High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/30669/2020allowed

Ashwani Chopra v. State Of Haryana

2022-04-05Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl9 pages

! !" #"$ %%& ' (

% & )*+ !" ",$- ./+0 ".*" "!"

01.

+$/,/

"2 "$3,4/"+0 5."6 4 /+0 ""*+ 77777

%. " 8 4 **4 $+" 9 "! " :"

* "2 8 4 ' + + 9 $+" ; !":"+ !4 "</,$"$:"

3 <</ "+ 1..$"5 *4 + * .445:"+" =

! " #$% &'( ()*(*(* *) * $ )* +*, - .

/0,,,,

# / ,

'( 2

" #

3 4

4 4 " 1

" # 5 6 #58 -

"" " "

" 4 "4

4 " "

" 9 3

" &

" " /& 4 2,- :"

+ $ 4

" , "

&( / " . " ,9 '((*(* & 4" &( $ 4 9 4

" 4

7(8 4 4 7,%;&<;/,%=,-$8 **(*(* >;2-1? > "+ $4 " . *" .

$83+ .

. *" / "+"$+".&3*42?!"0+'$+

+44 $!"0/< @." """"+ A./ < B5 * +<9@C$"!<B/"D$":.*" +* 4 3$ // ;$83+.

.3. $ 30+"+"+ +<</5 $83+ 8.

4 . *" .

. 3$ .

+ 8 +*+ + $"." 35 3 +.

/."5 2+ 3$

+;""* 84/.. 35$4+ 48+*+$"." $83+.

.*"$ 4."+"+ + <5$4+.5.

. "$4 ** ":""*+ .

+4+*."+" * + $+" E + <1 . / < ."$:. * 4 :"/5..5" F""+ +.

8""++. "+".

3$</9/ ; +</9/9 <;5" +8 * 8482.*"5 "++ : +"> "+$4" .*".

$83+.

4.$:./..

+":..

44:. *"+:8$..

++*+. 3$/5...

+8 + $+" <1 + E . / < + "+" *"0 . 3/..

*"+$+""+."*+ + <@C$"

</* :9 B$83+.

/. 3$5...

+8 +*+ $+" <1 . / <9 / / 9;/ 5.. .:.".

. 3$ 5 +8* 8482.*". "+"+ + <$"."$83+.

.*".

-+ .0:

> "+ $4"*+ </ "$ "3 $8 *"

"F. .

$83+ .

. *" .

-+ . 0:

<9<< +"D$"+"$"."0:

> "+ " $4 ** ": " "*+ .

**+ . *" **4 " * "2 8 4 + .

0.342 $83+.

.*" /.*".4*"*"". "3;** "4: +. 84.3.

+++$+ . !"0+ '$+ "8$ "3 . 3*42 5 :; "2 8$ . 3.

+8+*+338"&!' $ +.

+.$/ 33+ . $+" ; ! $"." $83+ .

*$"$ . "+" * + 82 . $"/ .

3"+"5" 4* +$+"E +<1./ < +. +"+"5"8"$:...$" +5" +."+"+ + < %.$".

. "+.4 "+$4".* " +.

*"$+.""+ *""+"+ +<9* +$+". /< / 3$ // ;5 "D$"+8+*+82. *". .*"/ .

8+."+" + +<</.

. 3$.

8+*+%.*"

+ 4:0 3.

2+ 3$ +;""* 84/ *+$.*"/5$4+ 48+*+ *"$ 4."+"+ + <5$4+.5.

. "+" * + $+" E + <1 . / < "D$"+ . *" +* ++ 4 3$ </9/ ; + </9/9 <; *" . "* + + < @C$" <B @* : 9 "$:B/.*".

++*+. 3$ / / 9;$+" <1 +</9/ ;$+"E./< +.

.$/+*+." 3$5..$4+.

08.

":+ :

. *"/ 4$+: . + : + " * 84 %. *" .

-+.0:

+ *". +. /."D$"+ "$"."0:

%. " 3 " 8 + . +$3 "2 0+ + .$/.$+ 4"":

.*""D$"+ . *" / ." ." $ 5.. + 8 "40+"+ 1..$"/0+"+"+ +<<.

+ C"+ -$"+ $+" 9 "!/ + .

+ +"+ .

"","

4!4/

"2 4 + 05."*. 445: = 78

#$%" @78

4#$%

" +

@78

4+ @ 78

4 ?

%." "/3*4 . 3/. + 05 4+82 . "","

4!4/

"2 / +5 $43 42+.

+8":"+/4$+:9'5..5"":"+ . 8 3*4 "0+ "3 . : 4 !"0+ '$+ 33" @>:

4B/ G 4 / &3*42? !"0+ '$+ ":

"2 ++ 442 0+ "+" + + </ " -( + 0/: 4!"0+'$+33"@>:

4BG 4 &3*42!"0+'$+ ":

H /

"2 5 4+"+ 4 ++ 4 + 0C*4 :." "+4 2 3 . + : + " + 4 3: . * F C*+ 4:.3*4 :

.+ $4" *$"$ . + +" $+ </ .

+ 0 + + < 5 4+ @* : . * *" 8FB !

*.. + 0 ""*"+$+ 845 A( :" 1 #5 ' % 7 84

1 #B/ ,

'( 9 % 5 # ( % 5 - +1 % 5 - +C % 5 % ' % 5 < $

" 4

" 1 #B/ ,

'(7, 8 "

" 4 "

0 "

"1 #5 "0

" "

A , ?

" % 5 4 " , #

7A,? 8

A , ?

% 5

A , ? 3 3

: D

5 *!*(*( ' % 5:" , " : D

% 5 :"

78 , E +,F5+4

0 *)0* 4 ,

78 , E +GF5+4

" "

1 # B / ,

" 1 #5

"4 "

" 4 1 #5

4 " "

:5 #5D

0 0 "

" 4

A1 5? #5

$ ' $

:" H

4 $ 4 " 0% 5 - +C 4 ? 4:5.. + 0/C$"A? +A1?5" 4 4+5..5$4+.5.+ 45."*0 "$: 4 44:

"2 C$"A?:0.+ 4.3*4 4+ $+" ; ! 5. . *4 $." + . C$"/.+ 4.

" !

! #$% ! .

08:0 C$"A1?/.402+ : +"+4 2+ +* .

8 + 4+ + 0 . + .

"/ .

! " &

! .

08+ 4+

*"$ 4 . 80 + 0 544 . "4"

+ 0 4+/ .5 .

."+" * + 82 . $" + 3*4+ 5. +.$" :$. .

. 544 . "+ $."5$4+ F **"*" "+ 5.4 5 " 2 $. + $4 5.. 3 + 5. "* . +* . &3*42!"0+'$+%. 3+ 44" 2$".""+" 05. 3/.*"*" * "28 4 . *" 445+ + . "3 8 4 :"

+ 0+ "+" + + <<3 + 84$

50"/ .: + 80 .

44 8 "$+ 4 C*"*.3". +." 45$4+*"+ +*+42.8"0 3 +.*" 5.. "42 ".*$"* +-$+ :.*"8 4 **4 $ %# ## :$"*"

.."* F:;" + (;

..""*" 84 (;