Sukhpal v. State Of Haryana And Others

   
         
         
         
      
 
 
 
  

     
 

   
 

   
 

   
 

 

!"#$%&%' )$*%$+,&+

&'*'*(-&+ &+. .

'$'&(/$+0$-$$-,('"&+.

&.#(-,&-'.

       

1

1

1

1 2 %,&&# *-3"&%' 451$*%$+,&+

&'*'*(-&+ &+. .

'$'&(/$+0$-$$-,('"&+.

&.#(-,&-'.

6 7

8 6  
       
6 7

8 6  
       
6 7

8 6  
       
6 7

8 6  
        +&.&-'

+&.&-'

+&.&-'

+&.&-'

6+ +9*-, *-3",9(:$'&/(+'"&#&'*'*(-&+ 6+ *'&." $-,*',,*'*(-$%,9(:$'&&-&+$% $+0$-$ ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;<                                 "*.(+,&+."$%%,*.#(.&(/
*9*%+*' &'*'*(- 
*9*%+*' &'*'*(- 
*9*%+*' &'*'*(- 
*9*%+*' &'*'*(-  (/ (/ (/ (/= !"#$%9  '$'&(/$+0$-$$-,('"&+.>$-,
*9*%+*'

*9*%+*'

*9*%+*'

*9*%+*'

&'*'*(- 1(/ &'*'*(- 1(/ &'*'*(- 1(/ &'*'*(- 1(/ =2 %,&&# *-3" 9  '$'&(/$+0$-$ $-,('"&+.>$.:(??(-*.. &$+*.&.*-@('"'"&.&#&'*'*(-.  "&#&'*'*(-&+.*-'"&.&'A(:(--&:'&,#&'*'*(-.+$*.&$ :"$%%&-3&'('"&(+,&+,$'&, B $'"&?.&%9&.A"&+&@0 A"*%&.&+9*-3$.$*%$+,&+.'"&0"$9&@&&-'+$-./&++&,/+(?
&-'+$%$*%?@$%$'(
&-'+$%$*% (-&#$'



 ) '"$.@&&-$+3 &,(-@&"$%/(/'"&#&'*'*(-&+.'"$' '"&0"$,C(*-&,$'
&-'+$%$*%?@$%$*-&:&?@&+4$-, "$9&@&&-,*.#%$:&,(-%0$/'&+:(?#%&'*(-(/1?(-'".8.'$0 :'*(-*.$%%&3&,'(@&*%%&3$%   9&-#%&$(/,*.:+*?*-$'*(-"$.

@&&-+$*.&,.'$'*-3'"$'('"&+$+,&+.A"("$,@&&-$##(*-'&, $%(-3A*'"'"&#&'*'*(-&+.*-'"&0&$+)"$9&@&&-#&+?*''&, '(:(-'*- &.&+9*-3$'?@$%$*'.&%/, +*-3'"&&-'*+&'&- +&(/ .&+9*:&$-,"$9&-('@&&-'+$-./&++&,  $?&.(/.&9&-. :"$*% $+,&+."$9&@&&-/ +-*."&,*-#$+$(/'"&A+*'#&'*'*(- '*.

/ +'"&+. @?*''&,'"$' #&'*'*(-&+ !"#$%=*-
*9*%+*' &'*'*(-

(/> "$,&$+%*&+$##+($:"&,'"*.
( +'@0/*%*-3
*9*%+*' &'*'*(- )45(/ *!&A*.&#&'*'*(-&+2 %,&&#

*-3"  =*- 
*9*%  +*'  &'*'*(-  1  (/  >   "$,  &$+%*&+ $##+($:"&, '"*.
( +'@0/*%*-3 
*9*%+*' &'*'*(- )4 (/    ('"  A+*'  #&'*'*(-.  A&+&  ,*.#(.&,  (/  9*,&  (+,&+  ,$'&,   :$%%*-3  #(-'"&+&.#(-,&-'7 '"(+*'*&.'('+&$''"& #&'*'*(-.$.+&#+&.&-'$'*(-.$-,'$!&$/*-$%9*&A(-'"&.$?& "&  *+&:'(+  &-&+$%  +*.(-.  $+0$-$7+&.#(-,&-'

"$.#$..&,$-(+,&+,$'&, --&D +& A"&+&@0 '"&  :%$*?  (/  '"&  #&'*'*(-&+.  .&&!*-3  +&7:(-.*,&+$'*(-  (/  '"&*+ '+$-./&+"$.$%.(@&&-+&C&:'&,  9&-. :"(+,&+,$'&,  $'--&D +& "$.@&&-$..$*%&,*-'"&*-.'$-'#&'*'*(-  $9*-3  "&$+,  %&$+-&,  :( -.&%  /(+  '"&  #&'*'*(-&+.  $' %&-3'"  '"*. 
( +'  *. (/  '"&  :(-.*,&+&,  9*&A '"$'  -(  @$.*.  /(+ *-'&+/&+&-:&*.?$,&( '

 +$-./&+*.$-*-:*,&-:&(/.&+9*:& -(+,&+(/'+$-./&+ A( %,@&(#&-'(*-'&+/&+&-:&(-%0*/*'*.,&?(-.'+$'&,'"$''"&

) '+$-./&+"$.@&&-,*+&:'&,@0$-$ '"(+*'0A"(,*,-('"$9&'"& C +*.,*:'*(-'(,(.(E(+'"&.$?&*.*-9*(%$'*(-(/.(?&.'$' '(+0 #+(9*.*(-(+"$9*-3@&&-#$..&,A*'"$?$%$/*,&*-'&-' &+ .$%  (/  '"&  *?# 3-&,  (+,&+  ,$'&,     $'

--&D +& #$..&,@0+&.#(-,&-' +&C&:'*-3'"&:%$*?(/'"& #&'*'*(-&+.  .&&!*-3  +&7:(-.*,&+$'*(-  $.  +&3$+,.  '"&*+  '+$-./&+ A( %,."(A'"$''"&#&'*'*(-&+.A&+&$##(*-'&,$.$*%$+,&+ $-,"$,C(*-&,(-1 ) -'"&*+'('$%)0&$+.(/.&+9*:& '"&0"$9&+&?$*-&,#(.'&,$'
&-'+$%$*%?@$%$/(+-&$+%0 0&$+.

 $+$)(/'"& -C$@$*%6$- $%$.$##%*:$@%&'( '$'&(/ $+0$-$+&$,.$. -,&+

F) 
(-,*'*(-.$.'('"&$*%'(A"*:"#(.'&,

(A$+,&+."$%%@&#(.'&,'($C$*%*-"*."(?&,*.'+*:' -(+  $  C$*%  *-  $  ,*.'+*:'  *-  A"*:"  "&  "$.  @&&-  %(-3 +&.*,&-'

  (  A$+,&+  ."$%%  (+,*-$+*%0  @&  $%%(A&,  '( +&?$*-$'$
&-'+$%C$*%(+$'$/*+.'(+$.&:(-,:%$.. *.'+*:'$*%/(+?(+&'"$-/*9&0&$+.-(+$'$'"*+,(+ /( +'":%$..*.'+*:'$*%/(+?(+&'"$-'"+&&0&$+.-(+ $'$. @.*,*$+0C$*%/(+?(+&'"$-(-&$-,$"$%/0&$+.
%&$+%0'"&'+$-./&+(/'"&#&'*'*(-&+./+(?
&-'+$%$*% ?@$%$'(
&-'+$%$*% (-&#$'*.C .'*/*$@%&(-'"&.'+&-3'"(/ #$+$)(/'"& -C$@$*%6$- $% "$'$#$+'*-'"&(+,&+,$'&, #$..&,@0 +&.#(-,&-' *-'"&:$.&(/2 %,&&# *-3"#&'*'*(-&+*-
*9*% +*' &'*'*(- 1(/*'"$.@&&-(@.&+9&,'"$''"&+& "$9&@&&-:(?#%$*-'.$3$*-.''"&#&'*'*(-&+$.+&3$+,.*-, %3*-3 *-$:'*9*'*&.(/. ##%0*-3,+ 3.$-,?(@*%&.'('"&*-?$'&.$-,"&

@&*-3$+&.*,&-'(/-&$+@09*%%$3&"(%*.'+*:'2 + !."&'+$A"*:" *.!?.

/+(?
&-'+$%$*%?@$%$  -,&+  . :"  :*+: ?.'$-:&.  '"&  :(?#&'&-'  $ '"(+*'0 "$.'$!&-$,&:*.*(-'('+$-./&+'"&#&'*'*(-&+./+(??@$%$'(

(-&#$'

"&.$?&A( %,-(':$%%/(+$-0*-'&+9&-'*(-  .+&3$+,.'"&*-.'$-:&./ +-*."&,@0'"&#&'*'*(-&+. *-#$+$(/'"&#&'*'*(-(/('"&+$+,&+."$9*-3@&&-+&'$*-&,$'
&-'+$%$*%?@$%$(9&+$:(-.*,&+$@%&%&-3'"(/'*?&'"*.
( +' "$,  ,*+&:'&,  %&$+-&,  '$'&  :( -.&%  (-  5   '(  :(?#%&'& *-.'+ :'*(-.  $-,  '"&  ?$''&+  "$,  @&&-  #(.'&,  /(+  '(,$0  * &     +*-3'"&:( +.&(/"&$+*-3'(,$06+ *'&." $-,*'

,,*'*(-$%,9(:$'&&-&+$%$+0$-$(-*-.'+ :'*(-./+(?6+ 

*%%       (//*:&  (/  *+&:'(+  &-&+$%  +*.(-.  $+0$-$  "$. ?$,&$.'$'&?&-''"$''"&?$''&+A*'"+&3$+,'('+$-./&+(/('"&+ $*%$+,&+./+(?
&-'+$%$*%?@$%$$-,A"("$9&@&&-.&+9*-3 '"&+&  .*-:&  '"&*+  *-*'*$%  ,$'&  (/  $##(*-'?&-'  *.  -,&+  $:'*9& :(-.*,&+$'*(-  $-,  -&:&..$+0  (+,&+.  A( %,  @&  *.. &,  A*'"*-  $ #&+*(,(//( +A&&!.

) -  '"&  '('$%*'0  (/  :*+: ?.'$-:&.  -(  @$.*.  /(+ *-'&+/&+&-:&*-'"&'+$-./&+(+,&+.(/'"&#&'*'*(-&+.*.?$,&( ' 4 ('"'"&#&'*'*(-.$+&,*.?*..&, =       > =       > =       > =       >             







6

6

6

6

('&

('&

('&

('&

"&'"&+.#&$!*-3H+&$.(-&,I "&'"&+.#&$!*-3H+&$.(-&,I "&'"&+.#&$!*-3H+&$.(-&,I "&'"&+.#&$!*-3H+&$.(-&,I

&.H

&.H

&.H

&.H "&'"&++&/&++&,'(&#(+'&+I "&'"&++&/&++&,'(&#(+'&+I "&'"&++&/&++&,'(&#(+'&+I "&'"&++&/&++&,'(&#(+'&+I

&.H

&.H

&.H

&.H