High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14955/2016allowed

Gram Panchayat Mavi Sappan v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2023-05-09Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari9 pages

!" #$%$!&'

(

)' *+ ) , , ,- *+ ) , - + !

"#"$%& '(" )#*& '("" "'+,"& '(" -% " .%& &+"/ ,"0"1+.%& '(" 0%/11& '(" - 2" 3 , ,- ./ #3 1 #450!3&6 5 "%" )"1 " "% " (55-%+"/ 11".##)" 6.1"7(&5895& 6- % %"- - " :% ) (:7& 0% "# "(%"*";"#"/%" 11"."'""& %1" (""1"

%.%""(%%/("##1" "" - "< %16"7&%1"--(1"# %#"$.-" (1""* (&%-"'&%--(&%"%*/ (1" "'"1 0 -%$%""#/ =

%1" 11((( &%.%"' (#"

%" ('1&53>==>>36?<527&"% (1 % (1""* 1- % 1"--& % % "..' %-#1"-- %"."""*""1 /". 552;=>>3& /- % # 11" %* (( &/%.%" #" %=@>==>>A6? <537&%"11""%*&"-"((.%" "*""1& ( "1%' (&"/("#"11*( /*%1" 11((( 6?<527&0%/*" #"1' (% /("# #" % 1"-- & "% /* % 1" 11( (( B

%"#"(%"*"(( &/(#."..' -# %#"$.-?<53&%%"""1 &%.%. '1C53=A8-=>>A/-% % %.%" "0=3>5=>5B6?<5A7&%0 6"7&# %% (&"1 '1#" "(%"*"&+"/&-" + (".%""1"-%&"&/-1 /*% "11"<1"--& % 2

%.%" "0>2>==>596?<5@7& %#" 1&%(#"11""%*"(( % ""1-1 /*%"11"<1"--& % 3

%"/'#" (6?<5@7&"((.% 1"--""1&%"(" "%<"#"(%"*"" %"1 %"."&%"/-% #%0 1 7 &"!0 6836$# $!&!"9 $&% &:0$; $$!& 9

%1" 11((( &%#"$." #"1 ' (&&%1"--&%" - %"#%#&%" % %&1"--%('1&/("#(#11*

(""(" 011 "* (1"# - "* (1""* (& % /(#." %-"'&%/*& (1".%#/'"1 00%'"1 '%1" %" # /(# &&%"'1%"% /-%& "%.%1" &%.%"1" &/(#. "(( %-"'&/*%"#"(%"*"(( %"/' ((1 /("# & & % 1" .& ?%/ <= " ?%/<2&"/("# /-%1" 11((( A

%"/'"/(#.". /*%1" 11((( &-.%1"--&0%" /-%&%1" 11"%*(( &( %.% "0.?<5@&". '("*% ( -.%&1".%1" %(##(.-#% *"58350" &0%%(1#-0%0%-&% 1" /("# ." " : " & % (1# - (1"-(" %-& % * - : /("# 1"* %/"-%"/'& %(#11"%*(( & 0"-%((1& %" %1" /(#. .

" %(1#- (1"-("&" *(#-(=6.7637-:% ) (:& ' 0%- /(# ?"( %"-& % ?.' (( / 1"*.%"%1" & /("#' -(##-%'11"."(( .% '( 1"1*&%11"%*#" "((1 %"%1"--%('1& %&0"/1"' %1" -#%-"11.

! "

#######$ #######$ % #######$ & #######$

! "#

$ %&

&##& '$'& &% ()

%!&% "!0 0 8 #$&5 9 #!&#13%$!& 60 :& <= 9 ;; 11

39!0$= @ %"/". %"-&%"/'#" ((1/*%"11""%*"%(#11*-# % "/'-(/(#( &-#%-"(#&%"'%.%% "/'?"( '-(=6.7637&"(" :% ) (:&%/* /.%1" (/ %(1"-("(1#& -%+"#"/" (( &" %0%%"#/-% -- 1" &/*(%0 :" :'% %"*(".D '(

) " %/E%"*(".D * + + * (

(

,F %&/'1*- . 1" &-"110%%"#/-% -- 1" & #1* E& %( % /(#. ." %"(1"-("(1#" /"1E %"' (/(#" ( %"%*0&"(%& ' 1* -%(##-%'11". %-&( %1"--%('1& %/-%"% (1"# %/--%" (1"&%&/("#(#/% 1"--%& %& (%".%-'.& %" %(1"-("(1#-%"+"#"/" &%

1" /. (/ " *%*0 - %(##-%'11". 0'&%"/'&"/(# ("%1"--&" &0%(%0"/ (%". /*%#&%.% " (-(.' (&"/("#(# %"

%/(#.1"( ( &" &#"$.%"/' 1"*& / /("#(# %-"(#%"% &/-% &0%"1- ". %/- "1.0%%%##/-%'11".*/ *&%#"$ (##%-&#"'1*"1.0%%%1 1"1*1*%"/''&%"/'?"( "'. (1"% -- 1" &01 (#%-" 01 (%1" &%-#/(#."#"/1/ ( / 1" 8 " 1*& % "/' #" (%".

%-&%"/'#" "./*%1" 11"%*& (#11*-#&" &""-#"(#1#<" .-% - - ( =6.7637 - :% ) (:& / #" (#1 ."-%E&%.%/(#.("&& %1"--&("11*"%* '%/-%-&* %" #".(#11* (%". 5>

%" " #"*& % (# 11" %* (( & %" (#11* ' %( 0% - %1" .&0%(%/1* 1"*%"%1"--%('1& /-%& 0". 1"'% 1" &%/*%1"--%('1&%/("#(#11* /" / /("# &-#(1"#.%"%*00%

%"#/-(=6.76'7-:% )(:&'0%- /(# ?"( %"-& % "#"/1 /(# ". % /-%-

! "

#######$ #######$ % #######$ & #######$ - #######$ .!

######## ##########$ ######## ( ############$ ( ########### ( ########## ( ######## , )#( )* , (&

)

()

$((

'& & &%

& ) &(

&% ()

(

) $ ) )#( ) & &

()

() .$* + & 55

%.%"" .-%'-(=6.76'7-:% )(:&"/(#?"( %"/''"1&%"(-% 1" (/ %(1#-0%"

" &%(1#-(1"-("%-&%% /(#. (/ " / *("% ' "1(1'":(( &""/1'%"%*% ("%0 ' "1(1'".- %1" &/ "1'.%"(% (1'". (( =9>5583>1"1*%&% 1"--#"*%"'"' %1" -#%'#% (( 0'&'%"/' (%"..

(-%/-(."(-(=6.76'7-:% )(:% /. "."/1 % 1"--& "% "1 #" (#11* (%". /*%1"--% %"%"%*0 "/1 ("*."1.("1"/1&/'"1.%"%* ' % % 1" & -# % '"1 ( ' % "/' 01 %"' %" 1* 0% % (&0( &%(1#-(1'"-% +"#"/" "0(-%1" &%1".% *":& 583>& "% / %1 . (1'". -%1" 5= (%"/'' (#" " ( &%-& 0" (#11* 1."

11* " - % 1" 11" %* (( &".% /-%&%%/- -%" "'.(1""/'" &'-"#.1*&%/- -%" "'.(1"0""."/1%1"--%('1& /*%#" "-(=6.76370"/" %"#1*" "1.0%& % ' - ( =6.76'7 %-& 1 % 1"--%" ' &%" &%1" /(#. (/ %(1"-("(1#&" *%" ."- %1" " "%<#"$.%#-"11& 0%%"#/-% -- ("11* 1% ( "*. &"(" %( -%" "* '&/(#.

'&%.%(.' (..-%&"% ..'&%"%1" /("# -%/--% (##-%'11".&%"(( .'( 5B (-%"/'" "&%" (%"..

#"(#11* (%". "%"(-%1"--% ('1 %-&0%/%%" "*'"/" (#/ 1* " (+('1* " 1* - "(% %

%-&"(%&/((1 &%"%/-%-( =6.7637-(=6.76'7&0"/". %1"--% ('1&0%"% % 52 #%"G.1*&/(1"" (" %"%1"-- 0". 1"-%1" %-&""/'" &% 1"--0(#11* (1"#.%&1&' %1" &%"0%- ,3<>$%%$!&%!"9 1 0& 6#!3&% 1"!00 %;!&6 &%! &6 52

%.%%1" (1-% /-% ".%"% "0.-#"2=A'G<"<'G&% 1" 0%/*%*/("#"- %".""(%"*"(( & "'"1 1* "0#"&" /*"* (#- 1 0'&'%"/'/#(#11*-"1&"% (*-?(-" (#-1&%.% - #""1*&0%%"*'&%#" ". %"1"*-%"?(1"*(1"67% -- "%' 1*(#%--&""'% 1" -#%/(#.' % (( & %&"1% -#"01 /(#'"1 53 ( % ("1 ( 6"7& (#1" /% % (1"* (1" % - - & " "1 % ?(1"*(1"% %-&0%% -#"0" 1"$ %1'"(1"* -%

" 0%-%""/'" &% %" (#11*"/1/.-%' (/..'%"%" ?(1"*(1"67% -- 1" "% "'"1"/1%#1"1*%#"$.-% -#" 2=A&/*%#'--((( &' - /*"* (#-1&/0%011 -#% '( &0%(%(#11* 1"*&-%"6"7& #"$ % 1" -"11 0% % (1"* - - %-&% "0.-% -#"'"1 $& 1 06 0!"9$% !30 59

"-#"%&%- #%0&" & 0%%"/'/'"&%"#"110 %#. ?<5@&E"% " " % " /*%1" 11((( 6?<527&#"" " "--# 5A "( /, ,- 2 /- + 2

(

$"'.% C%%"$.;" !

; C%%"/1 !

;