← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19121/2013allowed

Jabbar Singh And ORS. v. Union Of India And ORS.

2015-07-23Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh8 pages



      

 

 !"# !$%#& '





! !!$ !$%#& ' 

()*  +,(  - ( (,  .,(   -(,    

     !

"      / 0-12

( %% 34 



$$

%&' ( )*)

+

$ 

, 

$-.   

,

/0 "%&'(  %&'(  $ 1

/2+

/ 

0+3 .

* 4   2+

   *(3  5

   67 

/+  $8 9+ 8 "  

/ '  *        ,

   .    *

0+       $ " ".

$   .     $         

        

$   

 %&'(   "8, #

 

 $$/ /$

#

$ 

  1 8..



$ " +

/*1 $ 3"$

+

 $$/ /$

-, ' #

$ 1'

3  .

+ (( 2+

$   $$/ :



:+  /$

'/;

</$   + #  $4  2+

%$$   1

+ 

.+    (( $$ $$/ . "

#     $ 8 +

*  #  $ .

$$ $$/  $       4%'))(3 $   

. $$.,8  $

 =+/ <+ + .*

0+

  )>"$$ /.

$$ +8,

  ?

 "

/1 .,+ 

"

.*      8 $$ +  "

    "

   3*

0+      .

$ 

..

. +$8   ,8 '' .

+ '    $ $8

81 ,! 

.   

"  .  $   ,8        +  

(((

. "



,$# %$$ 

   /+  . $ .

+ (((   $,8   . .

$

- 

 . 

3 &   $  +

$   

+ 

 



   $ +  $

/$ *(3   

, 1 " 

/ .,8   ++ *  " .

"

 "

 )  *57   @5*  &$&%& 2 !

% !    %#&  21!%   627&!'

% !!%#&

' '%#&

$%#&61 % A57& 

.+ 

  +$$.

  8"+

0 

 "+ .,8 %$$ + 

 

$$  $   ,8

" 3 +, 57 $ //  ,8 . %$$  "8 .



/      8      "  

 %$$ + * ,8. 

 %$$ .

 .  +2+  "+ 

8,$ ""8,"

"+

.,8 +  

 "+

 %$$ 

$$, "+ 

+,

8

. .  +  "2+

,

/ 8 .

$$,0 $+6  + $ , 

.

  "

 "



, $.



"

 .  +# 

+   $

, $ +$0 $+



.

" "2+

,

 8 .

4  2+

%$$ 

 +   2+

!+

$ +  8.

$"1

. 

4  

() 5

 @ () 67.+$ $8  *(3  , $.

 $

. %+  ,+ *(3  * =+/ B

- C,$ +"%+

 

   

;(( %(

$ 

2+  , "

   ,  $

 8  .  + "

  

$ .

1

,

+$"1$  

 ,

"1

/. ,

"

. # $  ,  



 9;



,$

+$



+ 

.

 +

 

* 

"

"+

,8 .

 8

    .

          .   ,$    +  2+    

+   

 $ "    

   .

 ..  + +, 2+ $8



+ ,  + "+



.   "

 .B8  

,  * .

",8  +

  * , 

"+



 +, 2+ .",8  +.+$,

D

1

* ,  

 .+$  ,  

    "

 



$

"+

.+  .

"

    *# 

.



*

 $/

$+

   

$ , + *

$$8 "8 ,

+

   

357     $ $$

 

$$/  +", 

 

/$

  $$/ .

 +

 "

   *  .

 ",8  +      

 $$8+ *,$

 +$ $$/"8 "1 . .

 +

  *

 

  ,$

/

$$/  0 8

         .  ,+    "8  "    1 .    

+, 2+ .

 +

 

  ,$

/ " $$/, 0 8

  . #

 "  $ 1$8    

     

 +$ $.

 

,0 1  1$$  .

 +   "

   *  "8 ,

1 .

" ,+ .

",8   +     "

/ 

       * B8

$

.

*5$7

."

  *



.+$,  , 0 ,8

*  

+  .+$  +$

+

2+$ 8

8"

$/

$+ .     "   ,8    

/   *  #   ,!  $8

/  * .+$,,

 ,8/

0

D .D

* +$"

"

.

 +

;;;  

   *; 0

*5$7

 

+  .+$ ,,$ 1"

"+

8,$   

"        $$.

/  

 

  7 .  ++ ;;; "

  *E

7B8 . "+

0 

 "+ .,8 %$$ + 

$$.

 E

7# "

*

 

 $   ,8 "

357.

.$ 7  #     "

/     $       "1  

 %$$ + *E 5 7#

" .

  .

"



E 7?

$8   ," + * "

 "

,8  

 +   "

 "

 "

*

"

  .     ,

   .

 "

 



$ D $

,/

+

+

+$$ + + $ +

 ,8   +D    $

 , + $ "

*.

$$,/

+  $8" . ,

"

 "

 &  ,$/.

.0



 B,+  "  5 +7     : $ 

 5 +7    +    *   "

 

   $8,"

.

"

  *;

+ 

  ,     "

   "+   

*  ,  $

 8  .  +

   * 

1

, "1 *

 ,

"1

 .

"

6 ( ;

   3 *(3  .

+ ((# $  ..

+ ,8 4  2+

%$$  *# * *(3 .  $,8   3* .

 $

.  ;

. ,  %$$ . 

! 

", ..

+  *  *(3 .  $ "

 "



.

3* 

 +$ , . 

$$.# "+/  

,8 '

0+3



   " 

 "        4   2+

 %$$    1



  1 

 

/$  +

$

  

  .

$.  :/ 0-12

( %% 3;

 1$"& 1304< :

&=# ( %% 3;

."'.

 1$"&