1& 1!&/7&!1 )
%( 4-
#
+# ( #
+& &
< 9
# & /'
/= !1 4-
%(
# & '8&/"&!1
)
# % > '"&!/&!1& /?
!/ !1 )
< 9
# (
#
9
%( & '1&!/&!1 )
%( #
< 9
'/@ # ( A
( & '0&!/&!1 )
4-
+ B#
/?&!/&!1 '1&!/&!1& '"&!/&!1
> !8&!'&!1& '7&!!&!1 )
%(
4- % # ( +& &
&
+ !8&!'&!1 B
93) # % & B
93) > #
#
%( /= /!
!?
& ;
0/*%+0%/2/1H*%%"&+*2 0 >15 40 0 + "%+ 4 %**&% 0%/ , /'+''/401&20%"+/"%&-40%'H'4%' >1/,2%/
/+/5- 3
%8 )0%+%- %/ &1' " 0 *'0%'%**'/0'10%0>15 ""&0%/&+*/ 0>15/0'*/%/ ,5'%,'025&0%2
-40%'&0%2 #4%''%,'0/ 0'%+4%'*%&/ ,"0 1'02105%/0H&1&-///%/ #!
!-%2/400>15*%///"+*'" +%8*%5"# I&10+05*'"%*/"05%' %/0'%+0%/,&++1&%/0%**&%C'*/
/ 2'//%/#.
/0&&1+'%&'-14-4%'>1/ */0''1%"+/%*%2+%&+% '1%5-0 /"0'+/"/%/+0+0/"/%/
!41/&++&"+0/%"&*"&"/&*5"0 /- -
!%/0%**&%"40%2,"/
!/1%&%',44%'&&58&/ 420%"+/,'%'"+/"&% 0/-42,50%**&%&0%20//%/ #!
!-40,5+%8*%5"# I&10+05*'0%' ,//-404+0'"+0/%"&*"&"/&*5
"0*'/%&&/%&40%4 00%"+/+/"&%0/"0- 4*'%/'%4/ ?#()$ '&&!, - '&!, #$./"
#$./"
0 +3 41 6 6 50 47 89
:
(
6 6 42
(