High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16578/2014dismissed

Mohinder Singh v. Punjab State Power Corpn.Ltd. & ORS.

2018-07-16Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath3 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'( )*%'+#,-%'.* #"%"%'#, /& 0'1!2-"!"#3#,,4,!"%'5%6%"#+!'+"*#,& #&4'+#'"& )(7 5) )(7 5) )(7 5) )(7 5)- 8-8) - 8-8) - 8-8) - 8-8) ,#&#'"( )&!"%'+#,%"8!0,9 +:$!"#9

,"*#4#"%"%'#, ),-!'+*!3!9 +:$!"#9

,"*#,#&4'+#'"& 8-8) 9 8-8) 9 8-8) 9 8-8) 9 *#4#"%"%'#,*!&$*!;;#'.#+"*# %'!;!&&#&&6#'",+#,+!"#+ < 4!&&#+ 2= "*# #40"= *%# '.%'##,9 0'1!2 -"!"# 3#, ,4,!"%'5%6%"#+ %&",%20"%'>-!'$*!,?9&*%!,40,0'+#,-#$"%' "*# ;#$",%$%"= $"9 @ A , &*," B"*# $"7C !'+ "*# ,+#, +!"#+ @ 4!&&#+2="*#!44#;;!"#!0"*,%"=0'+#,-#$"%' "*# $" '2,%# 9"*#4#"%"%'#,*!+2"!%'#+ *,&#43#,$''#$"%' 2#!,%'. @ , %,,%.!"%' %' "*# :%;;!.# !'+,% %11,!' ' @ 9"*#

%$#,& "*#0'1!2-"!"#3#,,4,!"%'5%6%"#+A , &*,"B"*#-57C*#;+!&0,4,%&#$*#$D "*#4,#6%&#& "*#4#"%"%'#,!"

(@)!'+ 0'+"32,#& $$,+%'.""*#4#"%"%'#,9"*#&#$'+2,# 3!& 2#%'. ,0' ' "*# .#'#,!", 20" !$$,+%'. " "*# ,4,!"%'9 "*# 4#"%"%'#,3!& 0'+0&%'."*##;#$",%$%"=0'!0"*,%&#+;=",0'"*#&#$'+ 2,# *0&9 "*# 4,$##+%'.& 0'+#, -#$"%' "*# $" 3#,# %'%"%!"#+ 2#$!0&#2"*"*#6",&3#,#2#%'.,0''"*##;#$",%$%"=!'+"*#$'"#'"%'

"*#4#"%"%'#,"*!""*#&#$'+6",3!&2#%'.,0''.#'#,!",3!&'"

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

,6 "*# &!6# $''#$"%' !'+ "*0& "*# " #;#$",%$%"= 3!& +'#G *#!,.06#'" "*#4#"%"%'#,"*!""*#0'%,'.%'##,%&'" $64#"#'""$'+0$""*#%'&4#$"%'%& '0&#2#$!0&#"*#- 9*!:%'. "*#43#,& 93!&$64#"#'"":%&%"!'+#'H0%,#"*#6!""#,*# !$" ,#6!%'&"*!""*#4#"%"%'#,*!& !%;#+"4,:#',#$,+2# ,#"*#!44#;;!"# !0"*,%"=3%"*!'=D%'+ #:%+#'$#9%',#.!,+""*#0&# .#'#,!", ,"*# 40,4&# ,0''%'."*#&#$'+6",%'"*#&#$'+2,#3*%$*3!& 0'+" *!:#2##',0' ,6"*#&!'$"%'#+;!+'3*%$*"*#"*#,6",3!&2#%'. ,0'

@ *0&%':%#3 "*#!

,#&!%+ !$"&!'+$%,$06&"!'$#&9+'"

%'+!'=,#!&'"%'"#, #,#%'"*%&4#"%"%'!'+"*#&!6#%&*#,#2=+%&6%&&#+ > 8-8) ?

> 8-8) ?

*#"*#,&4#!D%'.I,#!&'#+ ( #&I *#"*#,#4,"!2;# ( #&I