High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22286/2012allowed

Surinder Singh Etc. v. Financial Commissioner Punjab And ORS.

2017-05-24Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

!""#$%$&' ()*+ ,-.$&/".,$&01 !1".% "!$!$&".% 2".%-%

$& &#$ 344$%%$&".* "5"&-"* -&6 7 !1".% "%8&/"&!%

!"#$%&'" '& !(#$)*"

."%"&!'

.2$9 %,$&01*/5# !"* .!1"8"!$!$&".%

. !$&/".,1 .4 *//3 -&6 7* .!1",! !"

.,, &"! */5# !"* .."%8&/"&!%)! :::::

'& !(#+

"!$!$&".% %-##"%%.%;$&;$&!"."%!1 . &,$&01*#3 $4$&0 !1"4%"35"%!7"!"& &!% 7$03 &/<&".%$&#"=>* ." 00.$"5"/!1" $48-0&"/./".%*+) &/?>*&&"@-."% ;* ;?

&/ ;>*."%8"#!$5"3(

.2$9 %,$&01*3" .&"/#-&%"3 88" .$&0&7"1 3!1" 8"!$!$&".%%-74$!%!1 !1 . &,$&01*7"$&0!"& &! 7$03 &/<&".*<1 /$"/&?=*1 /&=?%-74$!!"/ & 883$# !$&-&/". ,"#!$&!1" "8%-"& &#( &/0.$#-3!-. 3A &/%#!*=>> .

%1.!B=>>#!C.#&"..$&08.8.$"! .(.$01!%1" ."4"&!$&"/ 883$# !$& 9"8! 8"&/$&0 <$&0 ! !1" #! !1 ! !1" 3 &/<&". 1 / #1 33"&0"/!1"/"#3 . !$&!1"3 &/7"$&0%-.83-% &/!1"4 !!".< %

%-76-/$#"$&!1$%-.!<"5".*5$/"./"./ !"/)?= &&"@-."

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

".4%#!*=+ .%1.!B=+#!C "-.!1".#&!"&/%!1 !!1" -!1.$!$"%<".""&6$&"/-8& & 73$0 !$&! %#".! $&!1"%! !-%#&"..$&0!1"8.8.$"! .(.$01!%"$!1". !!1"8"!$!$&".%.!1"8.$5 !"."%8&/"&!%7(! 9$&0$&!#&%$/". !$&!1" ."5"&-"."#./<1"!1".!1"!"& &#(< %%-7%$%!$&0$&=>.&!*7-!!1" 6 4 7 &/$"%!1"8."5$-%8".$/1 5"7""&! 9"&$&!#&%$/". !$&* 4-#13"%%!1"3$4$! !$&8".$/8.5$/"/-&/".!1"8.5$%$&%,"#!$&> =+#!33!1"%" #!.%<"."."D-$."/!7".";5$%$!"/ &/."/."%%"/ 5$&0 $3"/!/%*!1"$48-0&"/./".% ."&!%-%! $& 73"$&!1""("% 3 < &/ ."."D-$."/!7".";8.7"/

.,, &"! * 3" .&"/ #-&%"3 . ."%8&/"&! %) ! %-74$!%!1 !!1"./".%!1"D- %$;6-/$#$ 3 -!1.$!$"% ."8"."#!3(3"0 3

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

! "

## $ %&' ##(

# ) * #

#( # # ( +,,- * #( ( # # # ## ( # # ) ! . #( ( / 0 1 2 ,3 ##

# # # 4

- # # 4

# ## 5* # # 6# # *

1 ( # !7 # # # (# #( # ##

* # # # 4 * # # 4 ) ! ## # #( ( !7 ( (( ( / 0 # # # # # * ) , (# ( # # - #( # ## #*

# # #

# ( # # ## #*8

, + 4 9 9 # : ( ## *

0 #

)

. ! ## # ( ## 5 #

## # 6 #( # # #( # 9 9 *

; 6 ## : # ( ##( #

# )

# # ( # -

#( ( 6-

# *

" 6

# # 4 4# <

<* , 4 6 # + ## # ## # #

## 4 #: #: * & ! $ 2

1( ( ( # #

= ! $( !

$( ## # # #( ( ## # - ! >

# # ## 6# # # # # ( #-

# ## # 4 ## *

# #

## +## ( ## #( : 6

# -

" # # # # 4 *

? @ # ## ( # +## ## ( # #

! "

== *

& , # # # ##

# # # *

' , # # ##

## *8

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

!!1"1"$.%!1"!"& &!5"&%-7;!"& &!%* %8".=>#! ." 3%8.5$/"/ .$01!!#3 $48.8.$"! (.$01!%& #!* .#&"..$&0!1"8.8.$"! (.$01!%* 33!1" ."4"&!$&"/$%%-"%<"." "D-$."/!7" //."%%"/1" 88. #1!1" -!1.$!$"%*$&4(5$"<*1 / 7""&& ..<*8 D-" &/&!<$/".*4-#13"%%76"#!

"%-3! &!3(* !1" ./".% -&/". #1 33"&0" ." %"!; %$/" 1" 4 !!".$%."4$!!"/7 #9!!1"%%$%! &!33"#!.%!. /"* !$ 3 !.";

8.7" &/.";5$%$!!1"#&!.5".%(9""8$&0$&5$"<!1"7%".5 !$&% &/!1" 8.5$%$&%!1"3 <1"8 .!$"%%1 337" !3$7".!(!! 9" 33!1"83" %$& %-88.!!1"$..$5 3#&!"&!$&% !$%"@8"#!"/!1 !!1"%%$%! &!33"#!.<$33/"#$/"!1"4 !!". $& 4%!8. 04 !$# &/76"#!$5"4 &&".7(! 9$&0$&!#&%$/". !$&!1" ."4"&!$&"/3 <A"!!1$%".!7"4 /"<$!1$& 8".$/-.4&!1% .4!1"/ !"."#"$8!#".!$$"/#8(!1$%./". 1"8 .!$"%*!1.-01!1"$.#-&%"3* ."/$."#!"/! 88" .7"."

!1"%%$%! &!33"#!.%!. /"* !$ 3 &++!8-.%-"!1".$0$& 3 883$# !$&1 . &,$&01 .$!8"!$!$&%! &/% 33<"/ +0-(/ '& ! +1 #$)*"

3 3 24 +5 67 +2

3 3 +: