← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16525/2014dismissed

Roshni v. Union Of India And ORS

2016-02-24Bench- 4,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal4 pages

  

       

   

 



 

  

  

   

  

   

 ! "! #$%& ' (!)*$+%, " -*"! %.(! %.& )!/  )    0

112

 

0



 0

 

 

1 0  0

 

     3

   

 4".!  - !.!.*( "  *)(. 45)  ! 4.6  *6 % 7 5) %  5'

1.)5(  4*  45)  5--*.(! %  5)  5  5)$5+  25,*$"  *(  8  89  &"5(! % ! '-*"5":)!5!$)5(%&"5% *( ;

89<5(% =-." %*(  88  45) ) ">.(&5) 5)$5+25,*$" 5(&'5(4.!! '-*"5":)!5!$)5!! !.' *6.) % 5!

  + 6!, .(%.)4.6 5'.(*")*(5(%5%5$&! "   4".!

- !.!.*( "45)5--*.(! %5)5 5)$5+25,*$"*(7*'-5)).*(5! &"*$(%)



 ".,$(5+" # 7! %! 7+5.'*6! 4".!- !.!.*( "6*"65'.+: - ().*(*(! &"*$(%!5! $+ 9*6!  $+ ) 883'5(%5! ): 5")*6! '-*"5":) ">.7 *65( '-+*: 4*%. %.( 5"( ))6*"! 65'.+:' ', ")!*& !65'.+:- ().*(

!45))$,'.!! %,:+ 5"( %7*$() +5-- 5".(&6*"! 4".!

 - !.!.*( "!5! $+ 9*6 $+ )8834*$+% 5--+:*(+:!*! '-*"5": 5.+45:) ">5(!)4*" !." %*()$- "5(($5!.*( !

.).))$,'.)).*(!5!5)- " $+ ;<?@?5@*6 5.+45: ">.7 ? ().*(@

$+ )  883  !  65'.+:  ' ', ")  *6  5  % 7 5) %  '-+*:  4*  5) 7*'-+ ! %: 5"*67*(!.($*$)) ">.7 .) (!.!+ %!*65'.+:- ().*( > ( *! "4.) 5( '-+*: 4*5)-$!.(3: 5")*67*(!.($*$)) ">.7 4.! ! '-*"5":)!5!$))5++, !" 5! %5!-5"4.!! '-*"5": "5%  '-+*: 5(%! " ,: (!.!+ %!*5++, ( 6.!)5)5" 5%'.)).,+ !* "*$- '-+*: ) *(" &$+5",5).)



2 5"( %7*$() +6*"! " )-*(% (!))$,'.!! %!5!5)- " $+ 9*6!  $+ )8835! '-*"5": '-+*:

)*$+%5> -$!.(: 5")*6) ">.7 6*".)65'.+:!*& !65'.+:- ().*(

!.).)6$"! ")$,'.)).*(!5! $+ ;<*6! 5,*>  $+ )4*$+%(*!5--+:

!*!  '-+*: 4*5> , (577*"% %*(+:! '-*"5":)!5!$)

<

!*"*$&+:- "$) % $+ 95(%;<*6!  5.+45: ">.7 ? ().*(@ $+ )883  " .)(*%.)-$! !*! 657!!5!! $),5(%*6 ! 4".!- !.!.*( "(5' +: 5'1.)5(45)) ">.(&5)5 5)$5+25,*$"

5(&'5(4.!! '-*"5":)!5!$)5!! !.' 4 ( %. %*(  88

6! "% %$7!.(&! + 5>  5%!5A (4.!*$!-5:!  -5"!' (!5) 75+7$+5! %! ! '-*"5":) ">.7 *6 5'1.)5(5)9: 5")5(%9%5:) ( *! "4*"%)4 ( 5'1.)5(%. %.(5"( )) 5%-$!.(9: 5")5(%9 %5:)*6) ">.7  B$ )!.*(.)4 ! "! 65'.+:' ', ")*65! '-*"5": '-+*: 4*5%#$)!-$!.(9: 5")5(%9%5:)*6) ">.7 5(%%. %.( 5"( ))5"  (!.!+ %!*65'.+:- ().*( 

3 

(  *$"  7*().% " %  >. 4  $+  ;<  *6  !  5.+45:   ">.7 ? ().*(@ $+ )8834.++5--+:*(+:!* 5.+45:) ">5(!) (! ".(&" &$+5"

) ">.7 .(5- ().*(5,+  )!5,+.)' (!*(*"56! "  8 (*! "4*"%) ! 4".!- !.!.*( "75((*!7+5.'6*"- ().*(*(! % '.) *6 "$),5(% 4*5%(*! (! " %.(!*" &$+5") ">.7 .(! - ().*(5,+  )!5,+.)' (!*6 ! " )-*(% (!)5!! !.' 4 ( %. %.(! "')*6 $+ ;<

;

)".&!+:-*.(! %*$!,:+ 5"( %7*$() +5-- 5".(&6*"! " )-*(% (!)*(+: $+ 9*6!  $+ )883 4*$+%5--+:!*! ! '-*"5": 5.+45:) ">5(!) )- " $+ 9?@*6!

$+ )8835! '-*"5": 5.+45:) ">5(!4* " !." )*()$- "5(($5!.*(56! "5>.(&" (% " %(*!+ ))!5(: 5")*6 ) ">.7 )5++,  +.&.,+ 6*"&"5(!*6- ().*(5(%.)65'.+:' ', ")6*" 65'.+:- ().*(*(.)% 5!

*$&% 5!*65! '-*"5": 5.+45:) ">5(!

45)(*!)- 7.5++:5%> "! %!*.( $+ 9?@*6!  5.+45: ">.7 ? ().*(@

$+ )8834 4.++5> !*7*()!"$ !5!! " B$." ' (!*6: 5") ) ">.7 6*"! '-*"5": 5.+45:) ">5(!4*" !." )*()$- "5(($5!.*(.) 5--+.75,+ !*! 65'.+:' ', ")4*7+5.'65'.+:- ().*(*(! % 5!*6

5.+45: ">5(!4*%. %.(5"( ))  (*! "4*"%).65! '-*"5":

5.+45:) ">5(!5)-$!.(: 5")*6) ">.7 5!! !.' *6.)" !." ' (! *"5!! !.' 4 ( %. ).(5"( )) .) (!.!+ %!*- ().*(*"*(.) % 5!.)65'.+:.) (!.!+ %!*65'.+:- ().*( 

$+  9?3@  *6  !  5.+45:   ">.7  ? ().*(@  $+ )  883 )- 5A)*6! )7*- *665'.+:- ().*(4.7)5++, &"5(! %!*! 65'.+: ' ', ")*6! ! '-*"5": '-+*: 4*%. %.(5"( ))*(! )5' )75+

 5%'.)).,+ !*65'.+. )*6- "'5( (! 5.+45:) ">5(!) $!5!5(:"5! !

5,*>  $+ 9?3@%* )(*!6*" &*! " B$." %- ".*%6*"& !!.(&65'.+: - ().*(  *(  !  % 5!  *6  5  ! '-*"5":  '-+*:  %$".(&  ) ">.7  5) 7*(! '-+5! %$(% " $+ 9?@

*"5++! ) " 5)*()4 6.(%!5!! " .)(*' ".!.(! 4".! - !.!.*(  " 6*" ! )5' )!5(%)%.)'.)) %   ! "

 #    ,"$5":  ! "

$+5!.

#