← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1474/2024dismissed

Gyaneshwar And Others v. Ld. Commissioner Gurugram And Others

2024-07-01Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl8 pages

        

 

 !"#$!%&'&"() * *  

         

 



     

  

       

  



    ! "

    #   

  $  %&%'(%()  *   - .

(/012.(%(1   " *      

  "   "     

 "     "       (#%&(%(1 45 .#%6  *

!   

   75

! !  %2'

" (%((          #'%&(%(#  #)#((%(( 45

./  .26  *      8   + 

      +  !     /#9:7; "

(%#/ " *

 !   ( < " "  "

     (  1.





 =

 *   " > $   "    "  "    1 ? #/   

  > /% >  /2 >  )024%.)6 )0&41.'6  >

 (  ?* 1 ? &     

  > #%)'  >  #('& >  )0/4%.26  ?* % ? 2       1 ? #/   

  !    " ! + : + 

        "     * 5        *

  "      "     "    1 "

 8

   

      "  *" "

     "

    * 5  5 .#   8   * !

     * ?       

 

 

  *   (  1    "

          *  

 *  *"   

 :  "     %&%#(%#& 45 .(6       *$   "           !      "     %&%#(%#&   * 5  5 .(    

   (  "    !  "@   

    

 !  4 6 "

       * ?         "

 ! "

   *

    !  .   *  !   

 !  

+ 1

 "

   ) 4 )(6

    "  "       "        

   "

  "        A? < 45 .'6          

     * ! *  

       "

  !   8

  " *$    #/#%(%#& 45 .06   A? <      *$    *$  

  *  

  *   (  1 

     3  !     "

  *            *!      *         *"   

 : *$  A? <   $  !     #'%&(%(# 45 ./6 :  " *  

      *    + !     #)#((%(( 45 .26         * ! *  

 A? <  *    ?  !  !  "    "

 8  "

 * !

          

) : !   " *  

       *    

  !

  !     (#%&(%(1    * !  

   "  A* :  +  *  " 

A* :        (&%2(%(1    

     

 9 *  !  *  ?  )0/ )02 )0&    1 ? #/         * "

    "

* !  *!           

    

 *        "

"  !

 

    "    "

  ! 

 "      " !  (/012 " (%(1    *   + ,  ! $  %&%'(%()   "           "   

 !      * "  8  "

 * !

?     !  "       "

   

 "  "           

  ! 

  

  * "

' :        *" "     "

    (  1   

  ?  )0&9#   ?  )0&9#  * !    "       *   5 .'    A? <  

    *        * 

       ?  )0&9#      

  *  *   (  1     "

,  "

 "   5  .1        "

 

  *   (  1      8   * !

 

  5  .1     *    "

  

    "

       

 *       ! * !     .1)0(. .(%()  =  )#

 (/      +  #'#   8  "

  *

 "

   * 

*      

 

 *    $ "

   

      *

!

 *  

0 - !       "   !    *? <      *     "           " 

   $ "

  + ,          *  !



/ -  

       *     "    *    *!    * !

       "

   

  !

    (#%&(%(1 45 .#%6 4   216 

    "     "   A* :  + 8       (&%2(%(1   * !

     

 9 *  !   *  ?  )0/ )02 )0&     1 ? #/      :    (&%2(%(1 

-   * 5       

    * 

        ! 

    :     *   *    + ,    $  %&%'(%() 7!   5 .# 4  '16 4    "  *" "

  6     *

? *  ""

 

  *  *   (  1        

    * !     * !   (  1 7!    *$    #/#%(%#& 45 .06  A? <     *$  

 " "  

 ! *  *  (  1      "

      * !

  *   "   5  .1 4    *    "

  

  *  (  16    "

  

            *"           

       :     

 *  *     "  ""

  

  *  (  1      "

  

   " 

       *  "      '    !  !   "  ? "

      

  *   (  1

      "

    *   !        $    *  " 

 

   

2 -  

        * !

 ?           

        "      * 5        !          ?   *       "

      !  * !  

 " 

"    !     

 "   45 .(6   * "  !    (

 

 !  4 6 "        *

?      "    " "@  

  *

     * !   .     !   8  

  !

      " "  !  !    (  1 

 !  * !  *

   8   

 " 

      

     * !  !   

 "   

 !  

  ?       

  * 

*     5      *      " 

              %0%/(%(# 4 5  .#6      45 .'6  !    "  

.

* ?      *  

  "@  :   ! *   

      

 "

            8   

 " 

 

 ; 

 5   $     ((0 "

 

 " 8 

    

"  !      *  !

          !  

  ! "

  !      

    & >  !  *!  "        

  "      "    $  *   + ,        *  !  

   

  

 

4*/*/ 0  12/ /   345 6   

  - ?  9A -  * 9A