← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13656/2023dismissed

Mahavir Singh v. Haryana Shehari Vikas Pradhikaran Through Its Chief Administrator And ORS

2023-08-07Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan14 pages

     !"#$#%# &##  ##% #   '(' ' )*

 



') (+') (*' ) '

'

' (' (+' **' (' ( ' ' ++ ( 

,- )+

% %..-+(

  

          

    #/- 0$1 / "2 22#%##1#  0$1 /2"2 # 

3# "

#

      

!     

"   # $%&&'( %&&''$()(&

   

"   # $%&*)*$()(&

 +   

"   # $%&',( %&'&&$()(&

 

   

"   # $%-.,* %-.,/$()(&

 0     

" 01  

"    # $%&.,) %&.// %&.,* %&'.'$()(&

 2    

"

+    

"   # $%&',($()(&

   03!  

"   # $%&&-&$()(&

 4

5 !

 

"   $

     

 

 

"   $   # $%&'&,$()(&

22#%##1#'" %

6     7   

   "  %-    

%&'.'

%-.,* %-.,/ %&&-& %&&'( %&&''

%&.,) %&.,* %&.// %&'&, %&',(

%&'&& %&*)* %&,()"()(&        88

9  5

 "8  

   ! "!"#$ ! 5""5

"

  ""    

  5

 8

" 

8:  

5 8

7 ! 5   5

 

    

" !5  88  (

6

"    !  ";

$  ! ! 5 ":

"(* )'

()(&! 5   5 ;  5  1< %(, .* 0 8$== !":

 /* */ )))>$  6  

!    

  $  

 %/ )% ()(&   "    % && -- ,))>$ 5   5   



  "

  " "  8   5  ! 5 ! 8    

     $     () )* ()(( : $%

&

 

    5    " $   " 5 ;  

1< %(, .* 0 8$==

!     "  %/ )% ()(&       5      5

 ":

    /* '- ,))>$  8 5   ! - ,/ &))>$ =    

 

 8 5 % && -- ,))>$    5 >   " /* '- ,))>  5

 "8 "

 " "8 8

  : $-" 8 

8" , -'

%,)>$! "    () )% ()(& : $.

8    %& &- -,)>$ ! !%)?" 5 8  !

"  "-8  %. !

8  ! $  5      @  @    ).

)'

()(& ! 

  5  < 8 !  ! 8 5

"   !

 "   5

 " "  $   ! "(* )'

()(&  5  5 ;  !":

 /* */ )))>$  -

      

 !     ! 

      5 8         !        5

 88   " 

  :

 "  8   

 !  

 < &%"    () )* ()(( : $%   8 "   " 5 !5 "   

 :

    5    8 !   ! &)"8  " $    "

8       

.

6  "

 5   $ !  5" ! :8   "

 !"  

    =  "!  "    !       !  ":

   

 "

 8    

    " %)?" 8   = = =5 5

;  

  (.

).

()(& "  8   8 5

 5  ).

)'

()(& 

 !   

 < %*" $      8         5!! 

  "8 $ 

)  

> $  !          "  5 

 6  8 "

 " $      8     !

  ! 

  =!

  !    " 

8 5     !       



 !    7  5  $  1  %#  &

'

  $()$*"#$ 

 "#$   (* )/ ()(% 8  

 !    7     +,  -#.*$  /)$#$  "  #$  

 01"

23 $)1$) -#. $ 4$"

/25 '

          8  " %)?" 58     5

 "     

8  

     5

     !           ! 5      "5   5    8       "

8   5

"     

 !      7  56 $#) #""#$

(   2 $*$  "  #$  7'8     ''   "8   7  =!    "

   ;     !  !

 ;    A$ 

  "

5

8   A 2""

'

    !"

  

   7   5   ! ! 5   5  

    " $           5" 7  5

1< %&% ., 0 8$==! 

 ! " % %, *- ,))>$  

 "  5

  )'

%% ()(( ! ! !

  5""

5

 %/ )% ()(& =!" 

  5    5   5

 

"          "  8 " .8 

   "   

 "85     $  

   

  

     

 

!    "



 !    #   $  %   &$%'(    

  

   

     

   

     ) 

  

  &( *    

        + 

     ,       

   !  ##-  

     . 

+   

  

/

 0 &/10(  $ 1      /1           

  

      

   

  

-      



 ,      /10

    



 /10

     

     

 

    ++



 

   .

 

23 .



  #4 

   /10     5    



 0'          $1

   /100   

     

      

    



+ /10  

   

 

     43

              

    

 #6   

 

       

 !       443

  +         

       

 

,  23

   6           #             

   

 

  723     

     8,  9  .  23 

:

*

 5  !   !! !     "  8 !         5!! 

  "8 $   

$  !     8      < &&  "    5  "  " ;  8   " 5 !5  

 "  5 A 2""          

  

:

  !    " 5  5

 

 "

        %)?" 8  

 < %*

 5   5 " " 8    " 5 ! 5  ! 

5 8 

      :

   5  6      " 5!5  5  8 ! &)"   $  

5  5



 !  5    8  "

+          

!"8 8

6 8  " !5

:  5 4 1 "

   '     9 ;    & ( !

 

     7 "  : 

,

6  :   1  0  ; & (

:8    8 " 8    5    !   !

    "

 5 

   !  ""         "            "

5  8 5     "

 5 8 8

    $ #< +)  .  

          

     

 

+                            

  %    +   

 

       .           

 

  )     

  

    



    0 

     

   

  

 =   -

  

.



 5-

  

  

 +  

   5-

  +   

             -

    +   



(

 .     

 

  +     + 

       

        

 

   +  .       >0 

   

         9          

  

      ?  

     .   

            

  

 43

   

  -    *    6&7(  *   @A+

 

   

   5-

  

#4   +   



 

23 

0    

 

        

      *    6&7(         !

 

     

 *  6 *   @A )   B 9 -#3- #3-"#,)-", )1$# ! &(0        +

 "

           "

          

,          !  &( *  >     

       



  &7(4     

 

 

 

*

                   !  &7( *  2   

   

< C55= C5!00=  

 

2    



           

+   

   +     

 

  

 

 5-

  D   4

  

  

  

   -        

           &#(      "

  +                  

 !  &6( &( *  2 &>(                    5  -

    

 

  

       

:

2?         E

 -$ , F 11 , &74#(255A7+ .               B   

  

 "



      

   

       

 . G%   

  

 

 743



  

    

    

   

  

. D  

                           G  5      . + 5    



B #4  0  

  

 +       5         +  % *,'       

   5    E    8   &@A7(  7  55  #62        5         

    

       5    *   8   &744(55>    B&55 >A#+ @( @        

  

 +  

 .                             

 

   

            

       

 

 

   



      

      

     

             

 

   : )  )  )  )  )0       1     H &@7(  7  55  #6  +   

     B&55

>>!

>2+ #( #)))))   

 

8    

 + 



  



 &E 0 8 ?  * &@6@(#55>6(8   +

 

 .    :&



 ())))) #0   

 5  

      +        %*,'    

  

 

 

  +    

    

 .                    

.  

  

  

 743  

   

  8  0       

     

 

   

 +            

. +  

 

   76!2!@    A!!@     

         +         

        -   

            

 :

&



 (  5              

     ,    



 

+ 



      

     

     

     +      , 

    +      

 +  

    

 0 

  

       60       + 

         +   

 

  

  

+         $     ! 

           

  +   

  

  

 

  %        

                 

   +          

  +    +  

 

+



   

     I  5  -

    !        

 +   . :

/

=    

!

  

"      !  

 "    

    "

!   ! 8 ! :8    !    B  ()(& 9 5

()(& ""

5      "     8         " "! "":         5  "  

   >

8    >   > 

   " %  . !5  "    

  

5" %  .     

 !5   5"    6 

 5

  4

  "

   "

   !   5    8      5

 

=    8 "

!!  !

5 !   5     !  ! !""

   

$  "

    

  %)?8   5 "   5 9  5 A

 !

 "  5

  -(   ! 

 "  5  !!  !  "

  !   !  "

       (( )- ()(&     "  (.

==   8  5 

%)

6 9

1 "  )65*

$$#3  "#$ &

45



 5  " "  $  5    8  5       5 5   " 85 8  5

  " !   8 

  

8    $    5

%%

=          8                   "  8         "

  "

       8 5

   !"  

 " !



5  !   5        5"! !"

8 8  5  8"  "8 "        

       "    " 5 !           5

"   "    "

  "

!  5 !   

 8  "  

 ! 5 "5  "   ! ! 5 ""

"

)   !  ":

   "  !     5  !  "    5 

5 8  5     5

  "  " :            "

!   ! 

  

    ! :8       !  "     5

          #  "    5

      !



  8  5  

    "        5

5

8    "   "

 %(

 

 !   8 5   4

5 !

 

"   $

0 <4#3= BC40A )* ), ()(&  AA6+CBAA#<   BC40A #    > 

#   5