M/S Hans Raj And Sons v. The State Of Punjab And Another
!" #
% &'#( ") '$ !
!"# $ %"& !"# "& '"(%'"&% $ $# *,-./0% $'* $ $123' 4
./0.0,/( ")
$ %"&)
&'* $' **$'' ($*$- 2$5( ' '*$%
$$67
)-'89 &9 $+(3+ $/4$ .0
9($+2
'* $ :$ (
.$'* $ ()3' $3 '
# 6'( ");.(0&90/7
'$<'0</*$%
(.)$3=' *$
3 $3' % 9&' ()3
''
'*$3 $= $$(
7&' * 2( ' $* ')> ( ' * $ =
( ?7 &' *$% .
(. ..-)$3=' '$$3 % ' > ' ='''*$3 /( (' '$= % 9)-'* $
+++
''$' /.$ #(
. ()3' () =$ ..-
('* $/'=%$/'* ( .- 2 ' *$ . =
(
&' $$
*
= =' 9 3
'$$3/' / )- .3 '%.$ (
.$'*$ *$( '**$ )> &' ' ' )(
*$3 ' * $ =
* 7/ *(&'(2''* $.3 '$% ?70
9($+6( $# 6 '0*$* 2$3*$%
'=%$ $*.-' * / ' '$ '$ .-'* $ =
$**$ 77 ' ' * $ **$..
7/ $ ' =
( $ 7 ' =
"($ '$$ (3)$
/)$ =
(
?7$?7&'*$% .$$
=
67 # 6'0$ ( @6$% .0
+ ='
-' 2 A/='$$($=..(.
2.' 33='%=%$ %'*-3 9$(9' ) *$ $($ ' ) .)-$ )'.*$ / ' $ 3-/ $ ' $
) $$ =$ 2/3>*$%
$ -*$$3 '9.).- %/
+6++ %$( *
$%'9.).- ('*$ '..
)
..- $ ' . ' $($ ' *$ $)3
$ &' *$% .
( $ ()+
'..)3='
$3' &'33
$3-/ '=%$/$$
)$$ =$ 2/9 '*$)- '$ *$(.$ $$$'3)-' $B 0*$( .'$ *$% '= ''
$' 3*=$3>*$%
.$/$ '$
)$$ =$ 2/='$/' $+. ''$
%9&'*$%
)$3='
*$ $3' &'33
$3-/ $'$
)$$ =$ 2/9 ' *$)- '$
*$(.$ /$$$'3)-' $ 0$'
')(
*$3 7/ '=( ?7 =
(' * $$**$ ?7C' 3 '$
$* '%) ( ')> ( $/ =''=$ D'3
() 5( .-*$()- '* $)$?7/$'
= $$(&'
$ ( @!2$ 2'$ ()"-($) 2 $3 '-($$3=
* 7&'$3
+ ++ ()3 $ 2( ..6A7 =''' . 2 >= //A/7A +&' >=''=
2% )-'$3 ') $/' >=''
= ( ' '*%.( 2 ?/66/ 7 +&'$ $ ?6/A7/? + ($ 2 '
*($' ' ( ''$3' 3$
..*($' &%$-' 3/-($ '
9 $ ?7 $$ $3 *$% .
( 6'( ");0&0/7$' *$$3 76A7E($'$)- ) 2 $ **$ )$ ' (
?7='..'( )> . *($' %('$ !3 / .$/ #$$/ 4$ .0 C *$ 3 '$'
**$ '$ 3-($ =(. )9+*$ -(=(.) ()"* .- 3( 2/( ( ");0&0/7B 0*$( .'$ '= ''..2%
9= $$$)-' $='.
( 2
?7C $3 '*$%
# 6'0/'
(.)$3=' $3 ' C'*$ > $3' / 9 3 *$9*$ ?7 =%$/'*$% .$$
+7++
=
67 /)- '*$ C
' '*$3 ' -9
= '$ (2')-' $ $ 2$ )- ' 33
$ $ $3 2 '
$ 2'''*$%
'
$3$*$ $3'/% = ..2.- /'$$ $% )5( '
$$$ 2.- =%$/5( ' 2'$$ 5( =.. ' $2(.$
*$ $/3-)
$ 2'
33$. &'* !" '4 . 1(2 $ $# 2'#'(
1(2 '
''$ *> 2 $ E ''$!*$).
E