High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2186/2007disposed of

Shivala Vakya Gram Rania v. Devi Lal & ORS

2017-07-28Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar12 pages

!"# "

"$%&'$'() *&+,-,.,/0,1,2,(&, 33$--,(4 +$1565 "$+&7,-,('4*$15 $53('$(45

1,2) 8!7 !9 1$5$(4)

,:;&1$*1,<,4= 1,- !

"#$%&$''( " #)))$''

*+#,(&,$''

*+#,)-$$'' *+ #-'))$'' ! .

/ ! 1

!2

.

/

/

*

0

0 3 .

! 0

!

1

/!

$ 40 0

!/ ! . / 0

! .

/ ) . ! . /0 !

, 5

/ .

.

.

.'' !/

6

7 '%2')2%,$3!/0/.

/7 /8-, 0

6 / " 9#0 :

; 0 !

0

< 2 6 *# 6 =

!

.

/

0 . !

.

6 /

"

<

: =9

>

;

!/ 0 $82'28&,

/ ? 0 <

: = 9

>

;

9

.8( .

@

; - 7

*

.:

*

.8( .

9$8 ;

0

.,( %

!/ /4

.,( %

.

& 7

!A /

9?

. /" .

;

8-$

! .5

00 .

0 / . /

!/ "

0

!0 0 /0

0

!

1 /

! ! / . /

/!/

!

!2 $82'28&, !

0 1

) - !2

!

A /

9?

. /" .

; 8-$ ./

# )&, '%2')28&(3

0

( 40 . !2 $82'28&,0 .

.,( %

0

0 0

0 3 0 /1

.)(& & "

/

.8- $

6 / # ! 0/

.8- $

0

.

0

% B . .. !/

0 !/

*

/ . .8- $ 6 / 0 . 0

! !

)'2'%28&%

C! !/

6 / 0 .

.8- $ 0

/ .

0

$-2'-28('40

0

D

: E

!

0 8 : !2

0 .C! 1

/8($2 ()

6 / " 0

0

'A !

6 / "

(

!? .* > 8& .

40

!/

* 76 -2$288$ 6 / " 0

*

" 4

*

" .

.

, - ( 4/ ! 8($

!

.

!/

*

" 0

!/* F ! $2'-288, !/

*

" 0

!/ *

,2$288, $ .

!/

. .

*

#82* $&2')288& .

6 /

8&82(' 2 3. !

.8-2$ *

.

.

* #,8880

!/ 0

',2'-2$''4

! !/ )

!

.

. . .0 !

,2:,5 *

#$8- )2 '-288&.

0

.%(2(9 8-2$! ;

$82'28&, /

:

> '%2')28&(0 0 ./

0 !0

. .

!/

B2

! />

*

$82 '(2$'') ! . /

!

. ! :

C . 0 * 0 &2'-2$''( 0 !

:

!/ $82'28&,

'%2')2 8&(

!

1

0 ! 0 . .

:

C . *&+,-,

,7

!

.

! " B22 9

8

! />

; 0 ,2'288( 0

.

"

!/

*

* !

0

!/ * '2288%7

"

0

!/ *

'2'-2$''' "A"0

!/ B *

)2'2$'' 9>

! !/ !2 ,2:,5 *

.

: >

* +

-> . *

#-&2* $,2'288& .

0

.8(2$0 0

'%2')28&( !

$82'28&,9

!

!/ ;

!

1

0

0

0 . . /

.

)'2'82$''$

> . * #8' $22$''$! :

C .40 0

2'2$''->

.

40 " !

!/ * 22$''8 &7

.

> . B229

8

!

/>

; 0 ,2'288(

0

.

> . !/

*

.

* !

0

!/ * '2288%7

"

0

!/ *

'2'-2$''' "A"0

!/ B *

)2'2$'' 9

! !/ 7,%**2,(&(?*$4%

(

0 !/ .

,2@,1,( $4%. .

.8-2$ .

"

.

!

/ 9>

40 / *

* .0

%A !

0

0 0

> !

0 .

G

>0A

*

4

,2'$2$''- ! .

0 0

3 30

87 0 !2

!

0 ! 1 !

".

! / +

!

!/

+

! /

! !/

.

3

!/ "

. *

#$8- )2'-288&30 0 !/

1

D E $ !

2

H"

D E 0

. %(2( ! 2

#)&, '%2')28&( !

$82'28&,

!

1

C! 6 0 0 .

D E ! .

0 .

0

/ 0

.

D E .

.

0

. !/

.

D E.

) 7

D E

#%(8&) .

6 / " 0 $82'28&,0

!/ * D E

9

;

7 !

#)&,0 '%2')28&( 0 0 0 ./

3 ! !

/

/ 0 .

07

!

1

C! 6 0 ! ! 2

/ D E

! !

.

0

D E

.

40!

!

0

2.

! *

*

6F ! !0

!

./ !/4

, A ! .

D E

0

/

.

/

7

/!

.

!/

*

6F ! .

!/

!

7 !

. / !/ 07

/ . /

! ..

!/ 6

%,$7

0

D E!0

/4

$82'28&,

HD E 0 . /

0

/ 0 . /

!

1

- &

*

!/

+

*

D E

1

D E * 0 6 /

!

1

/

*

. D E

!

0

D E

A 0 *

D E ! 0 D E

D E

. /!

*

!/

0 0

!!

1

0

.

1

3 *

#)&,0

'%2')2 8&(0

! / )2'-288&#G

! . !/

0/

0 .

4

40

)$/

0 !/ 4

!/

0 ! ! .

!/ *

0 !/

! 0 ( 0 *

!+

>0 *

D E0

/

/

!

3 0 ./

!7 D E0

1

/

0

H

. ! 0 6 /

*

D E D E ! ! 0 A 0 0 *

D E0

/

0 ,9-;

! /

! 0

)9$;

!> "

7

! ,

! />

4 0 40 . !/ !/ 0 * % .. .

!/ 0 *

D E

!/

*

! !"#

$

"

A

H

.

D E0 . . !

0 D E !

./

! 8 4 .

*

.

*

!

/

D E

D

E

0

/

/

/!/F *

D E

7 ! /

! .D E

6

5 )

! A /

9?

. / " .

; 8-$ D

E ! 0 !/

: * !,;,!,'1&",55631, D

E

DA /

E7 D

! 2G

0 .

! A /

9?

. /" .

; 8-$ .

4 D

E ! 0

0 0!/ . * $

% 0

!A /

9?

. /" .

; 8-$D

E

/ ! !/ 04

H

D E!

4 > * . /

!/

.!/ 0 * . .!/ * . '

!

/ 0

D E.

6

/ &'

()

* $ ""

# +, - 22$''8 /

/

! .!/ /!/ A 0 *

!/

!

! . ! .!/

!

0 * F 0 * .!/ * .

! !4

.!/ * . . !

$# .

!/

)7 0 !

!/ >0 *

!/ *

!/

!

4* 6-0= B !9C 5*,;*,

" +

.H I

+ ! I