← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15890/2015dismissed

M/S Majestic Hotels Limited v. Ifci Ltd And ORS

2015-08-04Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Satpal11 pages



    

   

     

  !"#

 $%  !  "#  $

   "# $ $#$## 

   '( #)*+) * #&   (,

' *+) * # ) -  

% !# .

#& /

&

&,0 12+

3, -4*/# 05 67 !*  



, *   

 ,  (   24  # ( ,

8 % 

,  

+

9   ( ,

5  + *  2 #  :# + ;4*

 0  



  0   

  # & - & 5  

)&

% <1=> .

# )&

% 

 3

-,  =2+

3, -<14

# ..& 5 !# .# 

,# # / #  ) /  

 

 * # & - & &&  # #



,

,

 6-  !    / #%  /

#5 >>

?# # 0  &    

 0,

 1>>> ?##*#)

.1/,

#  )

, # ,3,



0

,  )( 

 5: 8;

## ,# !

5

 & # # &    # 

  /  5* # * )     >>>*  6

#,#

 .

)

 

05/

 &,

 053

.# &5 &

?# / .

, ,  <</#  ,

.# 

#,

.# &5 ?# / .

, , )     <<   # 5  1* # & - &  )## #   ) *     %   /  0

    6< 7 , 0 6  @ A   +&

*    5* *     %  %  / 0

 @@ A   %  !&   &  )5  (  , # *  #  5  %   /  0

   +3

 @ A   =/ )  1* , 0"(

@ A A )    % !&  

.#  %   + & #& *#, , &50

 6   > /  % =**1=*-  % *<*>>*>1-   &

& ,    % =*1=*=1- 

 /) * =* 6  #     ,   % >>*>*>*=-   ,   <<  ?#  &,

,  1

,, (  <24#

+ * # & - & ,0  &5    /) *# B, #&  , ,

.#  , /   </  * # 50 &



#& - & / A ) 05 6  , (  <24 # +  /

,  ?# & - &

  #) &   ,   % <   >   <* #, * A

.   &5   % <11   ,  % =1   ,  >  ?# & - &

  #)   # &5   %    <<   #  &5 ,

.  % 1   ,

. # &

   +&

* <  =/) *   

. , % =

 ,   < /

, 05  6      )0   )0 &   # & - & 5#,.##, 

. & #&

% =11=    %  6

,  #    1=2+

3, ->4 /)  6< 7 , 0 6  @ A # . #   0  # 0 % ) 5 ?

0,  05

.  ( ,

8  +&&  0

. 6<=<    1 && * & #& *# 6 #       &5 3&

. # .#5  . 3..  ,   9)  #,.# #   /  &

. 0  # 0% ) 5?

0, *0, 6.

,       

, # ,    6< 7

, 0 6  @ A  # ,   % <   ?# & # . , #    05 /5   /

 &  !C  6 

* /# # /  

    )

. # & - & 5) #

) 5 &  

0 #0 % ) 5?

0, #

  , 06 @ A?#  # & - & 5     &&  (+ 6   , (  1#+ 0 #0% ) 5?

0, C# #   /  &

.  

   /  .

* 6

, #  ?# && / / # /   #  =/ &,0

# ?#  *(+6<1# 0  05#& - & #

. #    =* 0, #  / ,

  <1  

   &

 , #

  A

 *#& - & 5 !C 61*/# #/

)  1*/# 05#?

0, # 0

  #&&  05#& , (  1 #+ 3& 5 ##

#  

 #,    , # #&&

 05#?

0,  

 ,

   # &    # , # &  

 0  # 0 % ) 5 ?

0,    &

.* 0,  3

. #

.#   # & 5 # ,.# -,   )  

=*# #

,   , 

1

.0  

 0* /# #

 &

0  ?#  .,

 # / & )

.  

)  * 0,   &

, , )  #  

  #, (  <24 #+ *#@ A# &  A&



   #   # 

* # * #    

) 

0

 (  #+ 

&

0

.## &,.

 1

 ) ,0   #

 ))  #&      .  0   

 , #5 3, / ##+

% 

,  !& 5

 &, # #),0

#& - & 5# //5&

05& ..50 A #

 ?#  .,    0#  # & - &

 # #  5 A  ,

         ,   

 ,  (   <24  # + * /# #

,   A



#0

,

.#

.#

 05 /5   * 

    

. #

*0,#

0

 & 

.#*/# #

.)

05 (   #+   ?# *#    6 

0

 *

# ), #&

. 

 05 # &  .

 # @ A 0  # 0 % ) ?

0, 

   1 2+

3, -4* 6 -  #

 & &      0 +

 % 

,   !&

@ 



,

6 -@

 !&

( ,  !

   &, # 

   +  , * 

, 0

 / #   ..

. 0A0  % >11    <<  ./ # , 5

 ?# ) 3   # 1  ,

D

/#



&, #

.

 0## ,  #) ,0 #

0

,  ,

 /

.  :(#

 (,#

 E .* 93 , ) 

  *  !   ! ?/ * =* 6# ,  * 6/# >    ##   0 

05     

)5 5 0  &&

 # ? @3*A&#% &  !?/ @   ) #0 

/  0 &?#0 & & / 0     05 <  05 # D6 + ( !  !F* ! !?/ *=*6# ,  * 6/# > =

  #  # 6 +  , *   # 0

 & *  !5



# # 0   .

/ # ## .# 0  G% &  / #

0 

?#



3

05 !/,0

 1  !# 

.# # 

#&

& # & #  0 

*   # &,    0 

.*   

5 ,

,5*/# #/,0 05 # & ,#

5 ! &

.#0 ?# &

& /#B, ## .# &

0 

.*

&/ 0# , 

,0  ,0  H @ &

0

.0) )&

 H +&& )05#!& +,#

5 ! H ?#0 0

  #

) 8* .   #I(% ,&

 #

.   0

.) 0  &0 H !    

.  

# 0  0  0

B, 05 ! H

 # )   #  0

 & )

 &

B,

0 

. &

& 05& #  0 0  * /# B, # # .#  &

 # 0  &

. &  

 5 0    # # .#        # 0  , 0    #

 ! H + 5#  /#  !#  0.

 0 ) # #

   A5 &

   /, 0 & ,

#  ) &  & (%  33 33  ?# / 0 #/

.  

 ?#  6 +  ,     

 

,0

* /# # .

)

#+

3, *  ) 0   ,  .   )

  # +%!

 @  6@   #  !;

 G * # 

 0

, 

#+

3, -0/ +=  5 & #, , .  0 + 5 +%!

@    &

&  ,0  0       0# #  ,   

 /)

 

#0 0 ,0 

,5   #  ,

   )   ?#   #  , 2 4 & 6 + , #0,5  &  #  )   @ ,0  #  0 /0   / # /  33 33F )

. #  

 ,

   # &    .#* / 

 5

# .,

(  <#+  &/

A  ,

    , 

, ,0-   24  ) 0!, 24   &

.#A&



 # 0

,

. #

.#  

 05 /5   *

  

.# 

?# ) (  <24#+   ,

D& '()*+*',-*).(/,0/',*(*-,-33  33 24

  #0

 

# .#

 0 5

, / #

 # &

 &

,0-    24* #

 5 A  ,

         # /

 ,   ) #

0* 5 - 24 A &

  #  

  # 0

,

.#

.#

05/5  *

  

.#

J

204 A )  #  .   # 0,

  # 0

,

.#

.#

05/5  *

  

.#

) ##

.#

05/5  * 

   # 0 3

  5 /#  # ,0   &   # 0,

  # 0

#

5 #0J

)  , # # /# #  . /#*#0,

 &  #0,

) 0*# # A) # .  , #0,

0

/# #

0#

5 0J 2 4 &&

  5 &

 2#  

    #  . 4*   . #  

 #

  /# # #  0  A  )  05 #

J 24

B,

   5   05

 /

.*  &

/##  B,

 5# 

#0

 /# 5 5

, 50 ,#0

*&5#

 , #  #  5 

,

&5# 0F ?#  #  A     ,  ,  24  (  <24#+ */# &,0

#  #

 =* # . 5   ) 5  /# #

 0

3

 05 # 0 % ) 5 ?

0,   !,  24   &

 

(, #

# 





 

&  # 

#0



 

   0/   &

* /#

 #

.  0   5 



 

,   & 5 



, (  #+  &  

8  & 5   

,   & 5 

 B,

 

 

   5 0 A   



,     * (  

 .

.#

.#.

)  

0* #  0  .

8 05 #

 !,

 ! 6>   :'A #

 @ A 

 !) 5 ! -G-  2 5 4  " # ;  ?#!, 0 )#/

  D ?#  .,  # #

  !  @#)

#

0 #+ #

, % 1  0, # ,      # !& 3   % <  % <<     !   %  11 !

   @*

 .

  0 ?# 

  0/

#!& 5  ##



& 

  



,   ?

 (  

)  05   / #  0 ?#

# &&

# #

 # 0

  # 

    #,   #

.#    0 .

 

    #   .

 3 , 05 # 0

 / # #

   0  05 # 

 .

 # 0

 ?# * # , 

 

0  0 ,  0

/# ##!& 5     # ,  #

F

# ,. <

!C 611 < : ( #)"(

%   

'#

 @ A"#

;05

@ ##

!, *#

 0 /  ,   0 &

0

    (   <  # ?



5+ *?#@ #0 ) ,

D?# 

  0

 &

0

    (   <  # ?

 

5 + *  

 #&  , &

, 5& #

# ,  & #

.

0

),  # @

. & 5



&,#

6 

  @

. !& .

 ,  # @

%., + *>>/ ##% )@ A C

0.

/ ##0 )

#5

 # .# !,

# ,.  #!, # &   #

,& #

0 , 50, & )

  # +  ?# !,  #  3

 # & )

#?



5+   *#E,   .# !,  #   # ,.   (,&  !,

&      

                

 !    ?# ) / 

& , 0)*/ 

05#(,& !, C

#   #,. E,  .#!,

) / # (,&  !,  

#  , ,  ?# (,&  !, / 3

. #B,  1C## #E,   .#!, /

.#

#

.#

0 05# 0

   5&

0, #@%+ * >>  

B, 53 ,    

 0 / .KF$$ 33 33 ?#E,  .#!, #  5  # 0) ,.  0,   # & )

  # ?

 

5 +   ) /  # 0) ,.   # (,&  !, *#

005@ A # @ A



&

0 ,  # @

. %.,  + * >> ?# * # # .  # 

  0

 /#5 ) 

F C

##



005

& 

  */# #   # 0 5

.# #0

+ 5

005

/   # 

#   . 0 5#0

?#



 (  2<4#+ 

0, 05#

.# 0   # 

  ?# ) &

  3 05 #

#),  

0#  -  / # # A), 0),#

?#  

# & 5

  5 ,0     # . 0  # 0 % ) 5?

0, */#  # # .

#& /

&

 # 

   0 05 #   @#  

 

&    # # * # *  5   #   #  && , (  1#+ .

# 

&

0 #0% ) 5?

0, *

.



3

#/

,

#

!, .

#

0 05 #   

  

 

  #

/# ##0

 

#) 5 !

B, 5*/ 

 5

#& /

& ?# 



 29+6?EL ?+4 MLE9  2(+E4  MLE9