← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11495/2017allowed

Satyanarain And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2020-02-05Mrs. Justice Raj Rahul Garg7 pages



        

 

 !

"#$#%& '

'

(

) % * #% %! + *$ '''

# #% *,$- ./$'

(

  *) %  %! + *$ ''' $0%!

% ,$- 1& 231('(   '



     

    

 



                !"

  #"  $% $& '$()*+",- ,%./  #  / $( ($ '$$0" *+",(.

 

1 2

( '/  /   2

0/    3 /     #   1           /  

# 3   1  " " 4 "  / / 

 &$53  /    1  /  3       2

 (    0      #         " "

1   ",   

       

   

   

     1   "  2

'/          #  3  /

  6,7(&,'$$)  /  / #3  " ('

$( '$$) 4,($%(7,'$$)  3   # /  # () ($ '$$%

1 2

' " /  3 " 8/ '9 $- '$(- 1  

 "3

6,%9%-, '$(&     "            /    # 

"

#

  # 1/ /   (0 $'

'$$)       #  "         

/ 

0  #    $% $& '$() *+",- ,%.  "  /  0$ $9 '$$0/ "   3 

3 4 " 

1          

#   $( ($ '$$0*+" ,(. /  /   4 "  "    "  $( ($ '$$0*+",(.

:            /   #    3    2

( 0 3 1     #    $% $& '$()*+",- , %.  "  /  0$ $9 '$$0 " / "     

4 1  / #   /  0$ $9 '$$03    1 

 3 3  "  

!"

#$%& ' ()*++ (!

&  " 3 3  3 4 " #

3 #  #       3      # 6                 3  #   

"# 3  ",-, 

&+.

'

+/!

+ (!

&$%& ' ()*++ (!

& *+",9.   3     ;/  3  "   3  "    3  /     /  / 3 /         <"= #3 "    /  #

    3 3

>3 "# " 0+ +& + +(!

$%& 123(* % (4+/ +()5+ +(!

 '$(7*'.1'07 ; 07 "# " 3 ", ?07 : #  "  / "# "  /    /    3 3 "  "      4 "   "  / "           "  3 "    " 

  /  @  @#  /       "#3    

<"    3"   "    / "  3  ##3   ;      "#    " "  



3  "#3 "3 "   

# " 3  

   /    #      (7       "

<"  "      / "     3    /   /    #3 !"#  !" "#"

/ /       "     #   "

  /  #   "   3    #

    "   #  # 

/ /  #!" /  

 ;" @4 "   "         /  #   "  " #

3 " / ,"   /  / " # "   "# !"

#"  / " 3         (7       "   1"   ;"   "    / "  3      !"

  3

" (7    "     "# "  '!

(0 + 0/+ (!

&$%& ' ()

&!+ (!

&/    / /#

#  ""(990

1  /   "

3  (99-   '$$$ / " #

 ##"#

  1  '& $) '$$- / "

# #

/  #$( $( '$$'

1

  " 3" B"  "#/  "

1=    #  1   '$(7/#  1"# "/  "#  '

6 * ' ()7+ + (!

&$%&

2

+ (!

&  9'   3

      (990        #  # "            3  ;/   3  

 

# 1"# "  "#   "   /   " #3"   #/   3 /    "3" 8 1 2

"#  #

# "33  #   3 3  



 "3 3

    2

"#   /       3    3  #   #   3  1  3  " / "

#    +   #/ "

 

 3 "   

  " 3      3 1 !"

  #!"



!"    3 / 3 

1"# "  3 ", ?1  2:

&"3 3 

      

  3    "    #@ "  6"  3   2:

&"3   3##"    3 / "3  ; 3" 

  " 8 "#3   1   3   "      / "

# "  /  3 

(7(- /07*(.*.  "

  ;             "      :

'

0 8 + (+()+

;(9%0(0$  #    ;

  +    #  /    "

    

    3

5 "      3" 3      3 1      "     

 /   1  !"

  #!"

 !"    3 /

3 

1   ## " 3 3" !"

" "      6 

  3   ##  2:

&"3 1"#  #  "

/ 2:

&"3 3# 3 "/   " "#

#/

3   '$$- 1 "# '!

(0 +0/;&6& &"3 3 /3 "# " 33 0(& -,-()- #+ &!7"24 &!+ (!

&$%& ' ()

&!+

(!

&  ;   /  (999,'$$( 0#  #/ + ## #   #/ " '$$( #  ;;;#

/    /  3   "//"33  ; 3" /        / 3   ""

     #  / / "  "    1    /   "#                    /   /  /  

# ('  1 ##" #   =B" ## " ('

$) '$('

1 =B"  " 8  

$9 (( '$('   "3" 8/ $( $- '$('

/" =B" "" 

(- $% '$(7/ "   "   

    3   "/3  3  #  3        (7 $9 '$()       $9 $) '$(%=   #   1"#  "/ / "# '!

(0 +;&6& &"3 /       3 

"#  2:

;&6& &"3 /  # # "  " " #

 /    #  ($ 

<         "        /    #  #  

"            "        $( ($ '$$0 *+",(.

   !  !"  "#   /

 3   " 8   #   $( ($ '$$0*+",'./ !" 3 /-5       /#  #     

 "3 #  

,  - 

'

'

#6) %$+# +

+ *$0

7#%8/*

$% !

&  $/

+

+ ** 0*

9:

&  $/