Sangam Packages v. Employees Provident Fund Appellate & ANR.





   
 

   

!"#! $ %$& '"()*$+,-&,.(())/$0&),1$ 2(,     
 
$ $4&56.,+ $1($ $4()4##$6.,+ $1$(,


 

 718$(6($1),1$,$ ,,

6

,

.:&$ 6

, $(+)* $$&!,&$*1",*) ; !"#!

<<7(!=&, 1'-($" !+&$($+1($> $",,$8$($!1 ($1!!,"()*61$0*6($+$,0*'- .   &$&    1  7(!  =&,>  $($6  "(  &1$* ($,,1), .($,!

<<<,1),1($

$"+$,0*'-. .!!$+,0*1 .($,!,,

<<<6($($ $$,(()0 $1.(()).&1$*

 .(())  .&1$*  ))8,  1  ($>  (()    < <<<  , $",,1"$1"(&1$* $ $1 .($,! -$1 .($,!8,&,

,8!1 ($
=&)*6($($ $$,(()60 $1$+8!

&1$*,8)$5,

 /1$ $6($ ($ $$,(()0 $1.(()).&1$* .(()).&1$* 

$",1$,$(, .($,!

 /1&61 ($( ?$,&) $1($&0",17(!

=&,1+"($,1 $"0*(&!81 )&,1$)+)&" 81$&"0$ "()*$$=&$,0",8()7 8 &$1$&0",1($1!!,)* "()*, $,$($+1)* "()*8$8$#!11($,&,&"0$   ,&"    1 .  ($,!    8))    0 $  1 .(()) .&1$*/1"10(($,,#,$ .&1$($,,1),1($1,!!,"()* +, $"17(!=&,>$($7 1($1,!!, "()*1 $"61"8&),1+0$ ),+$& ,&"811$#,$)#!$)),!$8! $ 1*$ << <, << < 6&,$($6-$"

-2!$67"/:

2&$62!$ "()*",&,$ 1(,
""$) '0)1".6,&"$)!' 7.6 <

 1 ,&",),1($1!!,"()*/1$ $6 1  $(,  1+  $$,    1),!  1  ($  1  !!,   "()*
=&)*6($+$,0*'-. $$)$,&) $1$(,&0",1

 7(!=&,1+$,($> $"

<<$$0,

$"10,0*1($$ 1($> $",1 $"

1  0  )),    1  :  1    "()*  8$  !!,  0* 1 ($

$"-$1(&$( +,!'-+$!6($1+ 18  )*   "()*   7  8  &$1$  &0",  1  ,&$!  .

($,!6($1,0($+,,"()(($&* /1" 8&)@,0)1($1!!,)* "()*, "()*A,&! (1*)+$ 8)# ,$61$ $61($1",& $ $811"(&!,$,$ A$,)$,&) $1($ 

<<67(!=&, 1$(,!+ &$($+1($

$",$($10,$8 1) 8$!$($$( )&"$)!&"0$ "()* 8111018"()*65&,80)818$!  "()*,81$ )&,10((),,10 ,0*
"(.&1$*811$ $(()*!

81 )&,/1$ $61$,&0$( $* "()* !!,0*1($7(!=&,1+, ,"

1"()*/1$"1&),1+0",1$($ ,,  

<<   /1$ $6  1  $(,>      0 (,1:1($1,!!,"()*-&$1$ "$)10($,&,:(!1"()*1+0 !!,0*1($,10,0*1($$ 1 ($

$"&(()*! )&,1$)+)&"$(

&"0$ "()*$,,&01:1"1

 ($"1()*,"1 
=&)*60  ,&0$=&$, 0!+1($1:111!!, "()*/1($6($1,($,&,+$&,&")# 18111!!, "()*)*1$),1 ))8!

,&"

  

   !

  

   "!

 #$%&%'(%)
*$%)+$,-

 . /)%, %)(     "*$%) $% )#

0102$%$##/)&-
11 $3%%

%, 4"% ""$$ %$%)&5$#$%%$

%$ $ %# 4
%$ $ %  1&#%%$ $ 1,/  6 " ,01  6  "    2$%    31&(  1$%$  #  /)&  -
11 $  3%% 

%  )*$  1%)*$  1&(1% &$%$ %)&$5%   
    %%  '$  .



 %  4

$#'(%) %%2$7$ %,31&(, /%%8# 
&
)$)'$$%)%%# %)&#5$* %)3/8

%, "*  4

5!9 717(!=&,>$($6"($!8() &,$, 1$*"#$$$$81$ )&,0 ((),()/1

)$=&$,1 ,81)(()*!81 )&,0*1
"(.&1$* 7  "$)8- ?, $"$($+,818 8$&,$81$ )&,"$#/1$ $6
"(.&1$* ), ($+1($1!!,"()*1),($ +$,  0*  '-  . 
=&)*6  1  $,$  ,,  

6

4 

,

+,.:&$ 6

, $, ,))8,  

    !"#$#%&'  !

()**+ 11$(#!;$,

B; 11$2($0)

B;