M/S Goyal Trading Co. v. The State Of Punjab And Others




    
 

  

   !"#$% &
  '

 $()*+,(% - .

     !"#  $ %"&     !"# "& '"(%'"&% %  / %).!"#01'  %(. % %2&3(4 #01#1!0*+,

$ %"&)

$(. %( ..% ((


*%.%"

&%5* (.%'

3%%6 .

,"(78

 $8

%/
*3/

&

%04%#18*%/&

(. % 9% * #%(. % ( %3 (

 ) 6(*+,:#*1$81 0 

(%;(1 ;0.%'

*#,%3<  3( %3( '

8$(

((

(.%3

%< %% *  $(

. &* ( 

%.

(,= 

*    (  . %  <

*    >   $(  .%'

#

*# ##",%3<

(%%3 ' (

= (<(

((.%30**( (%< '

8,"(. %




///

((%(0#%) * # ( *,

<%

##"

*(. %0(<'%0(.

 *  #"

&  (  .%      #  

  <

*      $(  %%    

3  .

  <  <

8  3(

(%%30( 0,"#   ('#% * #%(.% .%* (..% ,= $(     (  (  ,*

 .%3

   (  . %  <

 0

 

.*$(*&((. % # 3 ( % '

> 18*%/6*%) 6 (1 .%.

&%3.%'

3(<'% %.#"( . 0 ( (% .

 ( % #"(. % <

% ..%    (( . % ..% ##   0  % (  

  <

*  %      (    <

+*%(%%*3,%

0,%

<

* > %> $(.%'

#%%

3< .

 6  ) 6(1 % *% / ?6%'

#1

3/ <  "(    0<(%%*%< ##*# &# ( , 33 < ('

<'% ' (."38%*8( ,. % %*%( , #,"%,(#.% 0 (  

&  

%  3"0  %  (  %    , % % <% &03=.%'

3% ".% %3 (8# , # " '0

/6// ' %*. %'

(8# , # " * (.% (## ,  

   ##"  %  (   #  (

 %*%    ( .%

% ,3%  $(  .%'

#  

3  *%  *,/

 (##,3<

%3( $(
33

%3"0 (<'%0%% ,% % <% &08 (.% ,"(%

.%

*#% %%%( 3,"(

&

%@ 1.%* #(% .%'

(< ((

&

%( ,3.<%3=.%'

3#%0% (% ,% % <% &0<(%0( %/#  ((%

  '8$(.%'

,%3<

.%

%3( $(
33

%3"0 %(% ,% % <% &08( .% ,"(%

.%

*#% 0%%%( 3,"(

&

% 1%(

(,*

.%3

 0 (< * 

>  <

*( . %%..% > A( ,3 ( %

%.

(',* (,= 

* %0 <(

(<% B( 3

 *, 5*#".%* ,"

(. %,%> 0%(

< %% *$( 

% *% / ?-&% &(%  *,+ "*%, %3 ("*% %3<

 $( %3

/ //  % &

* ##6  <(

((

#

 =< 
00 60> C/$(  =<(

(<

',"( %3(,

%0(  =<(

< * ( (.'#* & 
 06C/$(%

%    
>060

C/  *% &  ( 

   .*% ( ( ,*(( %3( 3 %

# #.*% ( $'% "( 30"*% ( ,  8  %  >   %%    %3  .%'

#

3*C 6(*+,:1$1 0 %( .% %3  6  D*%(%,"

, &   %     ..%  ,%  (  *%

&   > < (##(

*,= #.*% ( '* (% -3 0 #%0

) %% 0 4%#1 A

.% 3 (%(  ..% (%  3"*% <*# ,

8/.%"*<*#, *,+ .#"

3* &
0*C *+,:1$1 0 @ 1.%* #(% 

 (< ((##&'

8< %%%,"(

&

%<( #

* &

 > A%3 (.%'

) 6(1 0(

*#,%3<

%3 ( A(.% 

=%3(

0

3( .% 8.

%> E<'%0(.%'

#%%

/ //

3< .

6 0,"(.%

A

( (.%3("8

<  (% *&(,"( 

& 

%  %  &%  ,"  ( 
33

%  %  %3 &  (

3


% &( ((.%'

3( , %3%.%

%3(0'

< ##&#"

 0(%% %' ,5* (

%%

% &#" E<'%05* &(%% 5* < ## ( %&*#%

3.%  %03",

% &(

33% # $(.  

.   -+ (4 #   2*& E% %) &() (*   2*&  ((% .= &C%  D C  ((%-.%,# D C