← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19071/2013dismissed

Trilok Nath Passey v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2015-08-26Mr. Justice Darshan Singh19 pages

 

      

 !

"# $ %"&'( )#* + # ,



  -(.(

    

 

(/ & (  0)  120

 3 -  

( )  

   

 

   

    !   44444 " 

#  $%  & '

()

 

*( $% 

-  5

"   +  ))

 ,  -./ 0 

1 ,    ! )   



  )(       "2

(   &3"4  )    ( 

  )      #  4   

   ,    - ) # ) 1# "256     &3  +

)(+

 )   

    +

 

  )(     ()       7 

)(

,     

 

/



 8  

  97

()  

  

(  

  $ &  

 

 +   ( 

  ) ) )   #:

 

  ,  - 

) ;  1# "253

(

)  + +   *   (   < )<#( (

 

  

"2::7

=

(+    + )  )    +

(>   )

+

) 



  )  ( 7  

    4?>:>&@<+   ) (   





(+          + /

 )    +

 )      

 =  "2

 A &3"4   )  =  +

+

+ 



)

 &B&3"4  +) 

 

(

 (   4"

 &3"?   

>

 "26: 4 .  

 +

(

  ))

( (   



   +   *    (   )"4

 * )"22? &2

  ) "22:

(

 +  4"

  "222 7=C

)

   "3

  )&33" 

  

   (+

  

 =  ) 

=  

7=C #2-"1

 ,   - 

) ;  1# "253 >

( 

= 

 ,'

5"35&336+



 (

 ?

 &336 

)

 )

  (

, 

 6 )  

  



(

 (   



 

  ) 

 

( 



   

    )    

  7 

)   

 "3

B  &3"4 

 ) 

 ) ( "22"

 ,-.01  ? 7      

  

)  )    

    

 

 

 )  



 "4

( &3"4    )



+

  (     

     

 

 

             0    

(  

 

))



    

 

(   ( 

)



 

   =   

 ,C +

)  # 4-"1- 1

"256   ))

 +

  )     

      )           +  

 4)



 

(

 



    )

= 

) #4-"1-1

#  5 7  +

 ()   

  



+ 8  

  9  ()  +  

(

  / 

+

  D< 8   !

    7    

     &:?&3"&  (  (   +     "?-41      7    -*

< )<# )

 0

1# "26:  

 +

    (

  

 

  C )  

!

  

 

  &::&3"&  +

 

)  )  "6&3&643 46 (= (   

 + 

 @4-"1- 1

 ,    - )   # ) 1  #   "256   

(

 &?

"256 &  )  )   

 

 E), - 7#"2:3 ,,6?41 -, "6?"&33"4,,4&31+

+(

 D<   

 

      +  

 + )    (      



  1 '



    ( 

(  ) 



 )  

   

,)  )

 ) 

  )  4    !

          6  ))

))

  

,   4-"1- 1 

 ,  - ) # ) 1#  "256  +

 

,-./ 1 C  ))

) &?"3"&   =  &>>"4



 +( +

   

 

 



!



   &?256  &22:3  &&?:"   

  !

    7 (     &:?"&   

+   

  E )  ,   

 )

 

  # +  ,))



 

   

 

,  -./ 1  C

        )       



   (  

( @ )  (  

(  

  ,))

 )) )  )  B  (   #   

 



 +

) &3    .

(.%6"

 ".7  '  .%    /.6'  ('    ))  

,))

+



,)

 

(

!      )  ) 

+(  +

)) 

4-"1- 1

 ,  - ) # ) 1# "256D " B  (  , &   #  , 4 

 , >  

      

  ) 

 

 )  )= 

 ) 

   +  

 

+  +( ))  

  )  

)

)

   4-"1-1     ,    - ) # ) 1# "256 * , ( 

# . 7!

">

( &3"4 ,   !

    : 7 

    ( ()   

+ 

) , 8%9% 7.&7%: 3%"7%% &7(; 7#"2:> ,64" 3%".<%%  8&67%0 %;&33"-41,,4"> 2 7 %=.

7%  %7  %((  % &  % 7   7"  (' 0&'% ""'5%/%&%% 7;-"22&1&,,&22

) ,



+( 

( )   )  ( ) D< 8-1

      )    )     

)   7  )    ()     ((    ) 

 -1  





( )  )(





     ( ) )  









! )  -1

    

 

/   )  )   

) 

  

  /   (

'



( , 

, + / )

)

  , 

)  

 





- 1)  -1

    - 1

   F

   +)

= 

( )  G

      -  ! ) -

# +,))



) 1





  

 (  

)

F 

())   )  (

       +      

      

     @

 

     7 ( )    )      (   

 +

( 

   )   

 )   

 () 

)   )

- 

1     -

 )  )     =

    ,  )  

+( 

 + 

(     ))

     )   +  

    ) 

 

    9 "3 7 

5

), 

  



 " &%  3 7%;-"2531&,,>6: "" 7 8&67%0 %

 

, 



 

(     



)

 



 +

+( ) D< 8    +   (   

    

 +

 H    +

 

))  

D

  -1 '



    ( 

(  ) 

  ) 

    -1 C 



  

    

) )( 4""

,  -1 A

 )  



 





  

 

(( 

    

  -

    ) 

   

          (    +(

( 

(

 - .

 ))

  

           - 1    

 

  

  

   ) =+

  )   - 1 7

 + (  )     ) 

   

 

 

  - 1

 

 )   ) 9   

   

      

    

            

            

  

  

        

   



                     

  !

 !  "  #    "              

      

  

   # !$  " "%&'$!%&'("')   "                

  * 

      +

(



 

     "

         

          





   

    $  # ,-    

   .

     

                       



   $) *# $ && '&// "%'  

   "      " " %&0 1                      

   

                        

                 

         

   

  

  

       

  

2       

3         4

  

 

    

 

                                 5 

      

            6   

 

  / !   

           

   

 



    

3   #,-,-  &(/             

              

 *  

+

           

     

    7 



 !"#      

    

      

            

    



  

 





    2

 

 



 ' !  





 

     "                      



   "   



  %



   "   82 

          

      

             :8  "   

  "  

  8    "    ;      <     ":=     "    8    

        

  

   

    '.

 ) 1$  )#

  

  

 

   *7

+  

     

        

      

      

     :

   

             

 



 

 

         

 

             

     

   

 

 

        

  $

      

                   %#,-,- %    



  

   



  

    

             

  

    



        

    



 

   

    

    2

  

 

 



       

  

      



 

       

  " 

2

  

        



  

           

     

   

  

 

 





  ( "

      

          

            



               

      

 

   

           7

 

     4

      

             

 

            





  4

          

 

 33 

        3      

    4

         2

  



2

                4

                         

 



 >   2

  

             



   



    

     

      

     

      

    

      

  



 2      

   

        ? @AA !  +,&$#-!

*  +,&$#-!

". &$!'$!%&>)">&'

+

 <)   

 </     

)   

(   7

   



     

 

  

  

 )



 

  7

  

 )        ()  )



 +

   





  )

  (  

  (

(



  

)    

 4""  



 (+))  ()   +         

  

 ,  +   

 )    

 ') (/ (+

+       (    + +

 

 



   

 7B

   

+    "5"+

   / 

  



(

 

)    I

D< 8

 



                     

  

   



  B                    

 

     =       

 

  

 3  =  

    





      

       "

  

 



       

 

  

           

  C  

                 77

   



  







   







$  2    

 

 

   



         





    

  



%   7  

    

 !

                 

 < D!    

   

      

                 0

    !  

  

     

    



        

       



  

  

      

  

    

 

          2    

  $  #  



     

              3



  !  



                         ;  0,&/>"%>>-  



 

   !"  "

0    

   

  A ! ?  ;     E F!

        0    0 0  

0 

   < 

  0

0       0  

0  D <

    

  0 0D <               09 

0     

   366   ;   0

 

        E 0$     

 

   



             

   

               "  0    0  



     

         

  ,    

2- 

 9      

    

  ,        

2-    

 ,          

2-        6  

    

 30

0 0 0  0

0   0

0     

  



  

     



   0     2          2  



  

   

          

  $      0 

0  

 0  





 

0 $

                           



   



              ?   2   3  

        

  













 



   





 

       



       

$  #F C     

    3  

  

       

 

  

 6            

   

 

  

      

  



    



    



               



!   7 

 

 

       

!          4   

 

  



 

     

   

 

  

  

         

      



   

   







   <              

 

  









   

 G  

         

      

4



   

   





   

 

         

  



     

     6 2

 

   .                    



    

  

 

          3 3       3   3 3     

     

 





  

 2

 

   

  6

3  

     9 

   

 

  <       

  <    

              

                6      

            !         

  

    +,       - "2  (

  )  ,   .<%%  3  .6( +  (+



 

 (  (+)   +

(

  )     

+ 

 ) )  )  

 

  

+



()     



)



)+

  

)) ())  +   +) )  

  

)) +   

 &3  



, 

 

 

) (

 +

+

)

(   



)

 

 

) 

) (

 )

+



   

) )(

)     ) ( )



7

) 

 +

  

     

  )

)



   )       (+

 + ) + 

)  )      0

        )   (  

  

)() / ) 

 (

+ +  +

)



 )) 

  

  3%"7%   37%7=(7.=0(7%;

7#"25""3"" 

 (+

  (/

+

 )  

  ()   +  

       )  ) (

  )  )   

)  C  ) 

()   (( ) 

7



+



  )  )  =

   ( 

 " &% .%.;"224->1,43 -,1 &"  ,     





 ) 

) )) + ))

 (     ! ) +

) 

  )  ((

 +   

 

7

)(     

    

 )   



 +   

     

 +    (

  

 )  +

! ) +

 )  

  

 (<   + ( 66        (   )

   

)( &&    =       +

 

  +  8  9   / ++



    

 

 ) (

  +           +           , ) *

   "&

 .     8    E    E   E  

(

    )   8



G  

(G  ((G  = 9     +  EE   E   

/EE



   

  ) +( E

   EGE (EG E ( EGE = E C/*

 ;  <777/

7)

&33? E  E   

E  E 

 GE   E7 + 

+E  E        ) E  E'

     

) 

   ) (     ( G  8<

E  <(  < )          (          (  

(  

   ) )9 # ) 

E < I +I/ # &33>

)   8   (  (

8  9 8  98     (98  9 )  =  8 = 9 

+

 = )   

+

 ) 

 = 

(

  ' E  

*

    9)  

(    (   

 

                     +

    

 

))    

    +

    

   



))   



 9  ) ( 

+       

(

  

   &4    )  (  



, (

(( +(

 ) 

 + .

)(

    +

 J 



B(K     



+  (   + 



) 

+ 

+

)   )

 +

() )    



+   ))   

 ) E  +

)    

.(



E

)I ( (

 ! )   +



   7   (  ) < 

(

+ 8   9 ( (





(



 

"256 +

  



+  

( ( ) ( 

     

)  (

( (   )   

+ 

) 

   )+  

+  

+(   

 

  &> 

= )  -  18    +  E   E    E)



E 

       

    E 

  

( 

,

  



    

  

     



 ( (

 



 (

( &6 7 )

+ 

,      

 ( + )    )

 )





 7 ) 



)  





 '

 (

7 )  

)

+ /

+

+

))      (

+   + 



  ( 

   

(       )  8   

= 9

7+

  () .





(

( )(  (

8   

        9  7  +     +     



  (    66   

     () 







  )

)) +

) (   

)

  ) (

      

+

#4-"1- 1

  ,  - ) # ) 1# "256  (  +

( )   

)

( ( + /     (

   

  ) (  

 

      

!    

  ! )      4"3   

  ,  0  )  

  ( ( 

! ) 

)) 

 # +,))



 +   + )  

 ) 7  

  

   +



  )     

      

  )           

 

7 = +



   +  

 ( 

 

 ) (

  

))     

)(  (      





  )

   ) &? 7

) 7 

)  )

  )    ) 

 ,     

 

 ) +

/ )  + 

  (   )

    +     

     ">

,  '       

/  

),  89.8%

 " &%5-&33"1&,,4:?



 " &%  % %:.7%8G-"22515,,>?4  

     &5 A

     7 )    )     

 )

 

(

    )

 &: 

( 

+

(





+  +

)  

)) 



 + 

+)

+



( 

 /01234101301315 2 +6 1%  7  8 A